Shifman Mattress Review: Top 10 Luxury Pros & Cons in 2024

For over a century, Shifman Mattress has been synonymous with luxury, handcraftsmanship, and superior comfort. If you are looking for a reliable and in-depth Shifman Mattress Review, you’re in the right place. Here is a quick summary for those who need immediate insights:

• Luxury: Handcrafted and utilizing premium materials like cashmere, wool, and latex.
• Durability: Known for their double-sided design, ensuring longer lifespan.
• Comfort: Praised for their exceptional support and plush feel.
• Price: Generally high, but many consider them worth the investment.

Shifman mattresses are renowned for being carefully crafted by dedicated artisans, making each bed a masterpiece. Founded in 1893 in Newark, NJ, Shifman continues to combine traditional techniques with modern innovations to produce mattresses that deliver unparalleled comfort and support.

I’m Ben Trapskin, and my experiences with mattresses have ranged from personal trips in finding the perfect sleep to guiding others through my platform, Yawnder. With a focus on unbiased reviews and thorough evaluations, my aim is to help you make an informed decision when it comes to your next mattress purchase. Let’s dive deeper into what makes Shifman mattresses a top choice for many.

Similar topics to Shifman Mattress Review:

• Avenco Mattress Review
• Jamestown Mattress Review
• Kingsdown Crown Imperial Mattress

History and Background of Shifman Mattress

Shifman Mattress was founded in 1893 in Newark, NJ. The company has a long history of producing high-quality, luxury mattresses. It has remained a family-owned business, currently under the leadership of the Hammer family, who have been at the helm for over 35 years.

Shifman is known for its commitment to craftsmanship and quality. Each mattress is handcrafted, a process that involves meticulous attention to detail. Skilled artisans use traditional techniques combined with modern innovations to produce mattresses that stand out in the market.

One of the key aspects that set Shifman apart is the use of luxury materials. These include:

• Natural Cotton: Known for its breathability and comfort.
• Latex: Offers excellent support and durability.
• Cashmere: Adds a touch of luxury and softness.
• Horse Hair: Provides natural ventilation and resilience.

Shifman mattresses are also double-sided, a feature that many modern mattresses lack. This design allows for flipping and rotating, which helps extend the mattress’s lifespan.

Shifman’s dedication to quality has not gone unnoticed. Customers like Thomas Breisch and Richard Seidlitz have praised the comfort and longevity of their Shifman mattresses. Thomas noted, “Sleeping on a Shifman has changed my sleeping routine. It’s such a comfortable mattress and I look forward to sleeping on it each night. It’s 10/10!” Richard added, “Fantastic product. Never slept better and amazing workmanship. Have already bought two.”

However, Shifman mattresses are not just about luxury and comfort. They are also built to last. For instance, Joe H Parker shared his experience, “We have a queen and full. 12 and 15 years old. They are still exceptional. I go on travel, sleep suffers. Follow their advice and you’ll be pleased.”

The company continues to innovate while staying true to its roots. This blend of tradition and innovation makes Shifman a standout in the luxury mattress market.

Next, let’s explore the various Shifman Mattress Collections to understand what each one offers.

Shifman Mattress Collections

Shifman offers a range of mattress collections, each designed to cater to different preferences and needs. Let’s explore the details of each collection to help you find the perfect fit.

Handmade Collection

Exclusive to Bloomingdale’s, the Handmade Collection is the epitome of luxury. These mattresses feature premium materials like alpaca, New Zealand wool, and natural latex. The individually wrapped coils and foam encasement provide excellent support and durability.

Pros: High-quality materials, exceptional craftsmanship.
Cons: High price point.

Metropolitan Collection

Also a Bloomingdale’s exclusive, the Metropolitan Collection includes quilted top mattresses made with natural cotton and memory foam. These mattresses offer a balance of firmness and comfort, though some users have reported durability issues over time.

Pros: Comfortable, good balance of firmness.
Cons: Durability issues, high price.

Latex Collection

The Latex Collection is known for its eco-conscious design. These mattresses, available at Bloomingdale’s, feature hybrid and all-latex options. They are hand-tufted and double-sided, allowing for flipping to extend their lifespan. However, they are quite expensive compared to other latex mattresses.

