Saatva vs. Stearns: Top 7 Ultimate Comparison 2024

When it comes to high-quality mattresses, Saatva vs. Stearns is a common comparison for shoppers seeking luxury and comfort. Both brands are renowned for their craftsmanship and use of premium materials. Here’s a quick rundown to address your search intent:

• Saatva offers affordable luxury, more eco-friendly materials, and a longer trial period.
• Stearns & Foster excels in luxury feel, sturdier edge support, and long-lasting durability.

At Yawnder, we aim to provide honest and straightforward advice to help you make the best decision for your sleep needs. In this guide, we’ll dive deep into the specifics, comparing everything from mattress construction and materials to pricing and company policies.

I’m Ben Trapskin, the founder of Yawnder. I’ve spent years vetting mattresses to find the best ones for a good night’s sleep. Let’s explore the details of Saatva vs. Stearns to figure out which mattress is right for you.

Quick look at *Saatva vs. Stearns *:

• Saatva Classic Mattress Review
• Saatva vs. Purple
• Saatva Latex Hybrid Mattress

Saatva vs. Stearns: Brand Overview

Saatva Brand Overview

Saatva was founded in 2010 by Ron Rudzin and Ricky Joshi. This company quickly made a name for itself in the mattress industry by focusing on delivering high-quality, luxury mattresses directly to consumers online. Unlike traditional mattress companies, Saatva operates primarily through its website, which helps keep costs down and allows for a more streamlined customer experience.

Saatva mattresses are made in the USA, ensuring high manufacturing standards and supporting local jobs. The company prides itself on its eco-friendly materials, such as organic cotton covers and recycled steel coils. This focus on sustainability is a significant selling point for environmentally conscious buyers.

In terms of customer service, Saatva offers non-commissioned sleep guides available 24/7 to answer any questions you might have. This around-the-clock support ensures you can get help whenever you need it, making the buying process as smooth as possible.

Stearns & Foster Brand Overview

Stearns & Foster has a long history dating back to 1846, making it one of the oldest mattress brands in the United States. Founded by George S. Stearns and Seth C. Foster, the company originally made cotton-filled mattresses and later evolved to include luxurious materials like horsehair and wool. Over the years, Stearns & Foster has become synonymous with luxury and quality.

In the 1980s, Stearns & Foster was acquired by Tempur-Sealy, one of the largest mattress manufacturers in the world. This acquisition helped the brand incorporate modern materials and advanced mattress technology while maintaining its luxurious feel. Today, Stearns & Foster offers a range of high-end mattresses, including innerspring and hybrid models.

Stearns & Foster mattresses are sold both online and in-store through third-party retailers. This means that prices and policies can vary depending on where you make your purchase. The brand’s customer service is available Monday to Friday during business hours, but they are closed on weekends, which might be a drawback for some customers.

Whether you prefer the modern, eco-friendly approach of Saatva or the long-standing luxury of Stearns & Foster, both brands offer excellent options for a high-quality sleep experience. Next, let’s dive into the specifics of mattress construction and materials to see how these brands stack up against each other.

Mattress Construction and Materials

Saatva Mattress Construction

Saatva mattresses are known for their coil-on-coil construction, which provides a blend of support and comfort. This system consists of two layers of coils: a base layer of steel coils for durability and a top layer of individually wrapped coils for contouring support. This design not only improves support but also promotes airflow, keeping the mattress cool.

Comfort Layers:
On top of the coil system, Saatva includes a 3-inch Euro pillow top made of memory foam. This layer adds a plush feel while still offering the support needed for proper spinal alignment. The pillow top is covered with an organic cotton cover, which is breathable and eco-friendly.

Lumbar Support:
Saatva incorporates a zoned support system with a high-density memory foam strip in the middle of the mattress. This design offers targeted support to the lower back, making it a great option for those with back pain.

Eco-Friendly Materials:
Saatva’s commitment to sustainability is evident in its use of organic cotton covers and recycled steel coils. The organic cotton cover is not only soft and breathable but also free from harmful chemicals.

Stearns & Foster Mattress Construction

Stearns & Foster mattresses are built with a focus on luxury and durability. The brand uses its proprietary IntelliCoil® HD system, which consists of a coil-within-coil design. This setup provides a responsive feel and adapts to the body’s shape and weight, offering personalized support.

Comfort Layers:
One of the standout features of Stearns & Foster mattresses is the use of TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam. This foam, developed by Tempur-Pedic, is known for its excellent contouring and pressure relief. It sits atop the coil system, creating a plush yet supportive sleep surface. The mattress is also wrapped in a TENCEL™ cover, a fabric made from eucalyptus wood pulp that is cool to the touch and moisture-wicking.

