Best Mattress Stores

Written by

Ben Trapskin

I have carefully studied and evaluated many mattresses, sheets, pillows, duvet inserts, comforters, sleep gadgets, and adjustable beds for over a decade. My insights and evaluations are grounded in both my extensive personal experience and valuable customer feedback. I have expertise and knowledge of the industry. I have used this to conduct detailed assessments of products. My insights and guidance have given consumers the best sleep experience. I am committed to quality and excellence in this field. EXPERT TESTED Every product is tested with a variety methods to give you the best assement of what it will actually feel like and if it is good quality. UPDATED REGULARLY Our reviews are updated daily and we strive to produce the most useful content so you can make an informed decision.


There is no dearth of choices when it comes to buying mattresses, online or offline. You have the option of visiting your local brick and mortar stores. Alternatively, there’s always the choice to sit back and order online. Be warned, there are dozens of brands, and hundreds of stores and that can be confusing to figure out best mattress store. From where do you get the best deal or the mattress of your choice? Read on. This guide should help.

If you live in the San Diego metro area, make sure to check out the Yawnder San Diego mattress showroom where you can try the most popular online brands and get exclusive discounts and offers.

What Factors Matter?

  • Right off the bat, one must say that the word “best” is not very defining but encompasses various parameters such as returns, customer service, prices, delivery and brands. For example, if you are looking for specialist brands or types of mattresses, the best store may not have it in stock. As can be seen, most stores sell popular and fast-moving brands like Sealy, Seta, Tempur-Pedic, Stearns and Foster and Simmons.
  • For some people, returns may be the most important thing. You may buy a mattress online based on its looks, but you will find it uncomfortable. If you have the ease of free returns and a full refund or free exchange you will rate that store to be the best above others that charge processing fees. Mattresses may be good for 3 months after which they are likely to develop hollows due to body weight, and you feel like returning it. In this case, sellers that offer an extended trial period may be to your liking.
  • Then again you may be the type that likes to buy top quality mattresses, and you look for the lowest price. In this case, the store that offers the lowest price with free doorstep delivery is potentially the best for you.
  • A mattress is not something you can tuck under your arm and carry home. Therefore, if you shop at a local brick and mortar store, you want a store that has both varieties in types of mattress and various brands in addition to free delivery. If you find a store in your neighbourhood that satisfies these criteria, then it is the best for you.

Biggest Mattress Stores in US

One advantage of buying from the biggest stores is you are left with a pretty good choice and the best prices. This is possible since these stores buy in bulk and pass on discounts to their customers. They may even offer free delivery to your doorstep and have a fair returns policy.

Walmart: Walmart tops the list with over 5000 outlets nationwide and 11,635 across the world. It deals in Sealy, Simmons, Serta, Signature and Sleep brands of innerspring, hybrid, air and foam mattress with free shipping. Returns may be direct to their warehouse or nearest pickup points.

Mattress Firm: Mattress Firm has around 3,500 outlets. It deals in Serta, Hampton & Rhodes, Dreambed, Lux and Simmons brands of foam, hybrid and innerspring mattresses. Free shipping is offered on mattresses above $499 with a 120-day period for returns plus $79.99 applicable fee.

Big Lots: It has a presence in 1,400 locations and deals mainly in innerspring foam hybrid Serta brand mattresses. You pay around $140 for delivery charges. The returns policy is fair with a 30-day period, but 20% processing fees may apply.

Ashley Homestore: This brand has over 700 stores and deals in innerspring, foam, latex and hybrid mattresses. Brands available are Sealy, Tempur-Pedic, Foster, Simmons and Stearns. As for returns, you must notify Ashley within 72 hours of delivery and only if the mattress is received in damaged or defective condition.

Costco: Costco has a presence in 727 locations. Its product range covers foam, latex, innerspring and hybrid mattress. Brands available are Stearns, Foster, Sleep Science, Eight Sleep, Novaform, Sealy and Simmons. Shipping charges are included in the price and mattress can be returned for a full refund.

Macy’s: Macy’s has a presence in 728 locations and offers free delivery for mattresses priced less than $787, and $85 and above for mattresses priced $787 and above. Innerspring and foam mattresses from popular brands such as Serta, Sealy, Tempur-Pedic, Stearns and Foster-Simmons are all available. You have 180 days to return the product.

