The #1 Definitive Guide to Comparing Avocado vs. Saatva Luxury Mattresses in 2024

Avocado vs. Saatva is a common comparison for those searching for the perfect mattress that balances eco-friendliness, support, and budget.

Quick Comparison:
– Avocado Green Mattress: Best for hot sleepers, eco-conscious individuals, and those who prefer a bouncier feel.
– Saatva Classic Mattress: Best for those seeking varied firmness options, luxurious hotel-like beds, and strong lumbar support.

Welcome to Yawnder‘s definitive guide on comparing Avocado and Saatva mattresses! If you’re pondering which of these two popular brands suits your needs, you’re in the right place.

Both mattresses offer outstanding features and have carved niches in the market. The Avocado Green Mattress stands out for its commitment to organic and natural materials, making it a go-to choice for eco-conscious sleepers. On the other hand, the Saatva Classic Mattress excels in providing a luxurious feel with robust support and customizable firmness options.

I’m Ben Trapskin, the founder of Yawnder. My journey through countless mattress purchases and my dedication to quality sleep have armed me with valuable insights into Avocado vs. Saatva. Let’s dive deeper into how these two stack up!

Mattress Construction and Materials

Understanding how a mattress is constructed can help you make a more informed decision. Let’s break down the construction and materials of Saatva and Avocado mattresses.

Saatva Mattress Construction

The Saatva Classic Mattress is known for its coil-on-coil design, which provides a traditional innerspring feel with modern improvements. Here’s a closer look at its layers:

1. Euro-Style Pillow Top: The top layer is a quilted pillow top made from organic cotton. This layer adds a luxurious, soft feel while maintaining breathability.

2. Memory Foam Layer: Directly beneath the pillow top is a layer of memory foam. This layer is designed to offer targeted lumbar support, alleviating back tension and providing pressure relief.

3. Recycled Steel Coils: The middle layer consists of individually wrapped coils made from recycled steel. These coils help minimize motion transfer and provide targeted support.

4. Support Coils: The bottom layer features 7-inch high steel support coils shaped like hourglasses. These coils prevent sagging and improve durability.

This combination of materials ensures that the Saatva mattress offers excellent support and comfort, making it suitable for a wide range of sleepers.

Avocado Mattress Construction

The Avocado Green Mattress takes a different approach, focusing on natural and organic materials. Here’s how it’s built:

1. Organic Cotton Cover: The cover is made from breathable organic cotton, certified by GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard). It’s soft to the touch and eco-friendly.

2. Natural New Zealand Wool: Just beneath the cover, you’ll find a layer of natural wool. This material helps regulate temperature and adds a layer of plush comfort.

3. Organic Latex Foam: The next layer is 2 inches of GOLS (Global Organic Latex Standard) certified Dunlop latex. This latex is sustainably sourced and processed without chemicals, providing both support and pressure relief.

4. Individually Wrapped Coils: The core of the mattress features 8-inch supportive upcycled steel coils. These coils are individually wrapped to offer zoned support and reduce motion transfer.

5. Dunlop Latex Base: The bottom layer is another inch of firmer Dunlop latex, adding durability and support to the mattress.

The Avocado mattress is also reinforced with stronger coils around the perimeter, offering exceptional edge support.

In summary, both mattresses use high-quality materials, but they cater to different preferences. The Saatva focuses on luxurious comfort and support with its coil-on-coil design and memory foam layers. The Avocado emphasizes natural, organic materials and zoned support, making it ideal for eco-conscious sleepers.

Next, let’s explore how these construction differences translate into firmness and feel.

Firmness and Feel

Firmness Levels

When comparing Avocado vs. Saatva, one of the first things you’ll notice is the range of firmness options available.

Saatva offers three firmness levels: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. Here’s how they rate:

• Plush Soft: Around 4 out of 10 on the firmness scale. Ideal for sleepers who prefer a softer, more cushiony feel.
• Luxury Firm: Rated at 6.5 out of 10, hitting the industry standard for medium-firm. This is a versatile option that suits most sleepers.
• Firm: Around 8 out of 10, perfect for those who need extra support and prefer a very firm surface.

Avocado, on the other hand, provides two main firmness options:

• Standard: Around 7 out of 10. This is slightly firmer than the medium-firm benchmark, making it great for back and stomach sleepers.
• With Pillow Top: This version softens the feel to about 6.5 out of 10, aligning closely with Saatva’s Luxury Firm option. It’s a good choice for side sleepers needing extra cushioning.

Feel and Comfort

Bounce and Motion Isolation

Both mattresses offer a good amount of bounce, thanks to their coil systems. The Saatva excels in this area with its dual-coil construction, providing a responsive and bouncy feel. However, this can lead to higher motion transfer, meaning you might feel your partner’s movements.

