SweetNight sent me its Original adjustable foam pillow and a pair of Melody down-alternative pillows for the original review. I liked the ability to change their fill, but they have very different feels. The impressions and photos here describe those earlier samples; the current collection may use different names or construction.
My experience with the original pillows
The pillows arrived compressed in plastic. After opening, they expanded quickly. The Original foam pillow initially looked overfilled and uneven; removing some of the fill made it easier to tune the height. Both samples had zippers that let me reach their filling.
What stood out in the Original was the fill: rather than irregular scraps, my sample contained neat, consistently cut foam cubes. I liked the ability to adjust the height and found the feel appealing for side sleeping. Your ideal loft depends on your body and mattress, so start with a little adjustment and test it in your normal position.
The Melody had a softer, more familiar down-alternative feel. I liked that I could remove some of its polyester fill too. It seemed like a practical option for a guest room, where different sleepers may prefer a traditional pillow rather than a foam feel.
These are impressions of samples I received for the original review, not a new test of the present-day range. Prices and terms I reported at the time are historical.
Original foam vs. Melody down alternative
| Consideration | Original sample | Melody sample |
|---|---|---|
| Fill | Removable pieces of foam | Down-alternative polyester fiber |
| Feel I noticed | More foam-like and supportive | Softer and more traditional |
| Adjustment | Zipper allowed me to remove fill | My sample also had a zipper and removable fill |
| Best starting point | Someone who wants a tunable foam feel | Someone who prefers a plush fiber pillow |
A SweetNight comparison page describes older Original and Melody designs, but its product and trial language may not match today’s collection or policy. Verify the exact item and construction with the seller.
How to choose your pillow height
- Side sleepers: consider enough loft to fill the space between shoulder and head, while accounting for how much the mattress compresses.
- Back sleepers: a moderate height is a useful starting point; avoid pushing the chin uncomfortably toward the chest.
- Stomach sleepers: a thinner pillow may be easier to accommodate.
- Combination sleepers: try your usual positions and keep any removed fill clean and dry for later adjustments.
Gel foam and a breathable cover do not guarantee a cool night. We have no temperature measurements for the current versions. If neck pain persists, a pillow is not a substitute for appropriate medical advice.
What SweetNight sells now
The current SweetNight pillow collection lists products including CoolNest Ergonomic, Cooling Memory Foam and Comfort pillows. Those names do not establish that a present-day listing is identical to the Original or Melody samples I received. Check fill, size, adjustability and the care label for the specific product.
Price, care and returns
Current prices and pack sizes change. Compare the final price per pillow and whether the cover or inner fill can be washed; follow the label on your particular model. Do not place loose foam in a washer or dryer unless the maker’s instructions explicitly permit it.
SweetNight’s current direct-purchase policy says eligible unopened pillows may be returned within 30 days; opened or used pillows are covered for qualifying warranty defects rather than comfort returns. The page also explains how it defines unopened. Its mattress trial is different, and an older pillow comparison page mentions different terms. Confirm the policy in writing for your exact order; other retailers set their own terms.
Frequently asked questions
Can you remove fill from both pillows?
Both of my original samples had zippers and removable fill. Check the current listing because designs can change.
Is the foam pillow guaranteed to sleep cool?
No. My earlier sample was marketed with a cooling cover and gel foam, but feel varies and we have not measured the current model’s temperature.
Can I try a SweetNight pillow for 100 nights?
Do not assume so. SweetNight’s current return policy distinguishes pillows from mattresses and limits comfort returns for opened pillows. Verify current terms before ordering.
Related reading: My SweetNight mattress review.