Pros: Eco-friendly, pressure-relieving.
Cons: Very high price.

Hotel Classic Collection

The Hotel Classic Collection is a collaboration with Macy’s. These flippable mattresses include layers of cotton, memory foam, and either traditional innerspring or individually wrapped coils. Some models also feature wool and latex. While they are luxurious, they come with a high price tag and some customers have reported issues with firmness and longevity.

Pros: Available at Macy’s, flippable.
Cons: High price, firmness and longevity issues.

Saint Michele Collection

Exclusive to Neiman Marcus, the Saint Michele Collection offers double-sided mattresses with either wrapped coil or traditional innerspring support. Some models include natural latex and plush cashmere. These mattresses are available online only and are quite expensive.

Pros: Plush, luxurious materials.
Cons: High price, online only.

Frette X Shifman Collection

A collaboration with Italian luxury linen company Frette, this collection features traditional innerspring mattresses with layers of natural cotton, wool, horse hair, latex, and sometimes micro coils. Available exclusively at Bloomingdale’s, these mattresses are hand-tufted and double-sided.

Pros: Luxurious materials, multiple firmness options.
Cons: Very high price.

Masters Collection

The Masters Collection includes innerspring mattresses with a high content of natural materials like cashmere, wool, cotton, and latex. These mattresses are known for their luxurious feel and excellent support.

Pros: High-quality natural materials.
Cons: Expensive.

Modern Comfort Collection

The Modern Comfort Collection features hybrid mattresses with cotton, memory foam, and individually wrapped pocket coils. These mattresses offer a good balance of comfort and support.

Pros: Good balance of comfort and support.
Cons: Prices are high for the materials used.

Quilted Collection

The Quilted Collection includes traditional innerspring mattresses packed with natural cotton. These mattresses are among the more affordable options from Shifman but still offer good quality.

Pros: More affordable, natural cotton.
Cons: Still high-priced compared to other brands.

American Heritage Collection

The American Heritage Collection features double-sided mattresses with cotton and individually wrapped coil systems. These mattresses are designed for durability and comfort.

Pros: Durable, double-sided.
Cons: High price.

Each Shifman Mattress collection offers something unique. Whether you’re looking for eco-friendly materials, luxurious comfort, or durable support, there’s likely a Shifman mattress that meets your needs.

Evaluating the Quality of Shifman Mattresses

When it comes to evaluating the quality of Shifman mattresses, there are several factors to consider: luxury materials, hand-tufted craftsmanship, natural components like cotton and latex, and the overall durability and support. Let’s break down the quality of each Shifman collection.

Handmade Collection

Exclusive to Bloomingdale’s, the Handmade Collection is the pinnacle of luxury in the Shifman lineup. These mattresses incorporate premium materials such as alpaca, New Zealand wool, and natural latex.

Key Features:

• Luxury Materials: Alpaca, New Zealand wool, natural latex.
• Support System: Individually wrapped coils and foam encasement.
• Durability: Designed to last, though at a high price point.

Pros: High-quality materials, exceptional craftsmanship.
Cons: High price point.

Metropolitan Collection

The Metropolitan Collection is another Bloomingdale’s exclusive. These mattresses feature quilted tops made with natural cotton and memory foam. They offer a balance of firmness and comfort, but some users have reported durability issues over time.

Key Features:

• Materials: Natural cotton and memory foam.
• Support System: Coil spring support.
• Durability: Some complaints about longevity.

Pros: Comfortable, good balance of firmness.
Cons: Durability issues, high price.

Latex Collection

The Latex Collection is known for its eco-conscious design, available exclusively at Bloomingdale’s. These mattresses come in hybrid and all-latex options, are hand-tufted, and double-sided for flipping.

Key Features:

• Materials: Natural latex, eco-friendly.
• Design: Hand-tufted, double-sided.
• Durability: Expensive but long-lasting.

Pros: Eco-friendly, pressure-relieving.
Cons: Very high price.

Hotel Classic Collection

A collaboration with Macy’s, the Hotel Classic Collection offers flippable mattresses. These include layers of cotton, memory foam, and either traditional innerspring or individually wrapped coils. Some models also feature wool and latex.

