Pillow Guy White Down Pillow Review
Quick verdict
The Pillow Guy White Down Pillow is a traditional down option for people who like a soft, moldable pillow and are comfortable paying more for natural fill. In the original review, our reviewer liked its finish and compared the softer and overstuffed versions. Down compresses, so people who need a tall, firm pillow may prefer to compare other fills.
Consider it if: you want down and a choice of lofts. Consider another pillow if: you prefer an animal-free fill, adjustable fill or a consistently firm, high loft.
Current product details
Pillow Guy’s current White Down Pillow listing describes 650-fill-power RDS-certified white down, a 230-thread-count cotton shell, Standard/Queen and King sizes, and Soft and Overstuffed profiles. The current listing calls the fill “white down”; confirm the species and any product-specific certification directly with the seller if those details matter to you.
Prices and policies change. Check the selected size and loft, current delivered price, care label and return eligibility before ordering. The original review below describes an earlier sample; its materials and dimensions may not match every current version.
Original review: The descriptions and measurements below refer to an earlier Pillow Guy sample; the current White Down listing may differ.
The Pillow Guy Goose Down Pillow is yet another item part of an incredible line of products from the clever brand Pillow Guy. I received and reviewed free one of their items in the past and was pretty impressed with their Down Alternative Pillow so naturally, I had very high expectations of their Down Pillow. This is a company that targets its items towards men who consider themselves gentlemen and who pride themselves on their good taste.
Overview of the Pillow Guy Goose Down Pillow
While the Pillow Guy only has two pillow types in their inventory, the choice to keep it simple is wise in their case. Their Goose Down pillow comes in two densities, soft and overstuffed. Their pillows are crafted with 100% Certified RDS (Responsible Down Standard) 650 fill power White Goose Down. They’re encased in a down-proof cotton shell and then wrapped in their gorgeous white sateen cover that comes with stunning blue satin piping. The cover has a hidden zipper and truly feels like something a 5-star hotel would supply their guests (and should).
Construction of the Pillow Guy Down Pillow
Pillow Guy wants to separate themselves from the crowd as a company suited more for the elite. That being the case, their terminology can vary a little so keep in mind that a Jumbo pillow is more simply a Queen size pillow.
| Size | Width (in) | Length (in) | Fill weight (oz) |
| Jumbo Soft | 20 | 28 | 22oz |
| King Soft | 20 | 36 | 26oz |
| Jumbo Medium/Firm | 20 | 28 | 28oz |
| King Medium Firm | 20 | 36 | 36oz |
My Pillow Guy Goose Down Pillow Findings
Unlike the Down Alternative pillow, Pillow Guy’s Goose Down Pillow is not made from a synthetic material so there’s quite a process involved in trying to ensure that they’re providing the most desirable product on the market. Their Goose Down Pillows are 100% Certified RDS (Responsible Down Standard) but for those that want further clarification on what that means, the information below is quoted directly from the official RDS website, which can be found at http://responsibledown.org.
—Any removal of down and feathers from live birds (live-plucking or molt-harvesting) is prohibited
—Force-feeding is prohibited
—Holistic respect for animal welfare of the birds from hatching to slaughter
—RDS down and feathers is properly identified; to ensures that non-RDS down and feathers are not mistakenly identified as RDS
—Each stage in supply chain is audited by a professional, third party certification body
—Only products with 100% certified down and feathers carry the RDS logo
If you want to read more about how RDS works, there is more information towards the bottom of the home page on their official site. That’s where they discuss the certification process in further detail.
Another aspect that I really like about these pillows is that they’re priced accordingly. Because Goose Down is a limited resource, it can be costly, which is why I appreciate the fact that their soft pillow, the one with less filling, actually costs less. Not every company is so honest but I believe that the Pillow Guy is and this is just one indication.
One thing I found interesting about this pillow is how different it was in terms of density between the soft and overstuffed pillow. With the Down Alternative pillows this was quite evident but I think that with the Goose Down pillows they’ve drawn the gap a little bit closer. I think this is a positive aspect actually, considering it’s Goose Down which can lose it’s loft over time. This however can be remedied. Down pillows just require their own maintenance in order for them to last long.
My Pillow Guy Down Pillow Recommendation
The Pillow Guy has created another top notch item that they can be proud to have in their inventory. While there is no doubt that I’m a fanatic of their advertising and would love to meet their marketing person, their products make it clear that their money is invested in far more than just their advertising. I rate this pillow an A+.
Down vs. down alternative
Down is an animal-derived fill that can feel light and moldable. Down alternative usually uses synthetic fibers; its feel, care requirements and price vary by product. Neither fill is automatically better for everyone with allergies, and no pillow can guarantee the absence of allergens. Consider your sensitivities and the specific product’s care and cover.
Fill power vs. fill weight: Fill power describes the lofting capacity of down, while fill weight is the amount used. Both can influence feel; more fill does not guarantee the right height for every sleeper. See our pillow reviews for other options.
Frequently asked questions
Is the current pillow goose down?
The current product listing describes RDS-certified white down without identifying its species in the product details we checked. Our original review described its older sample as goose down; ask the seller if species is important to you.
What does RDS mean?
The Responsible Down Standard addresses animal welfare and traceability in certified down supply chains. Check the specific product’s certification and current claims with the seller or Textile Exchange.
Which loft should a side sleeper choose?
The brand positions its Overstuffed option for side and back sleepers. Shoulder width, mattress softness and personal preference affect fit, so compare the options and seller’s return terms.
How should I clean a down pillow?
Follow the label on your exact pillow. If washing is permitted, make sure the fill is completely dry before use or storage.
Can I try it at Yawnder?
Contact the Encinitas showroom before visiting to ask whether the exact pillow is available.
Live pricing and current promotions on the mattresses, bases, and sleep tech we recommend.
Shop current deals