Kirkland Signature Mattress Review: Top 5 Luxurious Picks 2024

If you’re looking for an unbiased Kirkland Signature Mattress Review, you’re in the right place. The Kirkland Signature by Stearns & Foster Hybrid Mattresses sold exclusively at Costco aim to provide luxury sleep experiences without the hefty price tag. But do they deliver on their promises?

Quick Overview:

• Brand: Kirkland Signature
• Collaboration: Stearns & Foster
• Availability: Costco
• Type: Hybrid mattress
• Quality: Rated high for materials and comfort

Finding the right mattress is crucial for quality sleep, especially if you suffer from chronic back pain or allergies. The Kirkland Signature mattresses offer a medium-firm feel, combining traditional innerspring support with the plushness of memory foam. This blend promises a balanced sleep experience with good motion isolation and cooling features.

I’m Ben Trapskin, the creator of Yawnder. Over the years, I’ve tested countless mattresses to help people find the perfect sleep solution. Through my experiences and rigorous evaluations, I aim to give you a clear and honest Kirkland Signature Mattress Review. Let’s find out if this mattress meets your needs and expectations.

Overview of Kirkland Signature Mattresses

Kirkland Signature, a brand known for quality and value, has teamed up with Stearns & Foster to offer exclusive hybrid mattresses at Costco. These mattresses aim to deliver luxurious comfort and support without breaking the bank. Let’s explore the specifics of two popular models: the Hope Bay and the Lakeridge.

Kirkland Signature by Stearns & Foster Hope Bay

The Hope Bay mattress is a pillow-top, spring-and-foam hybrid designed for those who crave a luxurious sleeping experience. This mattress features a combination of cooling gel foam and pocketed coils to provide both comfort and support.

Key Features:

• Pillow-Top Layer: The Hope Bay includes a 1.5” holofiber material layer that adds a plush feel.
• Cooling Gel Foam: A 1” layer of cooling gel foam helps regulate temperature, ensuring you stay cool throughout the night.
• Memory Foam: Two additional layers (1” each) of memory foam offer extra cushioning and pressure relief.
• Pocketed Coils: A 7.5” layer of individually encased coils provides robust support and minimizes motion transfer, making it ideal for couples.

The Hope Bay mattress is only available in king and queen sizes, with a firmness rating of 7.1 out of 10, making it a firm option for those who prefer a more supportive sleep surface.

Kirkland Signature Lakeridge Mattress

The Lakeridge mattress stands out with its impressive 14.5” thickness and a combination of poly foam, memory foam, and pocketed coils. This hybrid design aims to offer a balanced sleep experience with both comfort and support.

Key Features:

• Quilted Cover: A 2.5” quilted cover made of breathable Tencel fabric adds a plush and luxurious feel to the mattress.
• Comfort Layers: The Lakeridge includes a 1.0” poly foam layer, a 0.75” memory foam layer, and a 2.0” poly foam layer. These layers work together to provide transitional support and improve pressure relief.
• Support Layers: The mattress features a 7.25” layer of pocketed coils and a 1.0” support foam base. The individually encased coils move independently, enhancing motion isolation and edge support.

The Lakeridge mattress is available in various sizes, including queen, king, and California king, with a medium-firm feel rated at 7 out of 10. This makes it suitable for a wide range of sleepers, from back to side sleepers.

Both Hope Bay and Lakeridge models are designed to offer premium quality at a more accessible price point, making them an attractive option for Costco shoppers looking for a high-quality mattress.

For more detailed comparisons and insights, continue reading our in-depth Kirkland Signature Mattress Review.

Performance and Comfort

When evaluating a mattress, performance and comfort are crucial factors. The Kirkland Signature Lakeridge Mattress offers a blend of features that cater to different sleepers’ needs. Let’s break down its performance in key areas like firmness, support, motion transfer, edge support, cooling, and pressure relief.

Firmness and Support

The Kirkland Signature Lakeridge Mattress is rated as medium-firm, sitting at a 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale. This firmness level is ideal for a wide range of sleepers, from back to side sleepers. The mattress features a combination of poly foam, memory foam, and pocketed coils, which work together to provide balanced support and comfort.

• Medium Feel: The mattress’s medium-firm feel offers a good balance between softness and firmness, making it suitable for various sleeping positions and body types.
• Support Layers: With a 7.25” layer of pocketed coils and a 1.0” support foam base, the mattress provides robust support. The individually encased coils move independently, enhancing support and reducing motion transfer.

Motion Transfer and Edge Support

Motion transfer and edge support are essential for couples and those who share their bed with pets. The Kirkland Signature Lakeridge Mattress excels in these areas.

• Motion Transfer: The mattress isolates motion well, thanks to its pocketed coils and plush pillow top layer. During tests, minimal movement was felt when a partner moved or got out of bed, making it ideal for light sleepers.
• Edge Support: The mattress features reinforced edge support coils, providing excellent support when sitting or lying near the edge. In tests, the mattress showed minimal sinkage, with a measured sinkage of only two inches when sitting on the edge, indicating strong edge support.