Key Features:

• Materials: Cotton, memory foam, wool, latex.
• Design: Flippable, traditional innerspring or individually wrapped coils.
• Durability: Issues with firmness and longevity reported.

Pros: Available at Macy’s, flippable.
Cons: High price, firmness and longevity issues.

Saint Michele Collection

Exclusive to Neiman Marcus, the Saint Michele Collection features double-sided mattresses with either wrapped coil or traditional innerspring support. Some models include natural latex and plush cashmere. These mattresses are available online only.

Key Features:

• Materials: Natural latex, plush cashmere.
• Design: Hand-tufted, quilted.
• Durability: High price, limited availability.

Pros: Plush, luxurious materials.
Cons: High price, online only.

Frette X Shifman Collection

The Frette X Shifman Collection is a collaboration with Italian luxury linen company Frette, available exclusively at Bloomingdale’s. These traditional innerspring mattresses include layers of natural cotton, wool, horse hair, latex, and sometimes micro coils.

Key Features:

• Materials: Natural cotton, wool, horse hair, latex.
• Design: Hand-tufted, double-sided.
• Durability: Multiple firmness options but very high price.

Pros: Luxurious materials, multiple firmness options.
Cons: Very high price.

Each Shifman mattress collection offers unique features custom to different needs. Whether you prioritize eco-friendliness, luxury, or durability, there’s a Shifman mattress that fits the bill.

Customer Reviews and Feedback

Positive Reviews

Shifman mattresses have garnered positive feedback from many customers. Luxury feel and exceptional comfort are recurring themes.

Ronald Greene from Resaca, Georgia, mentions his six-year-old Shifman mattress as “the most comfortable, sturdy, plush, sleek, and extravagant mattress” he has ever owned. He plans to buy another one for his mother, emphasizing the regal feeling it provides.

Ana Taveras appreciates the quality so much that she prefers her daughter’s Shifman mattress over her own bed, joking that she needs to change hers to “save her marriage.”

Bryan Girsch praises his new Shifman mattress for solving his back and shoulder issues, highlighting the handcrafted quality.

Sam Foley has noticed improvements in his posture, back, and neck, attributing it to the company’s rich history and handcrafted approach.

Jennifer Zanger describes her Shifman mattress as “BY FAR the most comfortable mattress” she has ever slept on, feeling like she was treated to luxury.

Michelle Jacoby shares that she owns two Shifman mattresses and wouldn’t sleep on anything else, noting the meticulous construction and long-lasting comfort.

These reviews underline the supportive, well-made, and long-lasting nature of Shifman mattresses, often leading to back pain relief and a luxurious sleep experience.

Negative Reviews

However, not all feedback is glowing. Some customers have raised concerns about durability and customer service.

Jay Bangash reports that his high-end Hotel Classic mattress developed a deep valley in the center within 24 months, leading to back pain. He also criticizes Shifman’s warranty exclusions, suggesting they make the warranty seem illegitimate.

Jennifer Shield praises her Shifman mattress for alleviating her back pain but notes that the customer service didn’t meet her expectations.

Michelle Jacoby also mentions that while her mattresses have held up well, they are heavy to flip, which can be a drawback for some users.

Stephen Locker and Aidan Zucker both love their Shifman mattresses but have not mentioned any negative aspects, indicating a generally positive experience.

Luis Ramirez Morales finds his sleep quality has improved dramatically but doesn’t provide specifics on any potential downsides.

Common negative themes include durability issues like sagging and body impressions, high prices, and poor customer service. Some users also find the mattresses heavy to flip, which can be inconvenient.

Shifman mattresses receive a mix of glowing praise for their luxury and comfort, and criticism for durability and customer service. This balanced feedback is crucial for anyone considering a Shifman mattress.

Comparison with Other Mattress Brands

When evaluating Shifman mattresses, it’s helpful to compare them with other well-known brands to understand their unique features, strengths, and weaknesses.

Tempur-Pedic vs Shifman

Tempur-Pedic is renowned for its memory foam mattresses, which provide excellent pressure relief and conform to the body’s shape. However, some users report that these mattresses can retain heat.

