Tested by Ben Trapskin | Deep Dive into the Original vs. Pillow Top Models
🏆 Test It In San Diego
Voted Best Mattress Store by San Diego Magazine (2024 & 2025). Come try the entire Brooklyn Bedding lineup at our 5,400 sq ft showroom at 1441 Encinitas Blvd. We guarantee wholesale pricing that beats buying online.
📞 Call or Text (858) 232-5760Tested by Ben: The Bottom Line
Let’s cut to the chase. Running Yawnder involves a lot of moving parts, and I need serious physical recovery at night to keep things running smoothly. I test hundreds of beds, and I can tell you straight up that most mattresses under $1,000 cut corners where it hurts: the core support.
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is the rare exception. Because Brooklyn Bedding owns their own factory in Arizona, they eliminate the middleman. They offer an American-made, high-end hybrid for a fraction of what you'd pay at a big-box store. Whether you choose the standard model or upgrade to the Pillow Top, it hits the sweet spot for high-intent shoppers who want lasting coil durability without getting gouged.
Performance Ratings & Scores
To outpace generic reviews, we break down exactly how this bed performs across strict testing categories. Here is how the Signature Hybrid stacks up.
Sleeper Profile: Who Is It Best For?
Mattress firmness is entirely subjective based on your body weight and primary sleeping position. The Signature Hybrid comes in Soft, Medium, and Firm. Here is the straight talk on who should buy what.
| Sleep Position | Lightweight (< 130 lbs) | Average (130 - 230 lbs) | Heavyweight (230+ lbs) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Side Sleepers | Soft | Medium (Get the Pillow Top) | Medium or Firm |
| Back Sleepers | Medium | Medium or Firm | Firm |
| Stomach Sleepers | Medium | Firm | Firm |
Original vs. Pillow Top: Which Should You Buy?
Brooklyn Bedding now offers the Signature Hybrid in two distinct variations. Both come in Soft, Medium, and Firm, but the construction differences dictate the final feel and price.
The Original Signature Hybrid
This is the classic 11.5" disruptor. It features a quilted top with TitanFlex™ foam directly underneath. It has a slightly tighter, more responsive feel. It's fantastic for combination sleepers who need to move around easily without feeling "stuck" in deep foam.
The Signature Pillow Top (Upgrade)
This beefs the mattress up to 13.25" with a plush Cloud Pillow Top sewn onto the surface. It provides deeper pressure relief for your hips and shoulders and gives the bed a true "luxury hotel" aesthetic and feel. If you are strictly a side sleeper, the upgrade is worth every penny.
Long-Term Durability: My 3-Year Opinion
I don't just sleep on a bed for a week and push out a review. As a business owner balancing operations, marketing, and a busy family life, my body is highly sensitive to drops in sleep quality.
We’ve had the standard Signature Hybrid Medium in our guest room for three years now, and my son Isaac has put it through the wringer—jumping on it, wrestling, you name it. I've also personally slept on the upgraded Pillow Top version for over six months.
The Verdict on Durability: The Ascension® coils have held up remarkably well. There is zero noticeable "hammocking" or sagging in the middle third of the bed where the heaviest parts of the body rest. The edge support is decent—not as rigidly firm as the Plank, so you might notice a little dip if you sit right on the corner to tie your shoes—but for sleeping, the structural integrity of this bed easily outpaces its price tag. It continues to provide the restorative sleep I need to keep my focus sharp and Yawnder running.
Pricing & Spec Comparison
Here is a breakdown of how the two models compare. Note: Prices reflect standard Queen MSRP before our exclusive Yawnder discount is applied.
| Feature | Original Signature Hybrid | Signature Pillow Top |
|---|---|---|
| Queen Price (MSRP) | ~$1,332 | ~$1,732 |
| Yawnder Deal | Use code YAWNDER25 for 25%+ Off | Use code YAWNDER25 for 25%+ Off |
| Profile Height | 11.5 Inches | 13.25 Inches |
| Cover / Top Layer | Premium Quilted Top | Plush Cloud Pillow Top |
| Comfort Foam | 1.5" TitanFlex™ Foam | 1.5" TitanFlex™ Foam |
| Support Core | 8" Ascension® Encased Coils | 8" Ascension® Encased Coils |
🤓 The Geeky Stuff: Inside the Mattress
Don't let the approachable price tag fool you. The materials under the hood are built to perform.
TitanFlex™ Comfort Foam (Near-Instant Response Time)
Instead of generic memory foam (which sleeps hot and traps you) or latex (which is bouncy but expensive), they use proprietary TitanFlex™. It contours beautifully for pressure relief, but bounces back instantly. You won't feel stuck struggling to roll over, which is a major win for combination sleepers.
Ascension® Coil Core & Edge Support
The engine of the bed consists of up to 961 individually encased coils. They are decoupled to minimize motion transfer. While the edge support won't rival a dedicated heavy-duty mattress, the reinforced perimeter coils keep you feeling secure when sleeping close to the edge of the bed.
Bounce & Motion Transfer Test
Sleep disruptions are the enemy of recovery. A mattress needs to absorb the shock of a restless partner without feeling dead and motionless. We tested exactly how the Brooklyn Bedding Signature handles movement.
The Sinkage Lab Test
We used a 14 lb bowling ball to visualize the pressure relief capabilities on the standard Medium model.
This is ideal for a "Medium" feel. Notice how the weight compresses the top layers deeply for pressure relief, but stops before bottoming out.
Company Policies: Warranty, Shipping, and Trial
🚚 Free Shipping
Mattresses ship free within the contiguous US in a box straight to your door. White glove delivery options are available locally from our showroom.
🌙 120-Night Trial
You get roughly four months to sleep on the mattress in your own home. If it doesn't work out, returns are free and hassle-free.
🛡️ 10-Year Warranty
Backed by a robust 10-year warranty covering manufacturing defects and abnormal sagging above 1 inch.
🗣️ What People Are Saying
Pros & Cons
✅ The Good
- Unbeatable Value: Factory-direct pricing cuts out the middleman entirely.
- Customizable: Three firmness options and two height/feel choices (Original vs. Pillow Top).
- Fast Response Time: TitanFlex foam contours without making you feel trapped.
- USA Made: Manufactured directly in their state-of-the-art Phoenix, AZ facility.
❌ The Bad
- Edge Support (Original): Decent, but not as rock-solid as the ultra-firm Plank model.
- Basic Looks (Original): The standard model looks simple, though the Pillow Top upgrade fixes this entirely.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a box spring with the Signature Hybrid?
Does the Brooklyn Bedding Signature sleep hot?
How long does it take to expand and off-gas?
Can I try it in person before buying?
Use code YAWNDER25 for the best discount at checkout.