Casper vs. Nolah: The Best Must-Have Mattress Comparison 2025

The Ultimate Casper vs. Nolah Comparison: 5 Key Differences to Consider in 2025

When it comes to mattress shopping, the choices can be overwhelming. Two of the most talked-about brands are Casper and Nolah, each offering unique features to enhance your sleep experience. In this in-depth comparison, we will examine five key differences between Casper and Nolah to help you make an informed decision about which mattress may be right for you.

1. Mattress Type and Construction

Both Casper and Nolah provide a variety of mattress types, including all-foam and hybrid options. Understanding these constructions is essential for selecting the right fit for your sleeping style.

Casper Mattress Construction

The Casper Original features a three-layer construction, including:
– Top Layer: 1.5 inches of perforated AirScape™ foam for excellent airflow.
– Middle Layer: 2 inches of zoned memory foam for targeted support.
– Base Layer: 7 inches of high-density foam for durability.

Casper’s hybrids, like the Wave Hybrid Snow, incorporate multiple layers with pocketed coils to add responsiveness and support.

Nolah Mattress Construction

Nolah mattresses, on the other hand, usually include:
– Top Layer: A unique 2-inch layer of AirFoam™, which is designed to provide pressure relief while being more breathable than traditional foam.
– Support Layers: Various models contain transitions and base layers made from high-density foam or pocketed coils, aimed to enhance support and comfort.

Among Nolah’s offerings, the Nolah Natural 11 stands out for its use of eco-friendly materials and natural latex.

2. Cooling Technology: Nolah vs. Casper

Temperature control is vital for a good night’s sleep, especially if you tend to sleep hot. Nolah employs its AirFoam™ technology, which excels at breathability, while its TENCEL cover enhances heat regulation.

Meanwhile, Casper utilizes its AirScape™ foam, designed with perforations to allow for continuous airflow. Both brands perform well, but Nolah has a slight edge in cooling capabilities, particularly for hot sleepers.

3. Firmness Variations: What Works for You?

Understanding firmness is crucial in selecting a mattress that suits your sleeping position.

Nolah’s Firmness and Feel

Nolah typically falls in the medium-soft to medium-firm category, around a 6/10 on the firmness scale. Its softer feel, particularly in the Nolah Original, is best suited for side sleepers who require pressure relief.

Casper’s Firmness and Feel

In contrast, Casper’s mattresses tend to be medium-firm, rated around 7/10, providing a balanced combination of support and comfort. This makes them versatile for back and combination sleepers who appreciate a supportive yet cushioned surface.

4. Target Sleepers: Who Benefits Most?

Different mattresses cater to various sleeping styles:

– Nolah is particularly well-suited for lightweight and side sleepers, thanks to its softer feel, which relieves pressure on hips and shoulders.
– Casper shines for back sleepers and combination sleepers due to its zoned support, which aids in maintaining proper spinal alignment while adapting to your body.

If you share a bed with a partner who has different sleeping preferences, both options offer excellent motion isolation, though Nolah slightly outperforms in this regard due to its conforming foam.

5. Pricing and Value

While both brands deliver quality products, their pricing structures differ.

Nolah Pricing

– Nolah Original 10: $999 for a Queen
– Nolah Signature 12: $1,499
– Nolah Evolution Hybrid 15: $2,499

Nolah’s competitive pricing and frequent discounts make it an excellent option for those on a budget.

Casper Pricing

– Casper Original: $1,295 for a Queen
– Casper Wave Hybrid Snow: Premium option, priced higher
– Casper Nova Hybrid Snow: Another luxurious offering

Casper’s higher price point reflects its advanced technology and reputation but could be worth it for those seeking premium features.

Conclusion: Which Mattress is Right for You?

Selecting between Casper and Nolah ultimately hinges on your unique sleep preferences. If you prefer a softer mattress that provides excellent pressure relief and is particularly suitable for side sleepers, Nolah is likely the better choice. Its use of eco-friendly materials and outstanding customer satisfaction seal the deal for many.

Conversely, if you need a more balanced, medium-firm mattress that excels in support and temperature regulation, Casper’s offerings may be the way to go, particularly for back and stomach sleepers.

Both brands provide advanced features, responsive customer service, and trial periods, ensuring your purchase is risk-free. Ultimately, your choice will depend on your specific needs—whether you’re looking for cooling technology, firmness preference, or budget considerations, both brands aim to support your journey to a restful night’s sleep.

Ben Trapskin

I have carefully studied and evaluated many mattresses, sheets, pillows, duvet inserts, comforters, sleep gadgets, and adjustable beds for over a deca... Full Bio

See Full Bio