Shifman offers luxury innerspring mattresses with natural materials like cotton, wool, and horsehair. These are handcrafted and designed to be flippable, potentially extending their lifespan, though they are generally more expensive.

Saatva vs Shifman

Saatva is known for its eco-friendly hybrid mattresses, which combine innerspring support with memory foam comfort, often at a more affordable price point.

Shifman focuses on luxury and craftsmanship, using high-quality materials and traditional techniques. While more expensive, Shifman provides a more luxurious and handcrafted experience.

Millbrook vs Shifman

Millbrook mattresses, made in the UK, also use natural materials like cotton and wool and offer a range of firmness options.

Like Shifman, Millbrook mattresses are handcrafted and designed for durability. Shifman, however, offers a broader range of luxury materials and collections.

Dreamcloud vs Shifman

Dreamcloud offers hybrid mattresses at a competitive price. These feature a high profile and pillowy design, providing comfort and support for a wide range of sleepers.

Shifman mattresses, while more expensive, offer a luxurious feel and are crafted with high-quality materials. Dreamcloud provides a more affordable option with good support and comfort, but Shifman stands out for its luxury and craftsmanship.

In summary, Shifman mattresses offer a luxurious and handcrafted sleep experience, but they come at a higher price and may require more maintenance. Brands like Tempur-Pedic, Saatva, Millbrook, and Dreamcloud provide different features and price points, making them suitable alternatives based on individual preferences and budgets.

Frequently Asked Questions about Shifman Mattresses

Who owns Shifman Mattress?

Shifman Mattress has been owned by the Hammer family for over 35 years. This family-run business prides itself on maintaining traditional craftsmanship and high-quality standards. The Hammers have kept the company’s legacy alive by focusing on luxury and durability.

How long does a Shifman mattress last?

A Shifman mattress is designed for longevity. With proper maintenance, including regular flipping and rotating, these mattresses can last 10 to 15 years or even longer. Many customers report that their Shifman mattresses have remained comfortable and supportive for over a decade.

Flipping and rotating your Shifman mattress helps to distribute wear evenly, preventing sagging and body impressions. For the first six months, it is recommended to flip the mattress monthly. After that, flipping it every three months can help maintain its shape and comfort.

Where can I buy a Shifman mattress?

Shifman mattresses are available at several high-end retailers. You can find them at Bloomingdale’s, Macy’s, and Neiman Marcus. Additionally, some local retailers and specialty mattress stores carry Shifman products.

For those who prefer online shopping, Shifman mattresses can also be purchased through various online platforms. It’s always a good idea to check the retailer’s return policy and warranty before making a purchase.

Conclusion

In our comprehensive Shifman Mattress Review, we’ve explored the luxurious craftsmanship and high-quality materials that set Shifman apart. Founded in 1893, Shifman has maintained a reputation for handcrafting mattresses using premium materials like natural cotton, cashmere, and horse hair. This dedication to quality is evident in their meticulous attention to detail and traditional techniques.

However, luxury comes at a price. Shifman mattresses are among the most expensive on the market, with prices ranging from $930 to over $27,000. Despite the high cost, some customers report issues with durability and longevity, which can be a significant concern given the investment.

On the upside, many users rave about the comfort and support provided by Shifman mattresses. Positive reviews highlight relief from back pain and the luxurious feel of the materials. Yet, the high price and occasional durability complaints make it essential to weigh the pros and cons carefully.

At Yawnder, we value expert reviews and unbiased evaluations to help you find the perfect mattress. While Shifman offers a unique blend of luxury and traditional craftsmanship, it’s crucial to consider your budget and specific needs. If you’re looking for a more competitively priced alternative, brands like Dreamcloud and Sealy might offer better value without compromising on comfort.

For those ready to invest in a Shifman mattress, direct-to-door shipping makes the purchase process convenient. However, always check the retailer’s return policy and warranty to ensure you’re fully covered.

To explore more mattress options and find the right fit for your needs, visit our Yawnder mattress collection.

In summary, Shifman mattresses offer unparalleled luxury and craftsmanship but come with a hefty price tag. By considering expert reviews and evaluating your specific needs, you can make an informed decision that ensures restful nights and improved health.