When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Products or services may be offered by an affiliated entity. Learn more.

Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow Review

Brooklinen Down Alternative
Best Down Alternative
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Overview of the Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow

Brooklinen seeks to bring a sense of luxury to your life, or to be more specific, your bed. They’ve gained some popularity and after having a chance to try their pillows, I can see why. In addition to down pillows, they also sell down alternative pillows. They come in three different firmness levels and beautifully mimic down alternative pillows but what impresses me most is not what you would expect. 

brooklinen down alternative pillows unboxing

What impresses me most about their brand is not only the product but their lifetime warranty. A lot of companies of this type won’t offer a warranty so that’s the first thing but to then offer a lifetime warranty is a big deal. So Brooklinen, as awesome as your pillows are, it’s the warranty that blows my mind a little more than the pillows do.

Their return period is pretty great too. It’s certainly long enough for you to decide if these pillows are worth your time or not. You actually have one entire year, 365 days, to come to a decision. In this industry, it’s (incredibly) difficult to beat that.

The prices for a down alternative pillow from Brooklinen range from $59 to $79, depending on the size.

Construction of The Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow 

Brooklinen’s Down Alternative pillows are created with synthetic fibers that have been designed to mimic the warmth and texture of natural goose down. This makes them better suited to individuals with allergies.

  • Down Alternative Pillow Standard (20″ × 26″)
  • Down Alternative Pillow King  (20″ × 36″)
  • 400-Thread Pure Long-Staple Cotton Cover
  • 100% Shaved Microfibers
  • Antimicrobial
  • Hypoallergenic

My Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow Findings

My experience with the pillows from Brooklinen was positive overall. I enjoyed the unboxing experience and how straight forward it was. Each pillow having its own encasing was pleasing to see. The way everything was compartmentalized, in my eyes, shows attention to detail and it just felt clean and orderly. Clean freaks (such as myself) love that stuff. Companies should always consider their unboxing experiences. How a person reacts to a package is part of how they’ll react to the product that’s inside it.

brooklinen down alternative pillows packaging

The pillows themselves are wonderful, soft and oh, so comforting. I love down pillows and making good imitations of them is no easy task and these down alternative pillows by Brooklinen are well done. The density of each pillow, from the plush/soft to the medium-firm, and from the medium-firm to the firm, all seemed appropriate. I’m a side sleeper, so there was no way I was going to fall asleep on the softest pillow with the least filling; my neck would have never forgiven me but the moment my head hit the medium-firm pillow, I was sure ready for a nice, long nap. Described as luxury level, their crisp white color confirms that they are cooler than cool but what’s more? How luxurious are they? I’ve inspected hotel pillows in the past; I used to work at one. These pillows are just as good.

brooklinen down alternative pillows side by side comparison

In an industry saturated with custom pillows, regular pillows suddenly seem revolutionary but there’s something to be said for just keeping it simple. Not everyone has time to travel from one zipper to another. Some can never figure out just how they like their pillows; they want the manufacturer to decide for them. There’s freedom in being able to just grab a pillow and get our butts to bed, especially when there is zero thought required.

brooklinen down alternative pillow manufacturer tag

A customizable product is one that is still incomplete when it arrives at the customer’s door. The responsibility is then handed off to the consumer, who needs to add the finishing touches. Standard products like this, that are sold as they are, on the other hand, have zero deficiencies. We perceive them as being “whole” or “complete,” and therefore ready to use and that’s because they are.

Shop Brooklinen 

Brooklinen vs. Leading Brands

Here is a chart comparing the cost of down alternative pillows from Brooklinen, Parachute, Pottery Barn, West Elm, and Restoration Hardware:

RetailerQueen Size PillowKing Size Pillow
Pottery Barn$129$149
West Elm$99$109
Restoration Hardware$149$169

As you can see, the cost of down alternative pillows varies depending on the retailer. Brooklinen and West Elm have the most affordable options, while Restoration Hardware has the most expensive.

It is important to note that this chart is based on a quick online search and may not include all of the options available from each retailer. Additionally, the prices may change over time. It is always best to check with the retailer directly for the most up-to-date information.

Here are some additional factors to consider when choosing a down alternative pillow:

  • Fill material: Down alternative pillows can be filled with a variety of materials, including synthetic fibers, feathers, and buckwheat hulls. The type of filling material will affect the feel and weight of the pillow.
  • Firmness: Down alternative pillows come in a variety of firmness levels, from soft to firm. Choose a firmness level that will support your head and neck in a comfortable position.
  • Size: Down alternative pillows come in a variety of sizes, including standard, queen, and king. Choose a size that will fit your pillowcase and bed.
  • Price: Down alternative pillows can range in price from $50 to $200. Set a budget before you start shopping and choose a pillow that fits your needs and budget.

Benefits of Down Alternative Pillows vs. Down Pillows

Down and down-alternative pillows have jockeyed for position as top contenders for the preferred choice of discerning sleepers worldwide. While traditional down, sourced from the soft under-feathers of ducks and geese, has long been heralded for its luxurious softness and adaptability, down-alternative materials have risen in prominence, offering a host of benefits that sometimes outpace their natural counterpart. Here’s a deep dive into the advantages of down alternative over traditional down pillows:

1. Allergy-Friendly: Perhaps the most significant edge down alternatives have over natural down is their hypoallergenic properties. Many people are allergic to the dust, mites, or proteins found in natural down, causing symptoms such as sneezing, watery eyes, or even more severe allergic reactions. Down alternative pillows, typically made from synthetic materials like polyester, eliminate this concern, providing a safe sleeping environment for allergy sufferers.

2. Cruelty-Free: Ethical considerations come into play for many consumers. Down harvesting, even when labeled as “ethically sourced,” often raises concerns about the welfare of the birds involved. Down alternative pillows, being man-made, offer a cruelty-free choice for the conscientious buyer.

3. Cost-Effective: Pure down pillows tend to be pricier due to the process of collecting and cleaning the feathers. Down alternatives, on the other hand, are generally more affordable without compromising much on comfort.

4. Durability: The synthetic fibers used in down alternative pillows are designed for resilience. They can maintain their shape and structure for longer periods, reducing the frequency of replacements. Additionally, these pillows are less likely to develop lumps or lose their fluffiness over time, ensuring consistent comfort.

5. Moisture Resistance: Down can absorb and retain moisture, which may lead to the growth of mold or mildew if not dried properly. Down alternative materials are less prone to moisture retention, resulting in a dryer, fresher sleeping experience.

6. Ease of Care: While down pillows often require specialized care, including professional cleaning or specific washing instructions, down alternative pillows are usually machine washable and dryer-friendly. This ease of care is a boon for those leading busy lives or for settings such as hotels and guest rooms.

7. Uniformity: Down pillows can sometimes have quills that poke through the pillowcase, causing discomfort. Down alternatives don’t present this issue, ensuring a consistently smooth feel.

In conclusion, while the age-old debate between down and down alternative pillows may never see a definitive winner, the advantages of down alternative pillows are hard to dispute. They present a compelling case for those seeking a combination of comfort, durability, ethics, and affordability. As technology advances and manufacturing processes become more refined, we can only expect the gap between natural and synthetic bedding to narrow, with down alternatives potentially taking the lead in the luxury bedding market.

Best Down Alternative
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Have Questions?

Text us at 858-232-5760 for assistance. We’re happy to help!

Mattress Reviews and Guides