Casper vs. Nolah which is right for you? 5 key differences.

08/19/2024

Ben Trapskin

I have carefully studied and evaluated many mattresses, sheets, pillows, duvet inserts, comforters, sleep gadgets, and adjustable beds for over a deca... Full Bio

The #1 Powerful Casper vs. Nolah Comparison in 2024: 5 Must-Know Differences

Casper vs. Nolah: which is right for you? Let’s explore five key differences and find out which mattress offers the best sleep for your needs. If you’re curious about these two popular brands, here’s a quick comparison to help:

Mattress Type: Both brands offer all-foam and hybrid mattresses.
Cooling Technology: Nolah’s AirFoam™ vs. Casper‘s AirScape™ layers.
Firmness: Nolah offers medium to firm options, whereas Casper ranges from medium-soft to medium-firm.
Material Quality: Nolah includes eco-friendly materials like organic cotton and wool; Casper focuses on innovative foam layers.
Target Sleepers: Nolah is great for lightweight and side sleepers, while Casper shines for back and combination sleepers.

Introducing myself, I’m Ben Trapskin, the founder of Yawnder, who steerd through countless mattress experiences to help you find the perfect sleep solution. My journey and research aid in providing clear, relatable insights into Casper vs. Nolah choices.

Here’s an infographic summarizing the key points:

Casper vs. Nolah: Overview

When it comes to choosing between Casper vs. Nolah, understanding the key features and benefits of each mattress is crucial. Both brands offer all-foam mattresses designed to cater to various sleep needs. Let’s explore what sets them apart and who they are best suited for.

All-Foam Mattresses

Casper and Nolah both offer all-foam mattresses, which are known for their excellent pressure relief and motion isolation. These mattresses are made up of multiple layers of foam, each serving a specific purpose to improve comfort and support.

Breathable Layers

Nolah mattresses are equipped with AirFoam, a unique material designed to be more breathable than traditional memory foam. This helps in maintaining a cooler sleep environment. The TENCEL cover on the Nolah Original also contributes to its breathability.

Casper uses AirScape™ perforated foam in its top layer, which allows for continuous airflow, keeping the mattress cool throughout the night. This makes both brands suitable for hot sleepers, but Nolah has a slight edge in temperature control.

Pressure Relief

Both Nolah and Casper excel in pressure relief, making them ideal for side sleepers. The Nolah Original’s AirFoam layers are designed to relieve pressure on the hips and shoulders, which is crucial for side sleepers.

Casper also offers great pressure relief with its zoned support foam, providing targeted support for different areas of the body. This makes it a versatile choice for back, stomach, and side sleepers.

Motion Isolation

If you or your partner toss and turn at night, both Nolah and Casper have you covered. These mattresses are excellent at absorbing movement, preventing disturbances.

Nolah has a slight advantage in motion isolation due to its softer, more conforming foam layers. However, Casper also performs exceptionally well, making either a good choice for couples.

Ideal for Side Sleepers

Both Nolah and Casper are great choices for side sleepers. The Nolah Original is particularly good for lightweight and average-weight side sleepers due to its cushiony feel and excellent pressure relief.

Casper, with its balanced foam layers, also supports side sleepers well, especially those who are lightweight or average-weight.

Back Pain Relief

For those suffering from back pain, Nolah offers a supportive yet conforming sleep surface that can help alleviate discomfort. The foam layers provide a good balance of support and softness.

Casper is often recommended for back pain relief due to its zoned support foam, which keeps your spine in proper alignment. This makes it a top choice for back and combination sleepers.

Combination Sleepers

If you switch positions frequently during the night, Casper is a standout option. Its zoned support and responsive foam layers make it easy to move around without feeling stuck.

Nolah is also responsive but may feel a bit softer, making it slightly less ideal for those who need extra support when switching positions.

Lightweight and Average-Weight Sleepers

Both Nolah and Casper cater well to lightweight and average-weight sleepers. The medium-firm feel of these mattresses provides the right amount of support without being too hard or too soft.

In summary, Nolah is excellent for side sleepers, hot sleepers, and those with back pain, while Casper shines for combination sleepers, back sleepers, and those who toss and turn. Both mattresses offer great pressure relief and motion isolation, making them suitable for various sleep needs.

Next, let’s dig into the construction and materials of these mattresses to understand what makes them unique.

