Keeps vs. Thuma: Top 7 Critical Comparisons in 2024

Comparing Keeps vs. Thuma: An In-Depth Guide

When it comes to choosing the perfect bed frame, two names often stand out: Keeps vs. Thuma. Both offer unique features and styles that cater to various needs and preferences. If you’re short on time and just need the essentials, here’s a quick comparison:

• Keeps Bed Frame

  • Design: Minimalist, made with sustainable materials.
  • Durability: Sturdy, easy to move after assembly.
  • Price: Budget-friendly but fewer reviews available.

• Thuma Bed Frame

  • Design: Sleek, features Japanese joinery.
  • Durability: Known for durability but not easy to move after assembly.
  • Price: Higher-end, but highly reviewed.

Now, let’s dive deeper. The primary purpose of this guide is to help you make an informed decision between the Keeps and Thuma bed frames. We’ll break down each option in terms of design, materials, assembly, and overall value.

I’m Ben Trapskin, founder of Yawnder. My journey to better sleep began after struggling with poor sleep quality and knowing the frustrations of buying multiple mattresses that didn’t meet my needs. I’ve researched and tested numerous bed frames, including Keeps and Thuma, to provide you with genuine insights.

Now that you have a quick overview, let’s look at each bed frame in more detail, starting with the Keeps Bed Frame.

Overview of Keeps Bed Frame

Design

The Keeps Bed Frame boasts a minimalist and modern design, making it a great fit for various bedroom aesthetics. Its clean lines and sleek appearance create a sophisticated look that appeals to many. Available in queen ($1,035) and king sizes ($1,215), Keeps offers two color options for those looking to match their decor.

Materials

Keeps uses high-quality, sustainable wood in its bed frames. The exact type of wood isn’t specified, but it’s noted for its durability and attractive finish. The frame’s eco-friendly approach aligns with Keeps’ commitment to sustainability, ensuring a responsible choice for environmentally conscious consumers.

Assembly

One of the standout features of the Keeps Bed Frame is its tool-free assembly. The frame uses ratchet clamps to hold the pieces together, which simplifies the setup process. However, these clamps may require occasional tightening, as noted by some users who experienced a slight wiggle after a couple of months of use.

Durability

The Keeps Bed Frame is designed for durability. Despite the minor issue with ratchet clamps loosening over time, the frame remains sturdy and reliable. The use of high-quality wood contributes to its longevity, making it a solid investment for those who move frequently.

Weight Capacity

The Keeps Bed Frame is built to support a substantial amount of weight, though specific weight limits aren’t provided. User reviews suggest that it holds up well under regular use, indicating a robust construction.

Noise Level

Keeps Bed Frame is praised for being noiseless, which is a significant advantage for light sleepers or those who share their bed. The ratchet clamp system, despite needing occasional adjustment, does not contribute to noise, ensuring a quiet sleeping environment.

Price

With prices set at $1,035 for a queen and $1,215 for a king, the Keeps Bed Frame is positioned as a premium product. While it is not the cheapest option on the market, its combination of design, durability, and ease of assembly offers good value for money.

Headboard Options

Keeps offers two headboard options: a wall-mounted headboard and a free-standing headboard. The wall-mounted option may not be ideal for renters due to potential damage to walls. The free-standing headboard, however, is a great alternative, especially for those looking to avoid issues with their security deposit.

In summary, the Keeps Bed Frame is a stylish, sustainable, and practical choice for those who prioritize easy assembly and a modern aesthetic. Its noiseless design and sturdy construction make it a reliable option for various living situations.

Overview of Thuma Bed Frame

Design

Thuma’s The Bed stands out with its minimalist and modern design. The frame features clean lines and a sleek profile, making it a versatile addition to any decor. The walnut finish we tested was neither too light nor too dark, fitting well with a wide range of room decors. Thuma also offers finishes in natural, dark brown, and light gray. The design is improved by the absence of visible screws or bolts, thanks to its unique assembly method.