Sam’s Club:  Buy innerspring, Foam, hybrid and water mattresses in Serta, Tempur-Pedic, Night Therapy and Sleep innovation brands. Free delivery is available as is the removal of an old mattress. If you are a member, then you have the facility of free return to any of their 666 stores. They offer a 90-night free sleep trial and 10 days to report a defective mattress if you want a refund.

Sears: Sears offers several brands that include Serta, Sealy, Stearns and Foster, Tempur Pedic and Simmons. This includes innerspring, foam, latex, hybrid and air mattresses with free delivery. You have between 30 to 60 days to return the mattress. A 120-night sleep trial is available on select products.

IKEA: This famous brand of home furnishing company has 400 outlets offering its inimitable Ikea brand foam, latex and innerspring mattress. Delivery charges start at $ 59, and you have 365 days for returns.

Sleep Number/Select Comfort: You have a choice of 477 outlets from where to buy Sleep Number, and Comfortaire branded air mattress. You pay $90 for standard delivery and $180 for in-home setup with a 100-night sleep trial. However, mattresses can be returned after 30 days.

Medium to Small Mattress Stores in The US

American Mattress: American Mattress has 100 stores in Illinois and Indiana offering Sealy, Serta, Tempur Pedic, Simmons, Restonic brand innerspring, foam and hybrid mattresses. Delivery charges vary from $59.99 to $299.99 for out of state deliveries. They offer sleeping trials ranging between 30 to 90 nights. Out of state deliveries do not qualify for returns and exchanges.

Bob’s Discount Furniture: Bob’s deals only in Bob-O-Pedic brand innerspring, foam, latex and hybrid mattresses offered through 84 outlets. Delivery charges start at $9.99 and can go up to $ 329.99. On offer is a 90-night sleep trial period during which you can return the mattress for a full refund less the delivery fees.

Denver Mattress: Denver has 90 locations from where you can buy Sealy, Serta, Tempur-Pedic, Stearns and Foster and Simmons brand innerspring, foam, hybrid and latex mattress. Delivery rates vary depending on the location. You receive 100% refund if products are returned within the first 4 months, 75% for the second 4 months and 50% for the final 4 months which means you have a full year.

Havertys: Havertys has 125 outlets offering Sealy, Serta, Tempur-Pedic, Stearns and Foster and Simmons brand foam, hybrid and innerspring mattresses. Shipping charges apply. You may exchange your mattress within 3 days of delivery. No refunds are available so think carefully before you buy.

Mattress Warehouse: You have a choice of over 200 locations from where you can buy Sealy, Serta, Tempur-Pedic, Stearns and Foster, Aireloom, Kingsdown and Simmons brand hybrid, foam and innerspring mattresses. They charge $99 for local delivery and $199 for national delivery. Tempur Pedic mattresses have a free delivery offer. As for returns, they go by returns policies of the individual manufacturer. Clearance items are not eligible for any refunds or exchanges.

Rooms to Go: You have a choice of 240 locations to buy innerspring, foam and latex mattress in Sealy, Serta, Tempur-Pedic, Stearns and Foster, Kingsdown, Restonic and Simmons brands with free shipping through UPS. You will need to initiate the returns process within 48 hours of delivery in case of a problem.

Slumberland: Walk into any of their 126 outlets to buy Sealy, Stearns and Foster, Tempur-Pedic and Simmons brand foam, innerspring and hybrid mattresses. Delivery charges vary according to location. No returns but you can exchange mattresses.

Oldest Mattress Stores 

  1. Shifman Mattress Company – Founded in 1893 in Newark, New Jersey, Shifman Mattress Company is one of the oldest and most well-known mattress manufacturers in the United States.

  2. McRoskey Mattress Company – Founded in 1899 in San Francisco, California, McRoskey Mattress Company is another long-standing mattress manufacturer known for its high-quality and handmade mattresses.

  3. Charles P. Rogers – Founded in 1855 in New York City, Charles P. Rogers is one of the oldest bedding and mattress companies in the United States.

It’s worth noting that while these companies have been around for a long time, they may not necessarily be the oldest mattress stores still in operation today, as many older stores may have closed or merged with other companies over time.

The Best Mattress Stores for Returns

IKEA rates the best for returns since it offers a full 365 days for returns and exchange. Denver Mattress also offers 365 days but a 50% deduction if the product is returned during the final quarter.

Stores According to Customer Ratings

The stores above may feature a small or large number of outlets. However, what’s important to know is the customer experience and rating.