The Avocado also has good bounce due to its latex foam, which is naturally springy. This mattress handles motion isolation better, making it a good choice for couples.

Edge Support

Edge support is crucial for those who like to sit or sleep near the edge of the bed. The Saatva uses foam railing edges, which offer excellent support and prevent sagging. The Avocado reinforces its edges with stronger coils, also providing exceptional edge support.

Pressure Relief

When it comes to pressure relief, the Saatva stands out with its plush Euro-style pillow top and thick comfort layers. This design offers excellent contouring, especially for side sleepers. The Avocado also provides good pressure relief, thanks to its zoned support system and latex foam, but it’s slightly less plush compared to the Saatva.

Temperature Regulation

Both mattresses excel in temperature regulation. The Saatva uses a breathable coil system and cooling memory foam, making it a great option for hot sleepers. The Avocado relies on its natural materials like latex and wool, which are naturally cooling and moisture-wicking.

Performance for Different Sleepers

When it comes to choosing a mattress, it’s crucial to consider how it performs for different types of sleepers. Here, we’ll explore how the Saatva and Avocado mattresses stack up for side sleepers, back sleepers, stomach sleepers, and individuals of various weights.

Saatva Performance

Stomach Sleepers: The Saatva mattress, especially the Firm model, is a top choice for stomach sleepers. Its firm support prevents the hips from sinking too much, which helps maintain proper spinal alignment. This is crucial for avoiding lower back pain.

Back Pain: Many back sleepers find relief on the Saatva, thanks to its excellent lumbar support. The coil-on-coil construction and memory foam layer work together to keep the spine in a neutral position.

Seniors: Seniors often need a mattress that offers both support and ease of movement. The Saatva‘s responsive coils make it easy to get in and out of bed, while its pressure-relieving memory foam provides comfort.

Motion Transfer: The Saatva does transfer some motion due to its innerspring construction. If you sleep with a restless partner, you might feel their movements. However, the Luxury Firm and Plush Soft models do a slightly better job at minimizing this.

Avocado Performance

Side Sleepers: The Avocado mattress is a great option for side sleepers, especially with the optional pillow top. The natural latex provides a good balance of support and cushioning for the shoulders and hips, which is essential for side sleepers.

Back Sleepers: Back sleepers will appreciate the balanced feel of the Avocado. Its zoned support system helps maintain spinal alignment, making it a good choice for those who suffer from back pain.

Hot Sleepers: If you tend to sleep hot, the Avocado is a standout option. Its natural materials like latex and wool are inherently cooling and moisture-wicking, helping you stay comfortable throughout the night.

Natural Cooling: The Avocado‘s natural latex and wool layers excel at regulating temperature. This makes it a great option for hot sleepers who need a mattress that stays cool.

Zoned Support: The Avocado features zoned support, which means it provides targeted support to different areas of the body. This is particularly beneficial for back sleepers who need extra lumbar support.

In the next section, we’ll compare the pricing and value of the Saatva and Avocado mattresses to help you decide which offers the best bang for your buck.

Pricing and Value

Saatva Pricing and Policies

When it comes to price comparison, Saatva offers a range of prices that are generally more affordable than Avocado. A queen size Saatva Classic mattress is priced at $1,574. Saatva often runs sales, so you can usually find discounts up to $250.

Trial Period and Warranty: Saatva provides a 365-night trial period, giving you a full year to decide if the mattress is right for you. They also offer a lifetime warranty, one of the most generous in the industry.

Shipping and Return Policy: Saatva includes free white glove delivery with every mattress purchase. This means they will deliver, set up your new mattress, and remove your old one at no extra charge. If you decide to return the mattress within the trial period, Saatva will issue a full refund minus a $99 processing fee.

Avocado Pricing and Policies

Avocado mattresses are known for their premium, eco-friendly materials, which come at a higher price point. A queen size Avocado Green mattress is priced at $1,599. Like Saatva, Avocado also offers discounts, often up to $200.

Trial Period and Warranty: Avocado matches Saatva with a 365-night trial period, allowing you ample time to test the mattress. They offer a 25-year warranty, which is shorter than Saatva‘s but still substantial.

Shipping and Return Policy: Avocado provides free shipping on all their mattresses. Unlike Saatva, Avocado does not charge a fee for returns during the trial period, making it a more cost-effective option if you decide the mattress isn’t for you.

Customer Reviews and Feedback

Saatva Customer Feedback

Customer Experiences:
Many users appreciate Saatva‘s lumbar support and customizable firmness options. For instance, one reviewer with herniated discs praised the Luxury Firm model for providing the right balance of support and comfort.

Satisfaction and Complaints:
While Saatva has a high rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars from over 40,000 reviews, some customers have reported issues. Common complaints include sagging within a few months and discomfort leading to back pain. For example, one customer mentioned that their Luxury Firm mattress started sagging after just 2.5 months, causing significant discomfort.

