Saatva vs. Stearns & Foster: Top 5 Features Compared in 2024

If you’re comparing Saatva vs. Stearns & Foster mattresses, you’re likely looking for a luxurious and comfortable sleep solution that meets your needs. Here’s a quick rundown to help you decide:

1. Price: Saatva is generally more affordable than Stearns & Foster.
2. Eco-friendliness: Saatva uses more eco-friendly materials.
3. Firmness: Saatva offers a softer top layer, while Stearns & Foster tends to be slightly firmer.

Welcome to Yawnder’s Ultimate Guide to Comparing Saatva vs. Stearns & Foster Mattresses. Our aim is to help you steer the key features, benefits, and differences between these two popular mattress brands.

As someone who has spent years diving deep into the mattress industry—after experiencing sleep issues myself—I understand how crucial it is to find the perfect mattress. I’m Ben Trapskin, and I’ll be your guide through this comparison, providing insights from my extensive research and personal experience.

Let’s get started by taking a closer look at the main features of each mattress.

Glossary for Saatva vs. Stearns & Foster:
– Dreamcloud vs. Serta Perfect Sleeper
– Helix vs. BeautyRest
– Serta vs. Simmons

Saatva vs. Stearns & Foster: Key Features Comparison

When comparing Saatva vs. Stearns & Foster, it’s crucial to understand how they stack up in terms of firmness, feel, cooling features, motion isolation, edge support, and pricing. Let’s break it down:

Firmness and Feel

Saatva Classic offers three firmness levels: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. The Luxury Firm model scores a 7/10 on the firmness scale, providing a balanced mix of comfort and support. This makes it ideal for back sleepers and those who like a traditional innerspring feel.

Stearns & Foster Lux Estate comes in four firmness levels: Medium, Pillow Top Soft, Pillow Top Medium, and Pillow Top Firm. The Pillow Top Medium model scores a 6.5/10, which is the industry standard for medium-firm mattresses. It offers a plush, pillow-top feel, making it a favorite for side sleepers and those who prefer a bit more cushioning.

Cooling Features

Both mattresses are designed with breathability in mind, but Stearns & Foster takes the lead here. The Lux Estate mattress features a TENCEL™ cover, which is known for its moisture-wicking and cooling properties. The TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam also helps in maintaining a cool sleeping environment.

Saatva Classic features an organic cotton cover and a dual-coil system that promotes airflow. While it does a good job at keeping sleepers cool, it doesn’t quite match the advanced cooling capabilities of Stearns & Foster’s materials.

Motion Isolation

If you share your bed with a partner, motion isolation is key. Stearns & Foster excels in this area thanks to its thick TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam layer, which keeps movements isolated to one side of the bed.

Saatva Classic, on the other hand, has decent motion isolation but doesn’t perform as well due to its innerspring construction. You might feel your partner’s movements more on this mattress.

Edge Support

Edge support is essential for those who like to sit or sleep near the edge of the bed. Stearns & Foster wins here with its IntelliCoil® innersprings that provide reinforced edge support. You can confidently use the entire surface area without feeling like you’ll roll off.

Saatva Classic also offers good edge support with its foam encasement, but you might feel a bit of sinking through the pillow top.

Pricing

When it comes to pricing, Saatva is generally more affordable. Here’s a quick comparison:

Saatva Classic:
– Twin: $1395
– Queen: $2095
– King: $2595

Stearns & Foster Lux Estate:
– Twin XL: $2899
– Queen: $2999
– King: $3599

While Stearns & Foster is on the pricier side, it offers a luxurious feel and advanced features that some may find worth the extra cost. Saatva, however, provides excellent value for money, especially for those on a budget.

In summary, both Saatva and Stearns & Foster offer high-quality mattresses, but they cater to different preferences and budgets. Whether you prioritize cooling, motion isolation, or edge support, understanding these key features can help you make an informed decision.

Next, let’s dive into the construction differences between these two mattresses.

Mattress Construction Differences

Saatva Construction

Materials and Layers

The Saatva Classic mattress is built with high-quality materials that focus on comfort and support. The mattress starts with an organic cotton cover, which is soft, breathable, and treated with a botanical antimicrobial agent to keep it fresh. The cover is quilted to a layer of foam, creating a Euro pillow top that feels plush and luxurious.

Beneath the pillow top, you’ll find a dual coil system. The first layer consists of individually wrapped pocket coils that contour to your body, reducing motion transfer and providing targeted support. Below this is a base layer of traditional steel coils, which add durability and ensure proper spinal alignment. This combination of coils allows for excellent airflow, helping to keep the mattress cool.

Height and Eco-Friendly Features

The Saatva Classic comes in two height options: 11.5 inches and 14.5 inches. Both versions offer the same feel and support, but the height difference may affect the mattress’s compatibility with certain bed frames and adjustable bases.

