I Love Pillow Review (Discontinued): Gel, Classic & Contour
Yawnder Reviews · Updated October 2026
I Love Pillow Review: Legacy Snapshot
Status: Discontinued. I Love Pillow / I Love My Pillow products are no longer sold by the original brand. This is a historical hands-on review.
Best for: Readers researching the older I Love Pillow / I Love My Pillow models, especially the Contour pillow.
Quick verdict: Our favorite was the Contour model, but this product line has been discontinued.
Watch-outs: MyPillow is a separate brand, not the successor to I Love Pillow or an identical Contour replacement. We have removed the original purchase offers.
Our recommended available alternative: Read the MyPillow review or shop MyPillow on Amazon. Check the size, loft and return policy first.
I Love Pillow is discontinued: what to buy instead
The Gel, Classic Traditional and Contour pillows reviewed here came from the former I Love Pillow brand, which is no longer selling those models. Our earlier impressions are retained for historical reference only.
We recommend considering MyPillow as an available alternative. It is a different brand with different construction, so it is not a one-to-one replacement for the original Contour pillow. See our MyPillow review, or shop MyPillow on Amazon.
October 2026 update: I Love Pillow / I Love My Pillow has discontinued its product line. The original coupons, checkout links and return terms are no longer valid.
I originally received three I Love Pillow designs free of charge to review: the Gel Pillow, Classic Traditional Pillow and Contour Pillow. The following impressions document my original testing and are not a recommendation to purchase discontinued stock.
Original hands-on findings
Contour: Of the three pillows, this was the one I returned to most often. I sometimes sleep on my stomach with an arm underneath the pillow; the lower center of the Contour helped keep my head from resting too high.
Gel: My second favorite was the gel-infused foam version. It felt comparatively soft and less bulky than some other foam pillows, a combination I liked for side sleeping.
Classic Traditional: This felt the most familiar of the three and seemed like a versatile guest-room option during the original review.
Historical trial: The company once advertised a 100-day trial. Those terms no longer apply to current shoppers, since the brand and product line have been discontinued.
What to buy instead
For a pillow you can buy today, I recommend starting with our MyPillow review and shopping MyPillow on Amazon. MyPillow is a separate brand with different materials and shapes. If you specifically need the old Contour cutout, compare designs carefully rather than assuming it will feel the same.
Frequently Asked Questions About Discontinued I Love Pillow
Is the I Love My Pillow Contour Pillow worth it for stomach sleepers?
In the original hands-on test, we liked the Contour for stomach sleeping because the center dip reduced loft under the head. The product is discontinued; this is historical feedback, not a current purchase recommendation.
What can I buy instead of discontinued I Love Pillow?
I Love Pillow and I Love My Pillow refer to the discontinued line reviewed here. MyPillow is an unrelated, currently available brand. For a purchasable alternative, read our MyPillow review and shop MyPillow on Amazon.
What are the best I Love My Pillow options for side sleepers who sleep hot?
In our original test, the former Gel Pillow felt less bulky and softer than some other foam pillows. It is discontinued. Compare current loft and materials of any alternative before shopping.
Does the discontinued I Love Pillow trial still apply?
No. The original company advertised a trial years ago, but that historical policy is not available now. Check the seller's current terms for any alternative.
Can I try discontinued I Love Pillow products in person?
The discontinued I Love Pillow models are not available for purchase through this article. Contact Yawnder's Encinitas showroom to ask which other pillow models can currently be tested in person.
What types of materials does I Love My Pillow use in their products?
This historical review covered the Gel, Classic Traditional and Contour pillows. Those retired specifications are not specifications for the different MyPillow brand.
Want to test this in person? Visit our Encinitas showroom or call 858-232-5760.