Tested by Ben Trapskin | Deep Dive into the Original vs. Pillow Top Models
🏆 Test It In San Diego
San Diego Magazine voted us Best Mattress Store for 2024 and 2025. Visit our 5,400 sq ft showroom at 1441 Encinitas Blvd. You can try the full Brooklyn Bedding line. We offer wholesale prices that beat online deals.
📞 Call or Text (858) 232-5760Tested by Ben: The Bottom Line
I test hundreds of beds. Many mattresses under $1,000 have weak support. The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is different. They own their factory in Arizona. This cuts out the middleman and keeps costs low.
You get a high-end, American-made bed for a great price. Both the standard and Pillow Top models use durable coils. It is a top choice for shoppers who want quality without overpaying.
Performance Ratings & Scores
We use strict tests to see how this bed performs. Here is how the Signature Hybrid scored in our lab.
Sleeper Profile: Who Is It Best For?
Firmness depends on your weight and how you sleep. The Signature Hybrid comes in Soft, Medium, and Firm. Use this guide to find your match.
| Sleep Position | Lightweight (< 130 lbs) | Average (130 - 230 lbs) | Heavyweight (230+ lbs) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Side Sleepers | Soft | Medium (Get the Pillow Top) | Medium or Firm |
| Back Sleepers | Medium | Medium or Firm | Firm |
| Stomach Sleepers | Medium | Firm | Firm |
Original vs. Pillow Top: Which Should You Buy?
There are two versions of this mattress. Both offer three firmness levels. Their height and feel are different.
The Original Signature Hybrid
This bed is 11.5 inches tall. It has a quilted top and bouncy TitanFlex™ foam. It feels responsive and is easy to move on. It is great for people who change positions at night.
The Signature Pillow Top (Upgrade)
This model is 13.25 inches tall. It adds a plush Cloud Pillow Top. This provides better pressure relief for hips and shoulders. It feels like a luxury hotel bed. Side sleepers should choose this upgrade.
Long-Term Durability: My 3-Year Opinion
I have owned the standard Signature Hybrid for three years. It stays in our guest room. My son Isaac jumps and wrestles on it often. I also slept on the Pillow Top version for six months.
The Verdict: The Ascension® coils are very strong. I see no sagging in the middle of the bed. The edge support is good for sleeping. It might dip slightly if you sit on the very corner. Overall, the quality is much higher than the price suggests.
Pricing & Spec Comparison
Compare the two models below. Prices are for a Queen size before discounts.
| Feature | Original Signature Hybrid | Signature Pillow Top |
|---|---|---|
| Queen Price (MSRP) | ~$1,332 | ~$1,732 |
| Yawnder Deal | Use code YAWNDER25 for 25%+ Off | Use code YAWNDER25 for 25%+ Off |
| Profile Height | 11.5 Inches | 13.25 Inches |
| Cover / Top Layer | Premium Quilted Top | Plush Cloud Pillow Top |
| Comfort Foam | 1.5" TitanFlex™ Foam | 1.5" TitanFlex™ Foam |
| Support Core | 8" Ascension® Encased Coils | 8" Ascension® Encased Coils |
🤓 The Geeky Stuff: Inside the Mattress
The materials inside this bed are high quality. They are built to last and perform well.
TitanFlex™ Comfort Foam
This bed uses TitanFlex™ foam. It is better than memory foam because it does not trap heat. It contours to your body but bounces back fast. You will not feel stuck when you try to roll over.
Ascension® Coil Core & Edge Support
The bed has up to 961 coils. Each coil is wrapped in fabric. This stops motion from moving across the bed. Strong coils around the edges keep you feeling safe near the side.
Bounce & Motion Transfer Test
A good bed should stop you from feeling a partner move. It should also have some bounce. We tested how this mattress handles movement.
The Sinkage Lab Test
We used a 14 lb ball to see how much the Medium model sinks.
This is perfect for a Medium feel. The top layers cushion your body, but the coils keep you supported.
Company Policies: Warranty, Shipping, and Trial
🚚 Free Shipping
Shipping is free in the contiguous US. The bed arrives in a box at your door. We also offer setup help in San Diego.
🌙 120-Night Trial
You can test the bed at home for four months. If you do not like it, returns are free and easy.
🛡️ 10-Year Warranty
The 10-year warranty covers defects. It also covers sagging that is deeper than 1 inch.
🗣️ What People Are Saying
Pros & Cons
✅ The Good
- Great Price: Buying from the factory saves you money.
- Options: Choose from three firmness levels and two heights.
- Easy Movement: The foam reacts fast so you don't feel stuck.
- Made in USA: Built in Phoenix, Arizona.
❌ The Bad
- Edge Support: The Original model is good, but not the firmest.
- Simple Look: The standard model looks basic. The Pillow Top looks much better.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a box spring?
Does it sleep hot?
How long does it take to expand?
Can I try it in person?
Use code YAWNDER25 for the best discount at checkout.