Edge Support:
Stearns & Foster improves edge support by surrounding the mattress with a layer of coils. This feature ensures that the edges are firm, making it easier to sit or sleep near the edge without feeling like you will roll off.

Eco-Friendly Materials:
While Stearns & Foster focuses more on luxury than eco-friendliness, the use of TENCEL™ in the mattress cover is a nod to sustainability. TENCEL™ is more eco-friendly than traditional materials and helps in moisture management and cooling.

Both Saatva and Stearns & Foster offer unique constructions designed to provide comfort and support. Saatva‘s coil-on-coil system and eco-friendly materials make it a great choice for those looking for a sustainable and supportive mattress. On the other hand, Stearns & Foster’s IntelliCoil® HD system and TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam offer a luxurious and adaptive sleep experience.

Next, we’ll examine how these mattresses feel and their firmness options to help you find the perfect match for your sleep needs.

Firmness and Feel

When choosing between Saatva vs. Stearns, understanding the firmness and feel is crucial. Both brands offer multiple firmness levels to cater to various sleeping positions and body types.

Saatva Firmness and Feel

Saatva provides three firmness levels:

• Plush Soft: Ideal for side sleepers and lighter individuals. This option offers a softer, more cradling feel, allowing for deeper sinkage and pressure relief on the shoulders and hips.
• Luxury Firm: This is Saatva‘s most popular option and suits a variety of sleep styles, including back, stomach, and combination sleepers. It’s rated around 7/10 on the firmness scale, offering a balanced mix of comfort and support.
• Firm: Best for stomach sleepers or heavier individuals who need extra support. This option is rated around 8/10 and provides minimal sinkage, ensuring proper spinal alignment.

The Saatva Classic mattress has a traditional innerspring feel, thanks to its coil-on-coil construction. The Euro pillow top adds a touch of plushness without compromising support. This setup makes it easy to move around on the mattress, a feature many back and stomach sleepers appreciate.

Stearns & Foster Firmness and Feel

Stearns & Foster offers four firmness levels in their Lux Estate line:

• Medium: A versatile option suitable for many sleepers. Provides a balanced feel that’s neither too soft nor too firm.
• PT Soft: This is the plushest option, ideal for side sleepers who need extra cushioning for their shoulders and hips.
• PT Medium: Offers a medium-firm feel with the added plushness of a pillow top. It’s suitable for back and side sleepers who want a bit more softness.
• PT Firm: This option is best for back and stomach sleepers who need more support. The pillow top adds a touch of comfort while maintaining a firm overall feel.

The Stearns & Foster Lux Estate mattress features a plush pillow top made from TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam. This material is known for its excellent contouring and pressure relief, offering a cloud-like feel. However, the underlying IntelliCoil® HD system ensures you don’t sink too far, maintaining support and ease of movement.

Sleeping Positions and Body Types

Saatva Luxury Firm: Works well for most average-weight back sleepers. The coils support the spine, preventing misalignment. Side sleepers closer to 230 lb may feel pressure on their shoulders and hips; they might prefer the Plush Soft model. Stomach sleepers should consider the Firm model for better support.

Stearns & Foster PT Medium: Suitable for average-weight back and side sleepers. It provides a good balance of support and comfort. However, stomach sleepers might need the PT Firm option for adequate hip support.

Heavyweight Sleepers:

• Saatva Firm: Ideal for back and side sleepers between 230 and 250 lb. For those over 250 lb, the Saatva HD is a better option.
• Stearns & Foster PT Firm: Suitable for those closer to 230 lb. Heavier individuals might need a mattress designed specifically for heavier people.

Lightweight Sleepers:

• Saatva Classic: Works well for most side sleepers. Back and stomach sleepers may prefer the Luxury Firm model for added support. Lightweight side sleepers should consider the Soft option for more pressure relief.
• Stearns & Foster PT Medium: Suitable for lightweight sleepers of all positions. The plush pillow top ensures adequate support without excessive sinkage.

In summary, both Saatva and Stearns & Foster offer various firmness options to cater to different sleepers. Saatva‘s traditional innerspring feel and multiple firmness levels make it versatile, while Stearns & Foster’s plush pillow tops and TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam provide a luxurious sleep experience.

Next, let’s dive into the performance and durability of these mattresses to see how they hold up over time.

