Review context: Ben purchased a king-size Buffy comforter for the original 2018 review. Buffy later changed the Cloud’s construction; the firsthand observations below apply to the older sample.
Our verdict
The original Buffy comforter felt light, smooth and quiet in Ben’s test. After more than a week, he liked how easily it moved and found it less warm than a polyester comforter he compared it with, although he could still occasionally overheat. If you want a soft down-alternative comforter rather than a heavy, dense duvet, the current Cloud is worth considering—with the caveat that it is not the exact version tested.
Explore Buffy comforters. Yawnder may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.
What Ben found in the original test
Ben bought a king-size sample and described it as light, silky and not especially thick. After washing and using it for over a week, he found it soft and easy to move around under, without the noise some comforters make. A top sheet and the comforter were enough to keep him warm.
He felt it slept cooler than a polyester comforter he had used but noted that he could still overheat a little. That is an individual experience, not a guarantee that a current Cloud will feel cool for everyone.
Original sample vs. current Cloud
Buffy says it updated the Cloud’s quilting and fill technique in 2021. Its current Cloud page describes a TENCEL™ lyocell shell and recycled PET fill. Lyocell is a regenerated cellulose fiber made from wood pulp; it is not raw eucalyptus woven directly into fabric.
The original review described a different blend. Always check the label and the exact version when comparing materials, construction or care. Recycled content and certification claims should be evaluated for the specific component and product.
Is it warm enough?
Ben found the original sample warm enough with a top sheet, but comfort depends on room temperature, clothing and personal preference. The fill, weight and cover you choose all affect warmth. A smooth shell may feel cool initially without keeping every sleeper cool through the night.
Cloud vs. Breeze
| Model | Current material description | Consideration |
|---|---|---|
| Cloud | Lyocell shell with recycled PET fill | Buffy describes a fluffy down-alternative feel |
| Breeze | Lyocell shell and lyocell fill | Marketed for lighter warmth; care differs |
We reviewed the older Buffy comforter here, not today’s Breeze. See our separate Breeze review for its original test.
Care, price and returns
Buffy currently instructs Cloud owners to machine wash cold and dry on low or air fluff; the company gives different care instructions for Breeze. Follow your exact item’s label and use a machine large enough for the comforter. Dry it thoroughly.
The former coupon and try-before-you-buy details were historical. Check current price, shipping and return terms before ordering. A duvet cover can help keep the insert clean between washes.
Choosing and living with a Buffy comforter
Decide how much warmth you want. The older sample in Ben's test felt lighter than a polyester comforter he had used, but he still occasionally overheated. That is useful context, not a head-to-head test of the current Cloud and Breeze. Start with your bedroom temperature, the weight of your sheets and duvet cover, and whether a partner shares the bedding. If you are unsure, check the seller's current trial and return conditions before ordering.
Compare construction, not just a cooling label. Cloud and Breeze use different fill descriptions in the comparison above. A shell that feels smooth or cool to the touch may still retain warmth once layered on a bed. Look at the fill, construction and stated warmth level for the exact item you are buying, and remember that a heavy cover can change the feel of a lightweight insert.
Measure your cover and the bed. Bedding sizes are not perfectly standardized across brands. Compare the insert's actual width and length with your duvet cover, then consider how much fabric you want to hang over each side. If the cover has ties, check whether their placement matches the insert's loops. For partners who need different warmth levels, two individual covers are another option; see our two-duvet guide.
Plan for washing. The care instructions for the original sample are not automatically the instructions for a current version. Read the label for your specific comforter, allow enough room in the machine for water and detergent to circulate, and make sure the fill is fully dry before putting it back on the bed. A removable cover can be easier to wash between insert cleanings. Compare the total cost of the comforter, cover, shipping and any return charges.
Try one change at a time. If you already like the way your mattress feels but are too warm under a thick comforter, try a lighter cover or remove an extra blanket first. If you need more warmth, keep a separate washable layer nearby. Those simple adjustments can help you identify what you want from a replacement without assuming one comforter will suit everyone.
Frequently asked questions
Did Ben test the current Cloud?
He tested an older comforter in 2018. Buffy says the Cloud was updated in 2021.
Is the current Cloud washable?
Buffy currently says the Cloud is machine washable; follow the care label on your product.
Is it guaranteed to keep me cool?
No. Ben occasionally overheated under the older sample, and temperature comfort varies.
Does Cloud contain down?
The current Cloud page describes recycled PET fill, a down alternative.