  • Standing at the top are Haverty’s and Sit’n’Sleep with a rating of 4 out of 5.
  • A close second is Slumberland with a score of 3.83, Walmart with a score of 3.83 and Denver Mattress with a score of 3.83.
  • Just below are Costco with a score of 3.5, Ikea with a score of 3.58, Macy’s with a score of 3.75, Mattress Firm with a score of 3.25, Rooms to Go with a score of 3.4, Mattress Warehouse scored at 3.33 and Sears at 3.25.

Best Mattress Stores  – Widest range

  • Naturally, American Mattress sits at the top.
  • However, if you want more brands to pick from then, you have Ashley Homestore, Costco, Denver Mattress, Havertys, Macy’s, Mattress Firm, Mattress Warehouse, Rooms to Go, Sam’s Club, Sit’n’Sleep Slumberland and Walmart to choose from.
  • Only a few offer brands are other than the popular ones. These are Sit’n’Sleep offering Aireloom and Kingsdown in addition to the popular brands.
  • Sam’s Club offers Night Therapy and Sleep Innovation
  • Rooms to Go features Kingsdown and Restonic in addition to others;
  • Mattress Warehouse offers Aireloom and Kingsdown along with others
  • Mattress Firm features Dreambed Lux brands.
  • Costco has Novaform besides others.
  • Bob’s Discount, surprisingly, offers only its own brand of Bob-o-Pedic just like Ikea offers its own brand.
  • Big Lots deals only in Serta brand which could possibly mean that this brand is offered at the best price.

The Lowest Rated Mattress Stores

Customers rated Sears, Mattress Firm, Sam’s Club and Big Lots the lowest on several counts. However, keep in mind that this is a generalization. You may be looking for the lowest price; specific type of mattress; free delivery or the best returns policy. Therefore, the lowest rating is not an absolute indicator of all these parameters.

Biggest Online Mattress Stores

  • Amazon occupies top slot, offering Nectar, Leesa,  Lucid, Serta Tuft & Needle and Zinus brand foam, latex, hybrid air-water and innerspring matters with free delivery. You have a 30-night sleep trial period.
  • Costco offers innerspring, foam, latex and hybrid mattresses in Sealy, Serta, Tempur-Pedic, Stearns and Foster and Simmons brands with free delivery.
  • Overstock is one store to consider for innerspring, foam, latex, hybrid and air mattresses in Sealy, Serta, Tempur-Pedic, Stearns and Foster and Simmons brand. Free delivery in the US but you cannot return mattresses that have been used or removed from packaging.
  • US-Mattress is another online resource for innerspring, latex, foam and hybrid mattresses in Restonic, Sealy, Serta, Tempur-Pedic, Stearns and Foster and Simmons brands. Free delivery is available nationwide in the US. You get a 100-night sleep trial with exchange facility but no returns. If you exchange a mattress, you pay any price difference if the one you choose is a higher priced one, in addition to $139 processing fee.

Best Better Business Rated Online Stores

  • Amazon scores only a B+ in Better Business Bureau score but is the highest overall rated store due to a wider selection, excellent prices, customer services and delivery.
  • Overstock scores high A+ Better Business Bureau score in addition to a good range of mattresses, good pricing, customer services and delivery.
  • Walmart has an A+ Better Business Bureau rating in addition to excellent price range, customer service and delivery but falls down in the range of mattress available.
  • Similarly, Costco has good prices and very good delivery but only fair customer service and limited range of products giving it an overall 3.4 out of 5 despite a+ Better Business Bureau score.
  • US-Mattress edges out Costco despite an A- Better Business Bureau score due to good customer services, prices and delivery as well as a goodly selection of products.
  • Sam’s Club, despite an A- Better Business Bureau rating, and very good prices, customer service and delivery, sits at the bottom due to the limited product range.

Free delivery

  • Not all stores are in a position to offer free delivery because mattresses are bulky products. However, you have Macy’s that offers conditional free delivery for mattresses priced less than $787.
  • In the same way, Mattress Firm will ship mattresses free of cost provided it costs over $ 499.
  • Returns to Go offers free delivery but only through UPS so how fast you receive the mattress is the question.
  • In that regard, Sam’s Club may rate high because most locations are offered free delivery that includes unpacking and removal of the old mattress.
  • Sears offers standard free delivery, which is a good thing.
  • Sit’n’Sleep will deliver free mattresses costing $399 or above.

So, there you have it. Now it is for you to pick the mattress store that is best for you.