Saatva emphasizes eco-friendliness by using materials like organic cotton and CertiPUR-US certified foams, which are free from harmful chemicals and low in VOCs (volatile organic compounds). This makes the Saatva a good choice for environmentally conscious consumers.

Stearns & Foster Construction

Materials and Layers

The Stearns & Foster Lux Estate mattress is designed with premium materials to deliver a luxurious sleep experience. The cover is made from TENCEL™, a fabric derived from eucalyptus wood pulp that’s known for its cooling and moisture-wicking properties. This cover feels cool to the touch and helps regulate temperature throughout the night.

Underneath the cover, the Lux Estate features a TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam comfort layer. This foam, developed by Tempur-Pedic, provides exceptional pressure relief and a plush feel. It contours to your body, reducing pressure points and enhancing comfort.

The support layer consists of IntelliCoil® innersprings, which are dual-stage coils designed to offer both comfort and support. These coils adapt to your body shape and weight, providing personalized support and minimizing motion transfer. Additionally, there’s a layer of coils surrounding the edges of the mattress, enhancing edge support and durability.

Height and Eco-Friendly Features

The Stearns & Foster Lux Estate is available in two height options: 14.5 inches and 16 inches. The thicker profile adds to the luxurious feel and provides extra cushioning for a more comfortable sleep experience.

While the Lux Estate doesn’t emphasize eco-friendliness as much as the Saatva, it does use high-quality, durable materials designed to last over a decade, reducing the need for frequent replacements.

In summary, both the Saatva Classic and Stearns & Foster Lux Estate mattresses are constructed with premium materials and thoughtful design. Saatva focuses on eco-friendly features and a dual-coil system for support and airflow, while Stearns & Foster offers advanced cooling with TENCEL™ and TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam, along with robust edge support from IntelliCoil® innersprings.

Next, let’s explore the performance differences between these two mattresses.

Performance Differences

Durability

When it comes to durability, the Stearns & Foster Lux Estate has a slight edge over the Saatva Classic. The Lux Estate’s thicker profile (up to 16 inches) and high-quality materials, like the IntelliCoil® innersprings, contribute to its long-lasting nature. You can expect this mattress to last over a decade with proper care.

On the other hand, the Saatva Classic, with its dual-coil system and organic cotton cover, is also built to last, but typically has a lifespan of eight to ten years. While both mattresses are durable, the Stearns & Foster may offer a bit more longevity due to its robust construction.

Off-Gassing

Off-gassing refers to the release of chemical odors when a mattress is first unboxed. This is often an issue with memory foam mattresses that are compressed and shipped in a box. Fortunately, both the Saatva and Stearns & Foster mattresses do not come as bed-in-a-box options, meaning off-gassing is minimal.

Neither mattress emitted noticeable odors during our tests, making them suitable for those sensitive to chemical smells. This is a significant advantage for both brands, ensuring a fresher and more pleasant initial setup experience.

Noise

Both mattresses performed well in terms of noise. During our tests, the Saatva Classic and Stearns & Foster Lux Estate were completely silent. However, over time, the coils in these mattresses could potentially start to squeak.

This is a common issue with innerspring mattresses, but it usually takes several years to develop. For now, you can expect a quiet night’s sleep with either option.

Sex

For couples, the mattress’s responsiveness and bounciness are crucial factors. The Saatva Classic takes the lead here. Its dual-coil system provides a bouncy and responsive surface, making it easier to move around. This makes it an excellent choice for couples looking for a mattress that improves intimacy.

The Stearns & Foster Lux Estate, with its thicker memory foam comfort layer, is also responsive but might feel a bit more enveloping. While it’s still a good option, some couples might find themselves sinking into the mattress more than they’d like.

In summary, Saatva vs. Stearns & Foster each have their strengths and weaknesses in performance. The Stearns & Foster Lux Estate excels in durability and cooling, while the Saatva Classic offers better responsiveness and minimal off-gassing. Both mattresses are quiet, but potential coil noise could develop over time.

Next, let’s dive into what customers have to say about these two mattresses.

Saatva vs. Stearns & Foster: Customer Reviews and Feedback

Positive Reviews

Both Saatva and Stearns & Foster have earned high praise from customers for various reasons.

Saatva customers often highlight the excellent customer service. One customer, Patty, shared, “We were skeptical of buying a mattress online but it could not have gone any smoother. Anthony answered all of our questions during our many phone conversations. Delivery was prompt and went without a hitch. Best of all, the mattress is so comfortable! I haven’t had such a good night’s sleep in years.”

In terms of comfort and support, many users appreciate Saatva‘s traditional innerspring feel and the variety of firmness options. The Saatva Classic is particularly noted for providing a great balance of support and comfort, especially for back sleepers.