Materials

Thuma uses upcycled and repurposed rubberwood for The Bed, aligning with their commitment to sustainability. This choice not only reduces environmental impact but also ensures durability. The natural wood grain patterns add a touch of elegance, and the wood is known for its strength and stability.

Assembly

One of Thuma’s standout features is its tool-free assembly. The Bed uses a Japanese joinery technique that relies on tension and friction to lock the components together. This makes the assembly process feel almost like a giant game of Jenga in reverse. The bed ships in three manageable boxes, making it easy for one person to carry and set up. Unpacking is straightforward, with no annoying polystyrene or excessive plastic packaging.

Durability

The Bed is built to last, supported by a sturdy set of all-wood legs padded with cork, and slats lined with felt to reduce shifting and noise. Thuma cites a 1,500-pound weight capacity, the highest among the beds we tested. This ensures the frame can handle significant weight without compromising stability. Thuma also offers a lifetime warranty, indicating a high level of confidence in the frame’s durability.

Weight Capacity

Thuma’s bed frame can support up to 1,500 pounds, making it one of the sturdiest options available. This high weight capacity ensures that the bed can accommodate multiple sleepers or heavier mattresses without any issues.

Noise Level

During our tests, The Bed proved to be exceptionally quiet. The felt-lined slats and cork-padded legs contribute to this noiseless experience. Unlike other frames that squeak or shift, The Bed remained stable and silent, even under significant load.

Price

At $1,095 for a queen-size frame, The Bed is an investment. However, considering its durability, ease of assembly, and aesthetic appeal, it offers good value for money. The price includes the frame, extra-strength cushion-coated slats, and either The PillowBoard or The Headboard.

Headboard Options

Thuma offers two headboard options: the PillowBoard and a newly introduced wooden headboard. The PillowBoard is a rigid pillow filled with lightweight foam that wedges between the mattress and the wall. While some find it convenient, others feel it lacks the stability of a traditional headboard. The wooden headboard, introduced in 2022, provides a more traditional and stable option. Thuma also offers a removable and washable cushion for the wooden headboard in eight different fabric options, adding versatility and comfort.

In summary, the Thuma Bed Frame is a well-designed, sustainable, and durable option that excels in ease of assembly and noise reduction. Its minimalist design and high weight capacity make it a strong contender for those seeking a reliable and aesthetically pleasing bed frame.

Keeps vs. Thuma: Key Differences

When comparing Keeps vs. Thuma, there are several key differences to consider. These differences span across design, materials, assembly, durability, weight capacity, noise level, price, and headboard options.

Design and Aesthetics

Keeps and Thuma both offer minimalist, modern bed frames, but their designs have unique characteristics.

Keeps Bed Frame:

• Minimalist Look: Keeps frames feature a sleek, minimalist design with fabric detailing where the ratchet clamps round the legs.
• Color Options: Limited color options, focusing on natural wood tones that blend well with various decor styles.
• Headboard Styles: Keeps offers a real headboard option that attaches securely, providing a more traditional look.

Thuma Bed Frame:

• Neat Design: Thuma’s design is praised for its elegance, using Japanese joinery techniques for a clean, tool-free assembly.
• Color Options: Available in natural, dark brown, and light gray finishes.
• Headboard Styles: Thuma offers both a PillowBoard and a wooden headboard. The PillowBoard is a soft, removable headboard, while the wooden headboard is more traditional and stable.

Materials and Sustainability

Both brands emphasize sustainability, but they use different materials.

Keeps Bed Frame:

• Wood Types: Uses sustainably sourced wood, although specific types are not detailed.
• Eco-Friendly: Emphasizes sustainability in its marketing, but lacks certifications mentioned in the research.

Thuma Bed Frame:

• Wood Types: Crafted from repurposed wood, ensuring minimal environmental impact.
• Certifications: Greenguard Gold and CertiPUR-US certified, meeting strict standards for low emissions.

