Family Owned & Operated Since 2015
1441 Encinitas Blvd. Suite 116
Encinitas, CA 92024
Call or Text 858-232-5760

0
0

When you buy with our links, we may earn a commission. Learn More

Saatva Mattress: Stunning Comparison of Best Luxury Choices

Picture of Ben Trapskin

Ben Trapskin

I have carefully studied and evaluated many mattresses, sheets, pillows, duvet inserts, comforters, sleep gadgets, and adjustable beds for over a deca... Full Bio
a two beds in a room

The Ultimate Guide to Saatva vs. Stearns: Compare Mattress Brands

When shopping for a high-quality mattress, the comparison between Saatva and Stearns & Foster is often top on the list for consumers seeking luxury and comfort. Both brands are renowned for their exceptional craftsmanship and premium materials, but they cater to different preferences and needs.

Saatva provides affordable luxury, eco-friendly materials, and an extended trial period, while Stearns & Foster focuses on a luxurious feel, enhanced edge support, and impressive durability. In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the specifics of Saatva vs. Stearns, exploring aspects such as mattress construction, materials, pricing, and company policies.

Saatva vs. Stearns: A Brand Overview

Saatva Brand Overview

Founded in 2010, Saatva has quickly established itself within the mattress industry by offering high-quality, luxury mattresses directly to consumers through an online platform. This model not only keeps costs lower but also creates a more seamless customer experience. The company takes pride in producing its mattresses in the USA, ensuring that high manufacturing standards are upheld while also supporting local jobs.

Aiming to cater to environmentally conscious consumers, Saatva uses eco-friendly materials including organic cotton covers and recycled steel coils. Additionally, Saatva offers around-the-clock support via non-commissioned sleep guides, ensuring customers have assistance whenever needed.

Stearns & Foster Brand Overview

In contrast, Stearns & Foster boasts a rich history dating back to 1846, making it one of America’s oldest mattress brands. Originally producing cotton-filled mattresses, the company eventually evolved to include luxurious materials like horsehair and wool. Acquired by Tempur-Sealy in the 1980s, Stearns & Foster has maintained a focus on luxury while integrating modern technologies into its offerings.

Stearns & Foster mattresses are available through both online channels and third-party retailers, which can affect pricing and policies. Their customer service operates Monday through Friday, with limited availability on weekends, potentially a drawback for some buyers.

Both brands are exemplary choices for a high-quality sleep experience, but how do their constructions and materials compare? Let’s take a closer look.

Mattress Construction and Materials

Saatva Mattress Construction

The distinctive feature of Saatva mattresses is their coil-on-coil construction, which balances support and comfort. This system includes a sturdy base layer of steel coils paired with a top layer of individually wrapped coils that contour to your body, enhancing support while promoting airflow for a cooler sleeping experience.

Comfort Layers:

Saatva’s design incorporates a plush 3-inch Euro pillow top made from memory foam, providing additional cushioning while maintaining essential spinal alignment. This pillow top is encased in breathable organic cotton, ensuring a refreshing and eco-friendly sleep surface.

Lumbar Support:

A notable feature is the zoned support system, which incorporates a high-density memory foam strip in the center of the mattress, offering targeted lumbar support beneficial for those with back issues.

Stearns & Foster Mattress Construction

Stearns & Foster mattresses are constructed with an emphasis on luxury and resilience, featuring their proprietary IntelliCoil® HD system. This unique coil-within-coil design adapts to the shape and weight of your body, providing tailored support.

Comfort Layers:

A standout aspect of Stearns & Foster mattresses is the TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam, which delivers excellent contouring and pressure relief. The TENCEL™ cover, crafted from eucalyptus wood pulp, not only offers a cool-to-the-touch feel but also manages moisture efficiently.

Edge Support:

Stearns & Foster enhances edge support with an additional layer of coils, ensuring that you can sit or sleep near the edges without feeling unstable.

Both Saatva and Stearns & Foster offer premium constructions designed to elevate your sleep experience. The eco-conscious materials and thoughtful designs of Saatva create an appealing option for those focused on sustainability, while Stearns & Foster’s superior comfort and quality resonate with luxury seekers.

Firmness and Feel: Saatva vs. Stearns

Understanding the firmness and feel of each mattress is vital for selecting the best fit for your sleeping style. Both brands offer various firmness levels to accommodate diverse preferences.