Mattress Construction and Materials

Nolah Mattress Construction

Nolah Original 10″: This mattress features a three-layer construction. The top layer is 2 inches of Nolah’s proprietary AirFoam™, which provides excellent pressure relief and is more responsive than traditional memory foam. Beneath that is a 1-inch transition layer of high-resilience foam for added support. The base layer is a 7-inch high-density foam that offers durability and support. The cover is made from breathable TENCEL™, which is moisture-wicking and helps keep the sleeping surface cool.

Nolah Original Hybrid: Similar to the Original 10″, but with the addition of an 8-inch layer of pocketed coils for improved support and durability. The top layer of AirFoam™ is thinner, giving it a more neutral hybrid feel.

Casper Mattress Construction

Casper Original: This mattress has three layers. The top layer is 1.5 inches of perforated AirScape™ foam, which promotes airflow and keeps the mattress cool. The middle layer is 2 inches of zoned memory foam, providing targeted support to different parts of the body. The base layer is 7 inches of high-density foam for durability and support. The cover is a poly-blend stretch-knit that feels soft and durable.

Casper Wave Hybrid Snow: This advanced hybrid mattress features five layers. The top layer is 1 inch of AirScape™ foam with cooling gel. The second layer is 1.5 inches of zoned memory foam. The third layer is 1.5 inches of AirScape™ foam with graphite to draw heat away. The fourth layer is 1.5 inches of zoned support foam. The base layer is 7 inches of pocketed coils for added support and durability. The cover is made with Snow Technology, which helps keep the mattress cool throughout the night.

Casper Nova Hybrid Snow: This mattress also features multiple layers. The top layer is 1 inch of AirScape™ foam with cooling gel. The second layer is 1.5 inches of AirScape™ foam with graphite. The third layer is 2 inches of zoned memory foam for targeted support. The fourth layer is 1.5 inches of high-resilience foam. The base layer is 7 inches of pocketed coils. The cover features Snow Technology for improved cooling.

Both Nolah and Casper use high-quality materials in their mattresses, but their constructions differ significantly. Nolah focuses on innovative foams like AirFoam™ and natural materials like latex and organic cotton, while Casper incorporates advanced cooling technologies and zoned support systems in their designs.

Next, let’s explore the firmness and feel differences between these two mattress brands.

Firmness and Feel Differences

When comparing Casper vs. Nolah, understanding the firmness and feel of each mattress is key to finding the right one for you.

Nolah Firmness and Feel

The Nolah mattresses generally fall on the softer side of the firmness spectrum. Most of their models, like the Nolah Original 10″, are rated medium-soft to medium-firm, around a 6/10 on the firmness scale.

Key Features:

AirFoam: Nolah’s proprietary AirFoam offers a responsive and pressure-relieving experience. It contours to your body, making it great for side sleepers.
Pressure Relief: The AirFoam does a fantastic job of relieving pressure points, especially around the hips and shoulders, which is ideal for side sleepers and those who prefer a softer feel.
Responsive Feel: Despite its softness, the Nolah mattress is responsive enough for combination sleepers who switch positions during the night.

Ideal For:

Side Sleepers: The medium-soft feel and excellent pressure relief make it a top choice for side sleepers.
Lightweight Sleepers: Those under 130 pounds will find the Nolah’s softer feel more comfortable and easier to sink into.
Combination Sleepers: The responsive nature of the AirFoam ensures that you can move easily without feeling stuck.

Casper Firmness and Feel

The Casper mattresses are generally medium-firm, around a 7/10 on the firmness scale, providing a balanced feel that caters to a wide range of sleepers.

Key Features:

Plush Polyfoam: Casper uses a combination of plush polyfoam and memory foam in their comfort layers. This offers light contouring and a cushiony feeling, but with more support than Nolah.
Zoned Support: Casper‘s Zoned Support™ system provides firmer support under the hips and softer foam under the shoulders, promoting better spinal alignment.
Light Contouring: The mattress contours lightly to your body, offering a balanced mix of comfort and support.

Ideal For:

Back Sleepers: The medium-firm feel and zoned support make it excellent for back sleepers who need a balance of support and comfort.
Stomach Sleepers: The firmer feel ensures that your hips don’t sink in too far, keeping your spine aligned.
Couples: With great motion isolation and a balanced feel, Casper is a good compromise for couples with different sleeping preferences.