Assembly Process

The assembly process is a significant factor for both brands, especially for those who move frequently.

Keeps Bed Frame:

• Tool-Free Assembly: Uses interlocking pieces held together by ratchet clamps, making the assembly straightforward.
• Unique Feature: The ratchet clamps also aid in bundling and transporting the bed, simplifying moves.

Thuma Bed Frame:

• Tool-Free Assembly: Uses Japanese joinery techniques, allowing the frame to be assembled without tools.
• Ease of Assembly: The pieces slot together seamlessly, making the process feel like a giant game of Jenga in reverse.

Durability and Weight Capacity

Durability and weight capacity are crucial for long-term satisfaction.

Keeps Bed Frame:

• Sturdiness: Described as solid and reliable, with no specific weight capacity mentioned.
• Longevity: Customers report that it remains sturdy over time, even after moving.

Thuma Bed Frame:

• Weight Limits: Boasts a high weight capacity of 1,500 pounds.
• Longevity: Made to last, with a lifetime warranty backing its durability.

Noise Level

A quiet bed frame is essential for a good night’s sleep.

Keeps Bed Frame:

• Silent Operation: Known for being silent, with no squeaks or creaks reported by users.
• Design Features: The ratchet clamps and interlocking wood pieces help maintain its noiseless operation.

Thuma Bed Frame:

• Silent Design: The felt-lined slats and cork-padded legs ensure minimal noise.
• Customer Feedback: Consistently praised for its quietness, even during movement.

Price Comparison

Price is always a critical factor in decision-making.

Keeps Bed Frame:

• Cost: Generally priced lower than Thuma, making it a more budget-friendly option.
• Value for Money: Offers good value for its price, especially considering its durability and design.

Thuma Bed Frame:

• Cost: Higher price point, with a king-size frame costing around $1,195.
• Value for Money: Justified by its quality, sustainability, and lifetime warranty. Thuma also offers a 100-night trial, allowing customers to test the bed risk-free.

In summary, when comparing Keeps vs. Thuma, each has its strengths and unique features. Keeps offers a slightly more budget-friendly option with a traditional headboard, while Thuma excels in sustainability, ease of assembly, and noise reduction.

Customer Reviews and Feedback

When comparing Keeps vs. Thuma, customer reviews and feedback provide valuable insights into real-world experiences with these bed frames.

Keeps Reviews

Positive Feedback:

• Aesthetics and Build Quality: Many users love the Keeps Bed for its beautiful design and sturdy construction. One user mentioned, “It’s a hassle, but now I am happy with the bed. It is sturdy and beautiful.”
• Assembly: Customers appreciate the straightforward assembly process. A reviewer noted, “Assembly was straightforward. Love the looks. It’s been rock solid during the horizontal shuffle with an enthusiastic dance partner if you know what I’m saying.”

Common Complaints:

• Initial Defects: Some users experienced issues with defects on initial delivery. However, Keeps’ customer service was responsive in resolving these issues. “The first bed they sent had some defects. I contacted them, and they sent me the second one to swap the defective pieces.”
• Shipping Delays: A few customers faced delays in receiving their orders, which can be frustrating when planning a new setup.

Thuma Reviews

Positive Feedback:

• Design and Functionality: The Thuma Bed is often praised for its sleek design and functionality. A happy customer shared, “My Thuma bed is the purchase I am most satisfied with in my whole home. It’s virtually perfect.”
• Quietness: One of the standout features is its noiseless operation. “The Keeps frame is basically silent; no squeaking or rickety noises when you get into and out of bed or turn over at night.”

Common Complaints:

• Customer Service: Some users have expressed frustration with Thuma’s customer service, particularly the lack of a phone support option. “It is extremely frustrating not to be able to call Thuma customer service. It takes them several days by email to respond.”
• Shipping Issues: There have been instances of shipping delays and missing parts, which can be a significant inconvenience. “We received one box and FedEx is saying 2 boxes were delivered. Both saying it was delivered leaves us holding the bag.”

