The best sleep eye masks to buy in 2025 – tested by a light sleeper and a side sleeper
We tested the top contenders to find the ones that actually stay on your face and block real light.
Best for Total Blackout
Manta Sleep Mask
If you hate fabric pressing on your eyelids, the Manta is the gold standard. Adjustable eye cups create a true seal and let you open your eyes in total darkness.
Tester Notes
My Experience: This is my daily driver. The adjustable cups eliminate nose bridge light leaks entirely.
My Wife's Take: “It works, but it’s bulky for side sleeping.”