Plank Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe: Top Comparison 2024

Plank Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe is a crucial comparison for those in search of the ultimate firm mattress experience. Both options are part of the esteemed Brooklyn Bedding lineup, designed for sleepers who prefer a firmer feel. If you’re looking for a quick overview, here are the key differences:

• Support System: The Plank Firm Luxe is a hybrid mattress featuring individually wrapped coils, whereas the Plank Firm is constructed entirely from high-density foam.
• Feel: Both mattresses are very firm, but the Luxe offers slightly more ‘give’ compared to the original Plank Firm, which is among the firmest mattresses we’ve reviewed.
• Temperature Control: The Luxe model includes options like an advanced cooling cover, making it more suitable for hot sleepers.

I’m Ben Trapskin, the creator of Yawnder. With extensive experience in reviewing mattresses and personal trials with firm models like Plank Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe, I am committed to helping others achieve better sleep. Let’s explore which of these mattresses best suits your needs.

Important Plank Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe terms:
– firm queen mattress
– mattress medium firm vs firm
– medium firm mattress

Plank Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe: Key Differences

When choosing between the Plank Firm and Plank Firm Luxe, understanding their key differences is crucial. Both mattresses offer a firm sleeping experience, but they cater to slightly different preferences and needs.

Firmness Levels

Both the Plank Firm and Plank Firm Luxe are known for their exceptional firmness. They each have two sides: a firm side and an extra-firm side. On the firmness scale, the firm side of both mattresses scores an 8 out of 10, while the extra-firm side scores a 9 out of 10. This makes them some of the firmest options available on the market, ideal for those who find most mattresses too soft.

Construction and Materials

The biggest distinction between these two mattresses lies in their construction and materials.

• Plank Firm: This is an all-foam mattress. It relies solely on high-density foam for support. This gives it a very firm feel, with minimal give, which many sleepers describe as sleeping “on top” of the mattress rather than “in” it. The foam construction also contributes to its lightweight nature, making it easier to move.

• Plank Firm Luxe: In contrast, the Luxe version is a hybrid mattress. It combines high-density foam with a 6-inch layer of individually encased coils. These coils provide a traditional innerspring feel, offering more bounce and a touch more “give” than the all-foam version. The hybrid design also improves durability and support, particularly beneficial for heavier individuals or those seeking long-term investment.

The hybrid construction of the Plank Firm Luxe also allows for improved motion isolation and edge support, which is advantageous for couples or those who share their bed. Additionally, the Luxe version often includes features like a GlacioTex Cooling Cover, enhancing temperature regulation for hot sleepers.

Choosing between the Plank Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe largely depends on your personal preferences regarding firmness and support. If you’re looking for the firmest experience possible with excellent motion isolation, the Plank Firm might be your go-to. However, if you prefer a bit more give with improved cooling features, the Plank Firm Luxe could be the better choice.

Performance and Comfort

When exploring the Plank Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe, consider how each mattress performs in terms of temperature regulation, motion isolation, and edge support. These factors significantly impact overall comfort and sleep quality.

Temperature Regulation

Temperature regulation is a key feature for many sleepers, especially those who tend to overheat at night. Both the Plank Firm and Plank Firm Luxe offer solid temperature management, but the Luxe version has a slight edge due to its hybrid design.

• Plank Firm: This all-foam mattress uses high-density foam, which can sometimes retain heat. However, its minimal foam layers and breathable materials help maintain a temperature-neutral sleep surface.

• Plank Firm Luxe: The Luxe model incorporates individually encased coils, promoting better airflow compared to its all-foam counterpart. This design helps heat dissipate more effectively, making it a cooler option for hot sleepers.

Both models offer an optional GlacioTex Cooling Cover. This feature provides an instant cooling sensation, helping to keep the mattress surface comfortably cool throughout the night. While some may find the cover’s “slick” texture less appealing, its cooling benefits can be a game-changer for those who struggle with night sweats.

Motion Isolation and Edge Support

If you share your bed with a partner, motion isolation and edge support are crucial for a restful night.

• Motion Isolation: The Plank Firm excels in minimizing motion transfer due to its dense foam construction. The Plank Firm Luxe, while slightly less effective due to its coil layer, still offers good motion isolation. This makes both mattresses suitable for couples, though very light sleepers might prefer the all-foam option.

• Edge Support: The firm construction of both mattresses provides excellent edge stability, but the hybrid design of the Plank Firm Luxe gives it an extra boost. The coils in the Luxe model improve edge support, reducing the risk of rolling off the bed. This feature is particularly beneficial for those who like to use the entire mattress surface or sit on the edge.