Performance and Durability

Saatva Performance

Motion Isolation: The Saatva Classic does a decent job at isolating motion, thanks to its multiple layers of foam and coils. However, because it has a traditional innerspring feel, you might feel some movement if your partner tosses and turns at night.

Edge Support: Saatva excels in edge support. The dual coil system ensures that the edges are sturdy, allowing you to sit or sleep near the edge without feeling like you’ll roll off. This is especially beneficial for couples who need to maximize their usable bed space.

Cooling Features: Saatva mattresses are designed to sleep cool. The coil-on-coil construction promotes airflow, and the breathable organic cotton cover helps wick away moisture. This makes it a good option for hot sleepers.

Lifespan: The Saatva Classic is built to last between 8 to 10 years. The high-quality materials and robust construction contribute to its durability. However, as with any mattress, the actual lifespan will depend on how well you maintain it.

Stearns & Foster Performance

Motion Isolation: Stearns & Foster mattresses, particularly the Lux Estate models, are excellent at isolating motion. The thick layers of TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam and IntelliCoil® HD system keep movements localized, making it a great choice for couples.

Edge Support: This brand also shines in edge support. The extra layer of coils around the mattress’s perimeter provides exceptional stability. You can sit or sleep near the edge without feeling like you’ll slide off, which maximizes the usable surface area.

Cooling Features: Stearns & Foster Lux Estate mattresses have top-notch cooling features. The TENCEL™ cover is cool-to-the-touch and the air vents throughout the mattress improve airflow. This combination makes it one of the best options for hot sleepers.

Lifespan: Stearns & Foster mattresses are built to last over a decade. The high-quality materials and advanced construction techniques ensure that these mattresses remain supportive and comfortable for many years.

In summary, both Saatva and Stearns & Foster offer excellent performance and durability. Saatva is a strong contender with its traditional innerspring feel, good edge support, and cooling features. On the other hand, Stearns & Foster shines in motion isolation, edge support, and cooling, making it a luxurious and durable option for those willing to invest more.

Pricing and Value

When comparing Saatva vs. Stearns & Foster, pricing and value are critical factors to consider. Let’s break down the costs and see which brand offers the best bang for your buck.

Saatva Pricing

Saatva mattresses are known for being high-quality yet reasonably priced. Here’s a quick look at their pricing:

• Twin: $1,095
• Twin XL: $1,395
• Full: $1,895
• Queen: $1,995
• King: $2,495
• California King: $2,495
• Split King: $2,790
• Split California King: $2,790

Additional Costs:

• Free White Glove Delivery: Saatva includes free white glove delivery, which means they will deliver and set up your new mattress and remove your old one at no extra cost.
• Return Fee: If you decide the mattress isn’t for you, Saatva charges a $99 return fee. This is a small price to pay for the convenience of trying out the mattress for a full 365 nights.

Stearns & Foster Pricing

Stearns & Foster, on the other hand, falls on the higher end of the price spectrum. Here’s a breakdown of their Lux Estate model pricing:

• Twin XL: $3,499
• Queen: $3,599
• King: $4,199
• California King: $4,199
• Split King: $6,998
• Split California King: $6,998

Additional Costs:

• Free White Glove Delivery: Like Saatva, Stearns & Foster also provides free white glove delivery. However, this service is only available if you purchase directly from their website.
• Return Fee: The return fee for Stearns & Foster is higher at $175. This fee applies if you decide to return the mattress within their 90-night trial period.

Value for Money

When it comes to value for money, Saatva has the upper hand. Even their most expensive option, the Split King, is significantly cheaper than Stearns & Foster’s equivalent. Moreover, Saatva offers a longer trial period (365 nights vs. 90 nights) and a more affordable return fee.

Here’s a quick comparison to highlight the value:

In summary, Saatva offers premium features at a more accessible price point, making it a more cost-effective choice for most consumers. On the other hand, Stearns & Foster caters to those willing to pay a premium for luxury and brand prestige.

Company Policies

When comparing Saatva vs. Stearns, it’s crucial to understand their policies on warranties, sleep trials, and returns. These policies can greatly impact your overall satisfaction and peace of mind.

Saatva Policies

Warranty:

Saatva offers a lifetime warranty on their mattresses. For the first two years, if your mattress is deemed defective, Saatva will replace it at no cost. From year three onward, Saatva will repair and re-cover your mattress for a $149 processing fee. This comprehensive warranty ensures long-term protection for your investment.

Sleep Trial:

Saatva provides a generous 365-night trial period. This means you can sleep on the mattress for a full year to decide if it’s right for you. If you’re not satisfied, you can return or exchange the mattress during this period.