Saatva Firmness and Feel

Saatva mattresses come in three distinct firmness options:

Plush Soft: Ideal for side sleepers and lighter individuals, this option provides a softer, more cradling level of comfort while relieving pressure points.

Luxury Firm: This most popular firmness level caters to various sleeping styles, striking a balance between comfort and support, rated around a 7/10 on the firmness scale.

Firm: Designed for stomach sleepers or heavier individuals needing extra support, this option provides minimal sinkage, rated around an 8/10 for optimal spinal alignment.

Stearns & Foster Firmness and Feel

Stearns & Foster offers a selection of four firmness levels within its Lux Estate line:

Medium: A versatile choice that provides a balanced feel suitable for many sleepers.

PT Soft: Ideal for side sleepers who require extra cushioning for their shoulders and hips.

PT Medium: Offers medium firmness with a plush pillow top, making it great for back and side sleepers wanting a touch of softness.

PT Firm: This option caters specifically to back and stomach sleepers seeking maximum support, complemented by a soft pillow top.

Performance and Durability

Saatva Performance

Motion Isolation: Saatva does well to isolate motion, though its traditional innerspring construction may allow some transfer if your partner moves in bed.

Edge Support: The dual coil system excels in providing robust edge support, enabling you to utilize the full surface of the bed comfortably.

Cooling Features: Saatva’s design prioritizes breathability, featuring a coil-on-coil setup that enhances airflow, making it ideal for hot sleepers.

Lifespan: These mattresses are built to withstand between 8 to 10 years, depending on maintenance and usage.

Stearns & Foster Performance

Motion Isolation: Known for its superior motion isolation, the TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam and coils work together to minimize disruptions, perfect for couples.

Edge Support: The extra layer of coils bolsters edge stability, allowing more room to sit or sleep without rolling off.

Cooling Features: With its TENCEL™ cover and air vent design, this mattress excels at temperature regulation.

Lifespan: Designed for durability, Stearns & Foster mattresses can last over a decade.

Ultimately, Saatva’s traditional construction and eco-friendly features compete well against Stearns & Foster’s luxurious offerings, making both brands exceptional in terms of performance.

Pricing and Value

Let’s take a closer look at pricing, which is often a deciding factor.

Saatva Pricing

Here’s a breakdown of Saatva‘s pricing:

Twin: $1,095
Twin XL: $1,395
Full: $1,895
Queen: $1,995
King: $2,495
California King: $2,495
Split King: $2,790

Saatva also includes complimentary white glove delivery and charges a reasonable $99 return fee.

Stearns & Foster Pricing

Stearns & Foster’s prices, however, sit at the higher end:

Twin XL: $3,499
Queen: $3,599
King: $4,199
California King: $4,199
Split King: $6,998

Their return fee is $175, catering to a more limited 90-night sleep trial.

Value Comparison

In terms of value, Saatva excels with its more accessible pricing across the board and a more favorable trial and return policy. This advantage makes Saatva the clear choice for those looking for premium features without the burden of high costs.

Conclusion

Deciding between Saatva and Stearns & Foster ultimately hinges on your individual sleep needs and preferences. Both brands provide luxurious mattresses, but Saatva’s eco-friendly designs and consumer-friendly trial policies may appeal more to budget-conscious shoppers who still desire quality. Conversely, Stearns & Foster is ideal for those prioritizing premium materials and enhanced support features.

Evaluate your sleeping habits, preferences, and budget, and you’re sure to find the perfect mattress that suits you. For more detailed comparisons and to explore our extensive range of mattresses, visit the Yawnder mattress collection. Sweet dreams await!

author avatar
Ben Trapskin
I have carefully studied and evaluated many mattresses, sheets, pillows, duvet inserts, comforters, sleep gadgets, and adjustable beds for over a deca... Full Bio

Recent Posts

All
keetsa mattress

Keetsa Mattresses: Best Eco-Friendly Options for Better Sleep

08/05/2025
sleep dog

SleepDog RV Mattresses: Must-Have Comfort for Effortless Sleep

08/05/2025
sleep fresh mattress

SleepFresh Mattress: Stunning Quality for Ideal Comfort

08/05/2025
Pod 3 Cover

Eight Sleep Pod 4 Ultra: Stunning Sleep Upgrade Worth It!

07/21/2025

Have Questions?

Text us at 858-232-5760 for assistance. We’re happy to help!

Mattress Reviews and Guides