In the Plank Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe debate, your choice should align with your priorities. If temperature regulation and edge support are top concerns, the Plank Firm Luxe might be your ideal pick. However, for superior motion isolation, the Plank Firm stands out as a strong contender.

Who Should Choose Plank Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe?

Ideal for Back and Stomach Sleepers

If you primarily sleep on your back or stomach, both the Plank Firm and Plank Firm Luxe are excellent choices. These mattresses are designed to maintain spinal alignment, which is crucial for these sleep positions.

• Back Sleepers: The firm support provided by both models keeps the spine aligned and offers pressure relief on the lower back. This can help prevent back pain and ensure a comfortable night’s rest. The Plank Firm Luxe, with its hybrid design, might offer a slightly more adaptive feel due to its coil support layer, which can be beneficial for those who prefer a bit of give without sacrificing firmness.

• Stomach Sleepers: These mattresses prevent excessive sinkage, keeping the hips and spine aligned. This alignment is key to avoiding discomfort and pain. The extra-firm side of both models is particularly suited for heavier individuals who need additional support.

Considerations for Side Sleepers

Side sleepers might find the Plank mattresses too firm, as they can create pressure points on the shoulders and hips. These pressure points can lead to discomfort and disrupt sleep.

• Pressure Points: Side sleepers often require a softer mattress that provides more cushioning to alleviate pressure on the shoulders and hips. Unfortunately, both the Plank Firm and Plank Firm Luxe are not ideal for this need.

• Comfort Needs: If you’re a side sleeper considering these mattresses, you might need to add a mattress topper for extra comfort. Alternatively, exploring softer mattress options specifically designed for side sleepers may be a better choice. This ensures you get the necessary pressure relief and comfort to prevent pain and improve sleep quality.

In summary, when comparing Plank Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe, back and stomach sleepers will likely benefit the most from these firm options. Side sleepers should carefully consider their comfort needs and may need to explore additional solutions for optimal sleep quality.

Frequently Asked Questions about Plank Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe

How thick is the Plank Firm Luxe mattress?

The Plank Firm Luxe mattress stands at 13.25 inches tall. This height accommodates its unique hybrid design, which features a combination of individually encased coils and foam layers. The thickness is designed to provide a balance of firmness and support, catering to those who prefer an extremely firm sleeping surface.

Which side is more firm on the Plank mattress?

When it comes to firmness, both the Plank Firm and Plank Firm Luxe offer two options: a firm side and an extra-firm side. The extra-firm side is the firmer of the two, making it ideal for those who need maximum support. To identify the sides, look for the Plank label orientation—this will help you determine which side is facing up. The firm side offers a slightly softer feel, but both sides are considerably firmer than standard mattresses.

Are extra firm mattresses more expensive?

Extra firm mattresses like the Plank models often come with a higher price tag. This is due to the heavy-duty materials required to achieve their firmness and durability. For instance, the Plank Firm Luxe incorporates a hybrid design with high-density foam and coil support, contributing to its cost. While these mattresses may be more expensive upfront, they are a long-term investment in quality sleep, especially for those who need robust support.

In the case of the Plank Firm Luxe, the price for a Queen-size mattress is around $1532.00, slightly higher than the all-foam Plank Firm at $1332.00. This price difference reflects the additional materials and construction complexity in the Luxe model.

Conclusion

At Yawnder, we are dedicated to offering expert evaluations and unbiased reviews to assist you in finding the ideal mattress. Our comprehensive comparison of Plank Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe outlines the essential differences, enabling you to make an informed choice based on your sleep preferences.

Our Recommendations:

• If you are a back or stomach sleeper in search of maximum support, the Plank Firm Luxe is a fantastic option. Its hybrid design and dual firmness levels provide strong support, particularly beneficial for heavier individuals.

• For those who favor an all-foam experience, the original Plank Firm is a great choice. It delivers a firm sleeping surface without the additional expense of coils.

• Side sleepers may want to consider other mattresses that offer more cushioning for pressure points. The extreme firmness of the Plank models might not deliver the necessary comfort for hips and shoulders.

Investing in a mattress is investing in your health. Selecting the right firmness and support can greatly influence your sleep quality and overall well-being.

For more insights and to explore medium-firm options that might better suit your sleep style, visit our Medium Firm Mattress Guide.

At Yawnder, we’re committed to helping you discover the best sleep solutions tailored to your needs. Your journey to better sleep starts here!