Return Policy:

If you decide to return your Saatva mattress within the trial period, there is a $99 processing fee. This fee covers the cost of mattress removal and ensures a hassle-free return experience. Saatva often donates returned mattresses to charity or recycles them, making the process eco-friendly.

Stearns & Foster Policies

Warranty:

Stearns & Foster offers a 10-year warranty on their mattresses. If a defect is found within this period, they will repair or replace the mattress at no cost. However, you may be responsible for any transportation costs associated with the warranty claim.

Sleep Trial:

Stearns & Foster provides a 90-night sleep trial. This allows you to test the mattress for about three months. If you’re not satisfied, you can return or exchange it within this period. Some third-party retailers may offer different trial periods, so it’s important to check their policies.

Return Policy:

Returning a Stearns & Foster mattress incurs a $175 processing fee if done within the trial period. This fee covers the cost of mattress pickup and return logistics. Be sure to purchase directly from their website to take advantage of this policy, as third-party retailers may have different return fees and conditions.

Comparing Policies

Here’s a quick comparison of Saatva and Stearns & Foster policies:

When it comes to policies, Saatva stands out with its lifetime warranty, longer sleep trial, and lower return fee. These factors make Saatva a more flexible and customer-friendly option, especially for those who want ample time to test their mattress and peace of mind with a lifetime warranty.

Frequently Asked Questions about Saatva vs. Stearns

Which mattress is better, Saatva or Stearns & Foster?

Both Saatva and Stearns & Foster offer high-quality, luxurious mattresses, but they cater to different preferences and budgets.

Saatva is ideal for those looking for affordable luxury. It features eco-friendly materials, excellent pressure relief, and great motion isolation, making it perfect for couples. Saatva also has a more traditional innerspring feel, which many people enjoy.

Stearns & Foster, on the other hand, is geared towards luxury shoppers who don’t mind spending more for a premium product. It excels in edge support, temperature regulation, and offers a plush pillow top feel. This mattress is particularly good for back and stomach sleepers and those who sleep hot.

Personal preference and budget considerations play significant roles in deciding between the two. If you prefer a softer top layer and have a higher budget, Stearns & Foster might be the better choice. If you want a more affordable option with excellent support and eco-friendly materials, Saatva is a great pick.

How long will the Saatva and Stearns & Foster mattresses last?

Durability and lifespan are crucial factors when investing in a mattress.

Saatva mattresses are designed to last between 8 to 10 years. They use high-quality materials like organic cotton and coil-on-coil construction, which contribute to their longevity. The lifetime warranty also adds peace of mind regarding long-term durability.

Stearns & Foster mattresses are known for their robust construction and can last over a decade. The IntelliCoil® innersprings and TEMPUR-Indulge™ Memory Foam provide strong support and durability. The 10-year warranty covers any manufacturing defects, ensuring the mattress stands the test of time.

Can you flip the Saatva or Stearns & Foster mattress?

No, you can’t flip either the Saatva or Stearns & Foster mattresses.

Both brands use a specific construction where the coils are at the bottom and the comfort layers are on top. Flipping these mattresses would not provide a comfortable sleeping surface and could damage the mattress structure.

Maintenance involves rotating the mattress every 6 to 12 months to ensure even wear. This simple step can help extend the mattress’s longevity and maintain its comfort and support over time.

Conclusion

In the end, choosing between Saatva and Stearns & Foster boils down to your personal preferences, sleep needs, and budget. Both brands offer luxurious, high-quality mattresses, but they cater to different types of sleepers.

Saatva stands out for its eco-friendly materials, excellent pressure relief, and more affordable luxury. It’s a great choice for those who want a traditional innerspring feel with modern improvements. If you share your bed with a restless partner, Saatva‘s motion isolation is a big plus. Plus, with a generous 365-night trial and lifetime warranty, you can rest easy knowing your investment is protected.

On the other hand, Stearns & Foster is custom for those who are willing to spend more for premium features. It excels in edge support, temperature regulation, and offers a plush, hotel-like feel. If you sleep hot or prefer a firmer mattress, Stearns & Foster might be the better option. Although it comes with a higher price tag, the quality and durability often justify the cost.

Your choice should reflect your sleep style and what you value most in a mattress. Whether you prioritize eco-friendly materials and affordability or luxury and advanced cooling features, both brands have something to offer.

For more detailed comparisons and to explore our range of mattresses, visit our Yawnder mattress collection. Happy sleeping!

By keeping these points in mind, you can make an informed decision that ensures a comfortable and restful night’s sleep.