Nectar is the safer buy and the better long-term value. Lull's sale prices are genuinely low — $339 for a Twin, $708 for a Queen — but they are discounted off inflated list prices, and the trade-off is a shorter trial and a 10-year warranty against Nectar's 365 nights and lifetime Forever Warranty. Over five years of real use, the Nectar Classic Hybrid at $849 is the bed we would still be sleeping on: pocketed coils hold their support long after an all-foam budget bed has developed a body impression. Buy Lull if you need the cheapest usable Twin or guest bed on the market today. Buy Nectar if this is the bed you sleep on every night. Yawnder Score: 4.5/5.
Lull vs. Nectar (2026): Five Years of Testing, Re-Priced This Week
Lull's discounts look enormous — a Twin marked from $998 down to $339 — because the list prices are fiction. Nectar's are stable and public. We priced both lineups off the brands' own size selectors and looked at what actually survives five years of use.
These are two of the most similar mattresses in the category. Both are three-layer, all-foam, soft-leaning medium beds around 10″ to 12″ tall, both ship compressed in a box, both are sold direct online, and both feel like memory foam is supposed to feel. If you lay on them side by side without labels, most people could not reliably tell you which was which.
So the decision comes down to price structure, trial length, warranty, and what happens in year three. That is where they separate, and it is not close.
One note on Lull's pricing before the table: the list prices are not real. A $2,083 list on a Queen all-foam mattress is a marketing anchor — the $708 sale price is what the bed costs and has cost for a long time. That is not a scandal, it is just how Lull merchandises. Judge it on the sale number.
Price, size by size
Lull is cheaper than Nectar at the small sizes and roughly even at Queen and above. Neither brand is expensive.
At Queen the two entry beds are within $9 of each other — so take the one with 365 nights and a lifetime warranty. And for $150 more, the Nectar Classic Hybrid adds the coils that keep a bed supportive in year four.
Check the live Nectar priceWhat five years actually does to these beds
This is the part no launch review covers. Both of these are budget all-foam mattresses, and the failure mode for budget all-foam is the same on every brand: a body impression forms where you sleep, the comfort layer stops rebounding, and the bed goes from supportive to hammock-shaped somewhere between year three and year six. Heavier sleepers get there faster.
Warranties do not usually help, because both brands exclude normal softening and require an impression deeper than about 1″ measured with no weight on the bed. The practical protection is construction, not paperwork — and that means coils.
That is the argument for the Nectar Classic Hybrid at $849 over either $700 foam bed. A pocketed coil unit does not creep the way foam does. Five years in, the hybrid is still doing its job while the foam beds have a visible dip. If you are buying a primary bed you intend to keep, the $150 upgrade is the cheapest insurance in this comparison.
If you are buying a guest room bed, a kid's bed, or a Twin for a bunk, none of this matters much and Lull's $339 Twin is a legitimately good deal.
Feel, cooling and motion
Feel is close to a wash. Both are soft-leaning mediums with slow-response memory foam up top. Lull runs marginally firmer and marginally more responsive; Nectar contours a little deeper at the shoulder. Side sleepers do well on both. Stomach sleepers do poorly on both — if you sleep on your front, neither of these is your bed and you should be looking at a medium-firm hybrid.
Cooling is a wash too, and the honest answer is that neither one is a cooling mattress. Both are solid foam slabs with a cooling-marketed cover, and both trap heat around your torso. Lull's Luxe Hybrid at $1,456 and Nectar's Classic Hybrid at $849 are the respective fixes, and the Nectar is the cheaper way to get airflow by a wide margin.
Motion isolation is excellent on both, which is the one thing budget memory foam does genuinely well. If a partner gets up at 5 a.m., neither of these beds will wake you.
Trial, warranty and the fine print
Nectar gives you 365 nights. Lull gives you 100. Both are free returns with a pickup or donation arranged, and both ask for about 30 nights of break-in before you start a return. A year of trial on a bed that might develop an impression is worth more than a hundred nights, because a hundred nights is not long enough for the failure mode to show up.
Warranty: Nectar's Forever Warranty is lifetime and limited; Lull's is 10 years. Both exclude normal softening. Both require adequate support underneath — on Nectar, a center rail with a leg on Queen and larger, or slats no more than about 3″ apart. Skipping that is how a claim gets denied on either brand, so budget $200–$300 for a real foundation if you do not own one.
Nectar also has a 30-day post-purchase price match, which Lull does not. Given how often both brands move prices, that is real money for anyone willing to send one email.
Buying a guest bed or a Twin and not worried about year five? Lull's $339 Twin is the cheapest usable memory foam mattress we would actually recommend.