Customer Satisfaction

Keeps:

• Overall Satisfaction: Generally high, with customers appreciating the bed’s aesthetic appeal and sturdy build.
• Customer Service: Responsive in addressing issues, although initial defects can be a hassle.

Thuma:

• Overall Satisfaction: High, especially for design and noise reduction.
• Customer Service: Mixed reviews, with some customers facing delays and communication issues.

In summary, both Keeps and Thuma have their strengths and weaknesses according to customer feedback. Keeps is praised for its beautiful design and solid construction, while Thuma excels in quietness and ease of assembly. However, both brands have faced challenges with shipping and customer service.

Frequently Asked Questions about Keeps vs. Thuma

How long does the Thuma bed frame last?

The Thuma bed frame is designed to last for at least 10 years, thanks to its durable wood construction. Users have praised its longevity, noting that it remains sturdy and reliable over time. The weight capacity of 1,500 pounds further attests to its durability. One customer review mentioned, “The Thuma bed is my most satisfying purchase; it’s virtually perfect and rock solid.”

Is the Thuma bed frame quiet?

Yes, the Thuma bed frame is known for its quietness. The design incorporates thick slats with padding on the ends to prevent noise and scratching. This ensures minimal creaking or squeaking, even during movements. One user shared, “The Thuma frame is basically silent; no squeaking or rickety noises when you get in and out of bed or turn over at night.”

Can you use any mattress with Thuma?

Absolutely. The Thuma bed frame is compatible with any type of mattress, including memory foam, hybrid, and traditional innerspring mattresses. The slats are spaced less than three inches apart, providing adequate support without causing dipping or sagging. This makes it a versatile choice for various mattress types and sizes.

In the next section, we’ll dig deeper into customer reviews and feedback to give you a comprehensive understanding of how Keeps and Thuma compare based on user experiences.

Conclusion

In our Keeps vs. Thuma comparison, both bed frames offer unique advantages that cater to different needs and preferences. Let’s summarize the key points:

Keeps Bed Frame:

• Design and Aesthetics: Minimalist and modern with unique fabric detailing.
• Materials and Sustainability: Made from sustainable wood, emphasizing eco-friendliness.
• Assembly Process: Tool-free assembly using ratchet clamps, making it ideal for frequent movers.
• Durability and Weight Capacity: Sturdy construction, capable of supporting substantial weight without wobbling.
• Noise Level: Virtually silent, with no creaking or squeaking.
• Price Comparison: Generally more affordable than Thuma, offering great value for its quality.

Thuma Bed Frame:

• Design and Aesthetics: Sleek, with options for a pillowboard or a newly released wooden headboard.
• Materials and Sustainability: Crafted from repurposed wood and eco-friendly materials.
• Assembly Process: Tool-free assembly using Japanese joinery, known for its simplicity and sturdiness.
• Durability and Weight Capacity: Highly durable with a weight capacity of up to 1,500 pounds.
• Noise Level: Quiet during use, though it may become less stable if moved frequently.
• Price Comparison: Higher price point, reflecting its premium materials and craftsmanship.

Final Thoughts

Both Keeps and Thuma offer high-quality bed frames that excel in different areas. If you prioritize sustainability and ease of assembly, Keeps is an excellent choice. On the other hand, if you seek a more premium design with robust durability, Thuma might be worth the investment.

Yawnder’s Recommendation

At Yawnder, we strive to help you achieve the best sleep possible. Based on our research and customer feedback, we recommend considering your specific needs:

• Choose Keeps if you want a sustainable, easy-to-assemble bed frame that offers great value for money.
• Opt for Thuma if you prefer a premium, durable bed frame with a sleek design and don’t mind a higher price tag.

For more personalized sleep recommendations, take our sleep quiz to find the perfect bed frame custom to your needs. Happy sleeping!