Cooling and Pressure Relief

Cooling and pressure relief are vital for a comfortable night’s sleep, especially for hot sleepers and those with pressure point issues. The Kirkland Signature Lakeridge Mattress incorporates several features to address these needs.

• Cooling Performance: The mattress includes a Tencel cover and an AirVent system, which help dissipate trapped heat and regulate body temperature. In thermal tests, the mattress increased only around 5 degrees Fahrenheit after five minutes, indicating excellent cooling capabilities.
• Pressure Relief: The mattress features a 6.25” comfort layer, including poly foam and memory foam. These layers provide good pressure relief, although some sleepers may experience slight pressure points over time due to the foam quality. The thicker-than-average comfort layer helps distribute body weight evenly, reducing pressure on sensitive areas.

Overall, the Kirkland Signature Lakeridge Mattress offers a well-rounded performance in terms of firmness, support, motion transfer, edge support, cooling, and pressure relief. These features make it a strong contender for those seeking a high-quality hybrid mattress.

For more insights into how the Kirkland Signature Lakeridge compares to other popular mattresses, continue reading our detailed Kirkland Signature Mattress Review.

Pros and Cons of Kirkland Signature Mattresses

Advantages

When evaluating the Kirkland Signature Lakeridge Mattress, several advantages stand out:

1. Lower Motion Transfer: This mattress excels in isolating motion, making it ideal for couples or those who share their bed with pets. The pocketed coils and plush pillow-top layer work together to minimize disturbances from a partner moving or getting out of bed.

2. Improved Edge Support: The mattress features reinforced edge support coils, providing excellent support when sitting or lying near the edge. During tests, the mattress showed minimal sinkage, which is crucial for people with mobility issues and those who like to use the entire bed surface.

3. Thicker Comfort Layer: The 6.25” comfort layer, which is thicker than average, offers good pressure relief and distributes body weight evenly. This helps reduce pressure on sensitive areas, making the mattress comfortable for various sleeping positions.

4. Longer Trial and Warranty: While the mattress doesn’t come with a trial period, it does offer a 10-year warranty. This is longer than the average warranty period for mattresses, providing peace of mind regarding its durability and longevity.

5. Budget-Friendly: Priced at $999.99 for a Queen size, this mattress is a steal compared to other similar hybrid mattresses. It offers a luxurious feel without breaking the bank, making it a great budget-friendly option.

Disadvantages

However, the Kirkland Signature Lakeridge Mattress is not without its drawbacks:

1. Cooling Performance: Despite the TENCEL cover and AirVent system, the mattress’s cooling performance is below average. Hot sleepers may find that the mattress retains more heat than desired, affecting overall comfort.

2. Slower Material Response Time: The memory foam layer takes longer to reform back to shape, which can make the mattress feel more difficult to move around on. This slower response time may not be ideal for restless sleepers who change positions frequently.

3. Low Bounce: The mattress has a low level of bounce, measuring only 6.99” in tests. This can negatively impact activities like sex, as it doesn’t create the right conditions for ideal amorous activity. The low bounce also makes the mattress feel less responsive.

4. Off-Gassing: Like many foam mattresses, the Kirkland Signature Lakeridge Mattress has a strong off-gassing smell initially. This odor can be off-putting and may take up to eight days to dissipate fully.

5. Only Available Online: This mattress is exclusively available online through Costco’s website, which means you can’t test it out in-store before purchasing. This could be a disadvantage for those who prefer to try a mattress before making a decision.

Overall, while the Kirkland Signature Lakeridge Mattress offers several notable advantages, it also has some drawbacks that potential buyers should consider. For a more detailed comparison with other popular mattresses, continue reading our Kirkland Signature Mattress Review.

Comparison with Other Mattresses

Kirkland Signature vs. Casper

Casper is a well-known name in the mattress industry, famous for its memory foam mattresses. Unlike the Kirkland Signature Lakeridge, which is a hybrid, the Casper Original is an all-foam mattress. It offers a medium-soft feel, making it a great choice for side sleepers who need extra cushioning around their shoulders and hips.

Key Differences:

• Material: Casper uses memory foam, while Kirkland Signature Lakeridge is a hybrid.
• Feel: Casper has a medium-soft feel; Kirkland Signature Lakeridge has a medium feel (5/10).
• Cooling: Casper may not be as cool as the Lakeridge, which has a TENCEL cover and AirVent system.
• Price: Casper mattresses are generally more expensive than the Kirkland Signature Lakeridge.

Overall, if you’re a side sleeper looking for a softer, all-foam mattress, Casper might be the better option for you. However, if you prefer a hybrid construction and a firmer feel, Kirkland Signature Lakeridge is worth considering.

Kirkland Signature vs. Novaform

Novaform mattresses are also popular and are known for their memory foam construction. They are CertiPUR-US certified, ensuring low emissions and the absence of harsh chemicals. This makes them a good choice for eco-conscious consumers.