Stearns & Foster also receives high marks, especially for its luxurious feel and durability. Customers often mention the plush pillow top and the TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam that provides a weightless feel. One reviewer noted, “The mattress is high quality. The tufting, the materials used, the comfort, the evenness of support. Excellent!”

Negative Reviews

Despite the positive feedback, there are some common complaints about both brands.

For Saatva, some customers have reported issues with firmness. A few found the mattresses either too firm or too soft, leading to discomfort. Another concern is durability. Some users reported sagging or the formation of body impressions over time. Additionally, there have been complaints about customer service, with some experiencing delays in responses or unsatisfactory resolutions.

Delivery issues have also been noted. Some customers faced delays or complications in the delivery process. One customer shared, “Some users have reported delays in receiving their Saatva mattress or issues with the delivery process.”

Stearns & Foster has its share of negative reviews as well. Some customers find the mattress too soft, which can cause back pain. One user mentioned, “Starting on the first night my lower back has been killing me. I think the foam sinks too much and yet I’m not getting support from the springs?

There are also durability concerns. Despite its high-quality build, some users have reported that the Stearns & Foster mattress did not hold up well over time. Issues such as sagging and lumps were mentioned. Additionally, the return process can be cumbersome and costly, with a $175 processing fee for returns or exchanges.

Common Complaints

Here’s a quick look at the common complaints for each brand:

Saatva:
– Firmness issues: Too firm or too soft for some users.
– Durability concerns: Sagging and body impressions over time.
– Customer service: Delays and unsatisfactory resolutions.
– Delivery issues: Delays and complications.

Stearns & Foster:
– Comfort issues: Too soft, causing back pain for some.
– Durability concerns: Sagging and lumps over time.
– Return experiences: Costly and cumbersome process.

In conclusion, while both Saatva and Stearns & Foster offer high-quality mattresses, they each have their pros and cons based on customer feedback. Your choice will depend on your specific needs and preferences.

Now, let’s dive into some frequently asked questions about these two mattress brands.

Frequently Asked Questions about Saatva vs. Stearns & Foster

Is Saatva mattress made in China?

No, Saatva mattresses are not made in China. They are proudly manufactured in the USA. This assures high-quality control and supports American jobs. Saatva uses eco-friendly materials and implements rigorous quality checks to ensure their mattresses meet high standards. This domestic production also helps reduce the carbon footprint associated with long-distance shipping.

What hotel chain uses Stearns & Foster mattresses?

The Ritz-Carlton is known for using custom-made Stearns & Foster mattresses. These mattresses are designed to provide a luxurious sleep experience, aligning with the high standards of comfort and quality that the Ritz-Carlton is famous for. Guests often rave about the plush, supportive feel of these mattresses, which are custom to meet the hotel chain’s specific requirements for durability and comfort.

How long will the Saatva and Stearns & Foster mattresses last?

The lifespan of a mattress is a crucial factor to consider.

Saatva mattresses are designed to last between 8 to 10 years. They use high-quality materials like dual coil layers and an organic cotton cover, which contribute to their durability. However, some customers have reported issues with sagging over time, which might affect the mattress’s longevity.

Stearns & Foster mattresses, particularly the Lux Estate collection, are known for their durability. They are expected to last at least a decade. The use of IntelliCoil® innersprings and TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam improves their lifespan. Despite this, some users have reported sagging and lumps, which could impact the mattress’s overall durability.

In summary, both Saatva and Stearns & Foster offer durable mattresses, but Stearns & Foster might have a slight edge in longevity due to its robust construction and premium materials.

Conclusion

When it comes to choosing between Saatva vs. Stearns & Foster, both brands offer high-end mattresses that cater to different preferences and needs. Here’s a quick recap to help you make the best choice:

Final Thoughts:

Both Saatva and Stearns & Foster excel in different areas. Saatva is known for its eco-friendly materials, exceptional customer service, and affordability. Stearns & Foster, on the other hand, offers a luxurious feel with its high-quality materials and advanced construction.

Best Choice:

• Choose Saatva if you want a more budget-friendly option without compromising on quality. It’s also a great pick if you prefer an eco-friendly mattress with a traditional innerspring feel.

• Choose Stearns & Foster if you’re looking for a plush, luxurious mattress and are willing to invest more for premium materials and a longer lifespan. It’s ideal for those who want the ultimate hotel-like sleep experience.

Yawnder Recommendation:

At Yawnder, we believe that both brands offer excellent options depending on your specific needs. If you’re still unsure, consider what aspects are most important to you—be it budget, eco-friendliness, or luxury. For more detailed reviews and to explore other mattress options, visit our Yawnder mattress collection page.

Choosing the right mattress is a significant decision, and we hope this guide helps you find the perfect fit for a restful night’s sleep.