Check the current Lull priceQuick verdict by sleep style
Primary bed you plan to keep
365-night trial, lifetime warranty, and a $849 hybrid upgrade that survives year five.
Guest rooms and Twins
$339 for a Twin is the best price in this comparison and the use case forgives everything.
Side sleepers
Contours slightly deeper at the shoulder than Lull's marginally firmer surface.
Couples with a restless partner
Both isolate motion very well — the one thing budget memory foam nails.
Hot sleepers
$849 for pocketed coils. Neither all-foam bed sleeps cool.
Stomach sleepers
Both are too soft. Buy a medium-firm hybrid instead.
Real specs
5-year total cost of ownership
The topper line is why the hybrid is the cheapest bed here over five years despite the highest sticker price. Budget all-foam mattresses usually need help before year five; coil hybrids usually do not.
Pros and cons
What we like
- Lull's $339 Twin is the cheapest memory foam bed we would recommend
- At Queen the two entry beds are within $9 — so Nectar's 365 nights and lifetime warranty are effectively free
- Both isolate partner motion very well
- The $849 Nectar Classic Hybrid is the cheapest bed here across five years of ownership
- Nectar offers a split king; Lull does not
What to watch
- Lull's list prices are inflated anchors — only the sale price is meaningful
- Both all-foam beds will likely develop a body impression before year five
- Neither sleeps cool, and neither warranty covers normal softening
- Neither brand offers white glove delivery or old mattress removal
- Lull's 100-night trial ends before the failure mode would show up
Who should (and shouldn’t) buy it
Buy it if…
- You want a cheap Twin, bunk or guest bed today — buy the Lull Original
- You want the same feel with a full year to decide — buy the Nectar Classic
- You want this bed to still be good in year five — buy the Nectar Classic Hybrid
- You are a side sleeper who likes a memory foam contour
Skip it if…
- You sleep on your stomach — both beds are too soft
- You sleep hot — buy a hybrid instead of either foam bed
- You need the bed carried in and the old one removed
- You want to choose a firmness level — neither brand offers options
Better-value alternatives
- Nectar Classic Hybrid — $849 Queen — Our long-term pick. Coils, airflow and the lowest five-year cost in this comparison.
- Nectar Classic — $699 Queen — Same feel as the Lull for the same money, with 365 nights and a lifetime warranty instead of 100 nights and 10 years.
- Lull Original — $339 Twin — The right answer for a guest room, a bunk bed or a kid's room where year five does not matter.
Frequently asked questions
Is Lull or Nectar better?
Nectar, for a primary bed. At Queen the two are within $9 of each other, and Nectar gives you 365 nights instead of 100 and a lifetime warranty instead of 10 years for the same money. Lull wins at the small sizes — a $339 Twin is the best price in this comparison and a great guest-room or bunk-bed buy.
Are Lull's list prices real?
No. A $2,083 list on a Queen all-foam mattress is a marketing anchor; the $708 sale price is what the bed actually costs and has cost for a long time. Do not treat the crossed-out number as a saving — compare the sale price to Nectar's sale price, which is what we did in the table above.
Do these mattresses sag?
Budget all-foam mattresses generally develop a body impression somewhere between year three and year six, and both of these are budget all-foam mattresses. Heavier sleepers get there faster. Neither warranty covers normal softening — both require an impression deeper than about an inch with no weight on the bed. If you want the bed to hold up, buy a coil hybrid; that is why we point people to the $849 Nectar Classic Hybrid.
Which one sleeps cooler?
Neither, meaningfully. Both are solid foam with a cooling-marketed cover and both hold heat around your torso. The cheapest real fix is the Nectar Classic Hybrid at $849; Lull's own coil answer is the Luxe Hybrid at $1,456.
How do the trials compare?
Nectar gives you 365 nights, Lull gives you 100. Both are free returns with pickup or donation arranged, and both want about 30 nights of break-in first. The longer trial matters here specifically because 100 nights is not long enough for a foam impression to appear.
Do I need a foundation?
Yes — a solid platform or a foundation with slats close together, plus center support on Queen and larger. On Nectar that center rail is a written condition of the Forever Warranty and the most common reason a claim gets denied. Budget $200–$300 if you do not already own one.
Nectar's prices are live right now
The Classic is $699 for a Queen and the Classic Hybrid is $849 — both with 365 nights to decide, free returns and the lifetime Forever Warranty. Promotions rotate weekly, so check the current number before you order.
Shop current Nectar dealsReviewed by Yawnder Reviews — hands-on testing and price tracking from our Yawnder San Diego showroom. Some links earn us a commission at no cost to you.