Original verdict: Ben found the Allswell Supreme softer than many hybrids but still supportive, with a foam-forward feel and little partner disturbance. He thought the construction offered strong value at its original price. This review covers the 2019 model, not necessarily any current Allswell mattress.
Allswell’s Supreme combined a substantial Euro-top and foam comfort layers with pocketed coils. Ben slept on the mattress for about a week before describing his first impressions, and the details below preserve that original test.
What Ben found
The Supreme had a softer, cushioned surface, but Ben did not feel unstable when switching between stomach and side sleeping. He described the hybrid as more foam-like than a bouncy traditional innerspring, with the coil unit contributing support beneath the comfort layers.
His 16-pound bowling ball sank a visible amount into the surface. When moved, the responsive foam recovered quickly, which matched his impression that getting in and out was easy. A bowling ball is a simple visual demonstration, not a substitute for testing the mattress with your own body.
Inside the original Supreme
The manufacturer’s specifications at the time described a Euro-top, Energex foam, graphite- and copper-infused memory foam and individually wrapped coils with reinforced edges. The reviewed mattress was approximately 14 inches tall. These are historical specifications; construction and availability can change.
Ben opened the review sample to inspect the layers and observed that the coils did not dominate the surface feel. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for your own mattress and do not remove a cover unless it is designed to be removed.
Motion, comfort and tradeoffs
Ben reported that when he got up at night, his wife did not feel much movement on the tested mattress. That is a useful couples’ observation, though motion transfer varies with body size, position and sensitivity. The thick cushioning may suit people who like a softer feel; a sleeper who prefers a very firm surface may want to compare firmer options.
The original construction used infused foams marketed for temperature regulation. Ben’s short test does not establish how cool every sleeper will feel, and the foam ingredients do not guarantee a particular temperature.
Watch the original review
Availability and terms today
Allswell’s lineup has changed. We could not verify that the exact Supreme reviewed here is currently sold, so check the model name and construction with the seller. Original prices, trials and warranties are historical; check current terms, delivery and any return fees before buying.
For a broader comparison, see our Allswell mattress review. Different models do not necessarily share the Supreme’s feel or layers.
Frequently asked questions
Was the Supreme a foam or hybrid mattress?
It was a hybrid with foam comfort layers and pocketed coils, though Ben described its feel as more foam-forward than springy.
Did Ben find it comfortable for side sleeping?
Yes, he reported feeling comfortable switching between side and stomach positions on the original sample. Other sleepers may feel it differently.
Is the original review a test of a current Allswell model?
No. Verify the exact model and current specifications before using the old review to inform a purchase.
Compare this mattress against 142 tested mattresses
Sort all 142 mattresses we have tested by pressure relief, support, cooling, motion isolation, edge support, price, trial and warranty, then filter by how you actually sleep. Of those, 84 hold a complete standardized record and 41 a partial standardized record.