Performance Ratings

Temperature Control

When it comes to staying cool at night, both Casper and Nolah have their strengths. Casper scores slightly higher with a 3.5/5 for temperature control, thanks to its AirScape™ perforated foam, which promotes airflow and helps keep the mattress cool. Nolah, with a 3/5, relies on its breathable Tencel™ cover and AirFoam™ to offer decent cooling. Both mattresses are better than average for all-foam options, but if you’re a hot sleeper, Casper might give you a slight edge.

Motion Transfer

For couples, motion transfer can be a deal-breaker. Both brands excel here, but Casper takes the lead with a perfect 5/5. Its foam layers are designed to absorb movement, ensuring minimal disturbance. Nolah follows closely with a 4.5/5, also performing admirably in isolating motion. If you share your bed with a restless partner or pet, either mattress will serve you well, but Casper has the slight advantage.

Edge Support

Edge support is crucial for those who like to use the full surface of their bed. Casper scores a solid 4/5, offering robust edge support that makes it easier to sit or sleep near the edge without feeling like you’ll roll off. Nolah, however, falls short with a 2/5. Its softer foam compresses more at the edges, which could be a drawback if you frequently sit or sleep near the edge.

Pressure Relief

In terms of pressure relief, Casper again comes out on top with a 4.5/5. It provides excellent spine alignment and joint relief, making it a great option for those with back or joint pain. Nolah scores a respectable 3.5/5, offering good pressure relief thanks to its AirFoam™, which is particularly beneficial for side sleepers. If pressure relief is a priority, Casper might be the better choice.

Pain Relief

For pain relief, Casper is a standout, particularly for back pain, earning top marks. Its zoned support and medium-firm feel make it ideal for lightweight and average-weight sleepers who need extra support. Nolah, while decent, doesn’t quite match Casper in this area. If you suffer from chronic pain, Casper’s design might provide the relief you need.

Durability

Durability is another important factor. Casper scores a 4/5, indicating a solid lifespan for an all-foam mattress, especially for average-weight sleepers. Nolah, with a 3/5, is also durable but might not hold up as well for heavyweight sleepers. Both mattresses offer good durability, but Casper’s construction gives it a slight edge.

In summary, while both Casper and Nolah offer strong performance across various metrics, Casper tends to have the edge in most categories. Whether it’s temperature control, motion transfer, edge support, pressure relief, pain relief, or durability, Casper generally provides a more balanced and reliable option. However, Nolah still offers excellent value, especially for side sleepers and those who prefer a softer feel.

Pricing and Value

When it comes to pricing, Casper vs. Nolah shows some differences that might influence your decision.

Nolah Pricing

Nolah offers a variety of mattresses with different price points:

Nolah Original 10″: $999 for a Queen. This all-foam mattress offers excellent value for those looking for a budget-friendly option.
Nolah Original Hybrid: A step up in price but offers added support with pocketed coils.
Nolah Signature 12″: $1,499 for a Queen. This medium-firm mattress is great for back pain and side sleepers, with a lifetime warranty and a 120-night trial period.
Nolah Natural 11″: $1,999 for a Queen. Made with organic materials, it’s ideal for eco-conscious buyers.
Nolah Evolution Hybrid 15″: $2,499 for a Queen. This mattress offers multiple firmness options and advanced cooling features.
Nolah Evolution Comfort+: Prices range from $974 to $1,948, depending on the size and firmness you choose.

Nolah frequently offers discounts, so keep an eye out for deals that can save you a significant amount.

Casper Pricing

Casper’s range also covers a spectrum of prices:

Casper Original: $1,295 for a Queen. This mattress is known for its balanced support and cooling features.
Casper Wave Hybrid Snow: A luxury option with advanced cooling technology, priced higher than the Original.
Casper Nova Hybrid Snow: Another premium option, offering a plush feel and excellent support.

Casper also offers discounts and promotions, especially around major shopping holidays.

Price Comparison:

Size	Nolah Prices	Casper Prices
Twin	$999	$895
Twin XL	$1,199	$995
Full	$1,349	$1,195
Queen	$1,149	$1,295
King	$1,749	$1,695
California King	$1,749	$1,695

Affordability vs. Luxury:

Nolah: Offers a range of affordable options with premium features, making it a great choice for budget-conscious buyers.
Casper: Slightly higher in price, but offers more advanced features and a longer track record, appealing to those willing to invest more for added benefits.