Durability:
Durability is a mixed bag. While some customers rave about the long-lasting comfort, others report sagging and lumps. One user noted that their mattress began to sag within six months, and even a replacement showed the same issue.

Comfort:
Comfort levels vary widely. Some find Saatva‘s mattresses too firm or too soft. For instance, one user switched from the Luxury Firm to the Plush Soft model because the former was too firm.

Motion Transfer:
Saatva mattresses are generally good at motion isolation, thanks to their dual-coil construction. However, some customers feel the springs can be “jabby” and disrupt sleep, especially for side sleepers.

Customer Service:
Saatva’s customer service receives mixed reviews. Some users appreciate the white glove delivery and easy setup, while others report long wait times and unhelpful responses. One customer mentioned waiting 25 minutes to connect with an agent via live chat.

Avocado Customer Feedback

Customer Experiences:
Avocado users often highlight the brand’s commitment to organic materials. One user, a fan of eco-friendly products, praised the absence of harmful chemicals like fiberglass.

Satisfaction and Complaints:
Avocado has a solid rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars from over 17,000 reviews. However, some customers find the mattress too firm. One user mentioned needing a separate topper to make the mattress comfortable for side sleeping.

Durability:
Durability is generally a strong point for Avocado. Users report minimal sagging even after years of use. One customer noted that their Avocado mattress only became more comfortable over two years, with no signs of sagging.

Comfort:
Comfort levels are generally high, especially for those who prefer a firmer mattress. However, some side sleepers find it too firm without an additional topper. A user mentioned adding a $150 topper to their Avocado mattress, making it perfect for side sleeping.

Customer Service:
Avocado’s customer service is generally rated as satisfactory. While initial interactions may involve a bot, users can quickly connect with a human agent. One user appreciated the quick response when they needed assistance.

Frequently Asked Questions about Avocado vs. Saatva

What is similar to Saatva?

If you’re considering the Saatva mattress but want to explore other options, several brands offer similar features. DreamCloud and Leesa are popular alternatives known for their hybrid designs and luxurious feel. Casper and Puffy offer a more affordable yet comfortable experience with their memory foam constructions. Purple is another standout, known for its unique Hyper-Elastic Polymer grid that provides excellent pressure relief and support.

Does Avocado mattress have formaldehyde?

No, the Avocado mattress is formaldehyde-free. It holds multiple certifications, including GREENGUARD Gold, ensuring that it meets strict standards for low chemical emissions. This makes it a safe choice for those concerned about indoor air quality and chemical exposure.

Are Saatva mattresses healthy?

Saatva mattresses are designed with health and safety in mind. They are fiberglass-free and made from non-toxic materials. While they may not have as many organic certifications as Avocado, Saatva does use eco-friendly materials like recycled steel coils and CertiPUR-US certified foams, which are free from harmful chemicals. This ensures a healthier sleeping environment.

Conclusion

When comparing Avocado vs. Saatva, it’s clear that both brands offer unique benefits custom to different preferences and needs. Here’s our final take:

Final Thoughts

Avocado stands out for its commitment to eco-friendly and organic materials. If you prioritize sustainability and natural products, Avocado is a solid choice. Its use of GOTS-certified wool, GOLS-certified latex, and eco-INSTITUT-certified materials ensures you’re getting a mattress that’s good for both you and the environment.

Saatva, on the other hand, excels in providing luxury comfort with a focus on support and customizability. With options like the Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm models, Saatva caters to a wide range of sleepers. Its dual-coil construction and specialized lumbar support make it an excellent choice for those needing extra back support.

Recommendations

• For Eco-Conscious Shoppers: Choose Avocado. Its organic materials and certifications make it a top pick.
• For Those Needing Extra Support: Saatva is ideal. The coil-on-coil construction and lumbar support are designed to relieve back pain and provide excellent support.
• For Customizability: Saatva’s range of firmness options (Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, Firm) ensures you can find a mattress that suits your specific comfort needs.

Trial Periods and Warranties

Both Avocado and Saatva offer generous 365-night sleep trials, giving you ample time to decide if the mattress is right for you. However, Saatva charges a $99 transportation fee for returns, while Avocado offers free returns.

• Saatva Warranty: Lifetime warranty, which speaks to its durability and the company’s confidence in its product.
• Avocado Warranty: 25-year warranty with some prorated costs as time goes on, still providing long-term protection for your investment.

Yawnder’s Take

At Yawnder, we value both eco-friendly practices and luxurious comfort. Whether you choose Avocado for its natural materials or Saatva for its customizable comfort, you’re making a quality investment in your sleep.

For more information on other mattress options, visit our mattress category page.

In conclusion, both Avocado and Saatva offer exceptional mattresses, but the best choice depends on your personal preferences and needs. Happy sleeping!