
Quick verdict
The original Hartfield Luxury Firm felt supportive and had some bounce, but I found it firmer than I preferred and less pressure-relieving than I wanted. This is an archive of a specific 2015 mattress, so its feel and terms should not be assumed for today’s Beautyrest models.
Best for: readers researching this older mattress or seeking a firmer, responsive feel. Consider another option if: you want more cushioning or are shopping for a currently available model.
My original test and delivery
October 2026 legacy-review update: Beautyrest Recharge is a historical Simmons mattress, not the same bed as today’s Beautyrest lines. The comfort, construction and seller return fee here refer to the original review. For current choices see our Beautyrest comparison and the current Beautyrest catalog, including Quilted Innerspring, Hybrid and Black collections.
The Simmons Beautyrest Recharge is a very popular mattress that has been getting lots of attention. I put this mattress to the test and found it to be rather unimpressive when compared to the quality you get online.
Ordering the BeautyRest Recharge
I ordered this mattress through Mattress Firm. You can try out this model in their stores or just order online or via a phone call. I decided to order via the phone. Instead of trying out in a store I wanted to test it out in my own house similar to the other online mattresses I have tested. The process was very easy and delivery was extremely fast. I ordered on a Tuesday and has a scheduled 3 hour delivery window for Thursday. This mattress does not come in a box so a freight delivery needs to be scheduled.
A nice touch was a coupon for 15% off at Olejo.com and a mint. Olejo.com sells mattress and other bedding accessories.
Construction of the original mattress
Here are the specifications of the Simmons BeautyRest Recharge mattress. The specific model I purchased was the Recharge Signature Select Hartfield 11.5″ Luxury Firm Mattress.
Historical trial: At the time of the review, the retailer advertised a 100-day trial. Current purchase and return policies depend on the seller.
My comfort findings
Below is my original video illustrating the bounce of the Beautyrest Recharge mattress.
As you can see it still has some good bounce for a firm mattress but doesn’t sink in as much as a
What really concerned me was tufting on the mattress. As you can see the buttons are just for show and aren’t sewn into the mattress although this is true for many foam mattresses I have reviewed as well.
Here’s a video of the tufting of the Beautyrest Recharge
My BeautyRest Recharge Recommendation
This mattress just didn’t do it for me. It is a bit too firm for my taste. The top layer looks nice but nothing special. At the time, I disliked the retailer’s $149 return fee; current return terms depend on the seller. With all the other companies I have reviewed so far you get a full cash refund and aren’t stuck choosing a different mattress in stock. The archived 2015 Queen price was $649; current availability and pricing are not verified so I imagine the more expensive models have more features.
In conclusion, I would take a look at some of the other inner spring mattress reviews on my site before committing to a Beautyrest Recharge.
Disclosure: We aim to highlight products and services you might find interesting, and if you buy them, we may get a small share of the revenue. At the time of the original review, I did not have an affiliate relationship with Simmons Beautyrest. Links on this updated page may be affiliate links.
Current alternatives
Beautyrest’s current catalog includes quilted innerspring and hybrid mattresses across several collections. These are different models from the original Recharge Hartfield: compare the exact firmness, construction, price and return policy rather than assuming the old review applies. See the Yawnder Beautyrest comparison and Beautyrest’s current catalog.
When trying alternatives, spend time in your usual sleep position and consider edge support, movement and delivery costs. A firmer mattress can feel supportive to one person and uncomfortable to another.
Frequently asked questions
Which Recharge did Yawnder test?
The original review tested the Recharge Signature Select Hartfield 11.5-inch Luxury Firm model.
How firm did it feel?
I found that particular mattress supportive but firmer than I preferred, with less pressure relief than I wanted. We did not assign a numerical firmness score.
What did the original mattress cost?
The archived review records a $649 queen price in 2015. It is historical and should not be used as a current price.
What were the return terms?
The original reviewer reported a $149 return fee at the time. Current return terms vary by mattress and retailer; check the written policy before buying.
Are current Beautyrest mattresses the same?
No. The original Recharge is a historical model. Current lines have different designs and must be evaluated separately.
Live pricing, current promotions, and full manufacturer warranty through our affiliate partner. Buying through this link supports Yawnder’s independent testing at no extra cost to you.
Shop BeautyRest