Key Differences:

• Material: Both Novaform and Kirkland Signature Lakeridge use memory foam, but Lakeridge is a hybrid.
• Feel: Novaform offers a range of firmness levels, while Lakeridge is medium (5/10).
• Certification: Novaform is CertiPUR-US certified, ensuring safer materials.
• Price: Novaform mattresses can vary in price, but they are generally comparable to Kirkland Signature Lakeridge.

If eco-friendliness and multiple firmness options are important to you, Novaform is a strong contender. On the other hand, if you prefer a hybrid mattress with a balanced feel, Kirkland Signature Lakeridge is a solid choice.

Kirkland Signature vs. Emma Hybrid Cooling Elite

The Emma Hybrid Cooling Elite is another hybrid mattress but with a 12″ thickness. It offers a medium-firm feel and is designed for minimal sinkage and high bounce.

Key Differences:

• Material: Both are hybrids, but Emma focuses more on cooling.
• Feel: Emma is medium-firm, while Kirkland Signature Lakeridge is medium (5/10).
• Bounce: Emma has high bounce, making it more responsive.
• Cooling: Emma is designed to be cooler, making it better for hot sleepers.

If you need a mattress with excellent cooling features and high bounce, the Emma Hybrid Cooling Elite is a great option. However, if you prefer a thicker comfort layer and a medium feel, Kirkland Signature Lakeridge might be more suitable.

Kirkland Signature vs. Helix Midnight

Helix Midnight is a 12″ hybrid mattress that uses a combination of memory foam and poly foam. It offers a balanced feel with moderate sinkage and high bounce.

Key Differences:

• Material: Both are hybrids, but Helix uses a mix of memory foam and poly foam.
• Feel: Helix offers a balanced feel, while Kirkland Signature Lakeridge is medium (5/10).
• Bounce: Helix has high bounce, which can be more responsive.
• Support: Helix provides targeted lumbar support, which is great for back sleepers.

For those who want a balanced feel and targeted lumbar support, Helix Midnight is an excellent choice. If you prefer a thicker comfort layer and a more traditional hybrid feel, Kirkland Signature Lakeridge is worth considering.

Kirkland Signature vs. Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is a versatile mattress offering three firmness levels: soft, medium, and firm. It has a 12″ thickness and provides moderate sinkage and moderate bounce.

Key Differences:

• Material: Both are hybrids, but Brooklyn Bedding offers more firmness options.
• Feel: Brooklyn Bedding provides three firmness levels, while Kirkland Signature Lakeridge is medium (5/10).
• Customization: Brooklyn Bedding allows you to choose your firmness level.
• Price: Brooklyn Bedding is generally more expensive but offers more customization.

If you want the flexibility to choose your firmness level, Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is a great option. However, if you’re looking for a budget-friendly hybrid with a consistent medium feel, Kirkland Signature Lakeridge is an excellent choice.

For more detailed comparisons, check out our Kirkland Signature Mattress Review.

Frequently Asked Questions about Kirkland Signature Mattresses

Who makes Kirkland’s signature mattress?

The Kirkland Signature mattresses are made by Stearns & Foster, a well-known name in the mattress industry. The Hope Bay model, in particular, is a popular choice. It’s a pillow-top, spring-and-foam hybrid mattress that combines luxurious comfort with sturdy support. You can find these mattresses exclusively at Costco.

Is there a difference between Kirkland and Kirkland Signature?

Yes, there is a difference. Kirkland is a brand associated with Kirkland’s Inc., which focuses on home decor and furniture. On the other hand, Kirkland Signature is a private label brand owned by Costco. Kirkland Signature offers a wide range of products, including the Stearns & Foster mattresses, known for their quality and value.

Are Stearns and Foster mattresses good?

Absolutely. Stearns & Foster has a long history of making premium beds. Their mattresses are often considered top-of-the-line and are strong contenders in the luxury mattress market. With features like cooling gel, pocketed coils, and high-quality materials, they offer exceptional comfort and support. If you’re looking for a luxury-quality mattress, Stearns & Foster is a brand worth considering.

Conclusion

In summary, the Kirkland Signature mattresses offer a remarkable blend of quality and value, thanks to the craftsmanship of Stearns & Foster. Available exclusively at Costco, these mattresses have become a popular choice for those seeking luxurious comfort without the hefty price tag.

Our mattress review revealed that the Kirkland Signature mattresses excel in several key areas, including support, comfort, and durability. With features like cooling gel, pocketed coils, and high-quality materials, they provide a top-notch sleeping experience. Whether you’re considering the Hope Bay or the Lakeridge model, you’re likely to find a mattress that meets your needs.

At Yawnder, we pride ourselves on providing expert evaluations and unbiased reviews to help you make the best purchasing decisions. If you’re in the market for a new mattress, the Kirkland Signature line is definitely worth a closer look.

For more information on our top mattress picks and detailed reviews, visit our mattress category page.

By following this guide, you’ll be well on your way to finding a mattress that offers both comfort and value. Happy sleeping!