When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Products or services may be offered by an affiliated entity. Learn more.

Brooklinen Down Pillows – Are They Worth It?

Brooklinen Pillows Bring Affordability to Down Comfort 2
Brooklinen Down Pillows

Best down pillows for the money. Brooklinen always provides great quality.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

While Brooklinen down pillows are not necessarily unique in every aspect, they do offer some specific features and qualities that distinguish them from some competitors:

Multiple Firmness Options: Unlike many brands that only offer standard down pillows, Brooklinen provides three firmness options (plush, mid-plush, and firm) to cater to different preferences and sleeping styles. This allows for better customization and finding the pillow that suits your individual needs.

Ethical Sourcing: Brooklinen’s down pillows are certified by the Responsible Down Standard (RDS), ensuring animal welfare and responsible practices throughout the down and feather supply chain. This is important for consumers who value ethical sourcing and sustainability.

Competitive Price Point: Compared to some luxury down pillow brands, Brooklinen offers their pillows at a slightly more accessible price point, making them a good value for the quality.

Long Trial Period: With a 365-day trial period, Brooklinen allows you to test the pillow extensively before committing, which gives you peace of mind and flexibility.

Additional Features: While not unique, some other noteworthy features include:

    • 100% cotton sateen shell for a soft and smooth feel.
    • Double-stitched edges for durability.
    • Hypoallergenic down and feather fill for most sleepers.

However, it’s important to consider potential drawbacks:

    • Limited fill options: If you prefer down alternative or other fillings like latex, Brooklinen might not offer the variety you seek.
  • No organic cotton shell option: All their down pillows have a regular cotton sateen shell, not organic cotton like some competitors.
Brooklinen stays true to its mission by offering affordable, quality down pillows to the masses. I had the privilege of reviewing all three different down pillows, plush, mid-plus and firm. These pillows are stuffed with down sourced from the world-famous duck farms of Brome Lake Quebec, Canada and have a 500 thread count cotton shell. To get that picture of Brome Lake in your head, here’s a picture of the lake: brooklinen pillows When you stay at a high-end hotel, chances are you will be sleeping on a down or down alternative pillow. They are very versatile and extremely comfortable. People often don’t invest in them because of the cost. Pillows are finally getting the credit they deserve However it’s wrong to think of a pillow as just a mini mattress for your head.  Although most online beds will appeal to most sleepers, foam pillows will appeal to far less. That’s because with a pillow you really want to be able to sink in immediately and not have to wait for it to adjust. It also needs to breathe and sleep cool throughout the night. There are very few foam pillows on the market that do this. Down is just flat out softer and easier to adjust than foam so it often makes for a better pillow. Finally, these pillows from Brooklinen are much lighter than any foam pillows I have reviewed so if you switch positions at night or just want to have a good pillow fight, these are the pillows for you. Out of the three levels of firmness, I really liked the plush level of firmness. I sleep on my side and stomach so sometimes I want it flatter than normal but also want to be able to scrunch it up when I switch to my side. The other levels of firmness would probably best suited to back and side sleepers. The Brooklinen pillows are just as good a bargain as their sheets: pillow prices Compare these pillows to the Scandia Home down pillow prices below: scandia pillows It’s important to note that these pillows are made with duck down which at times be better than goose down. Most people will enjoy sleeping on down pillows so I always keep a set for guests that come to visit. I actually started my own pillow bar where they can choose their level of firmness. It’s a nice hospitality touch. And it’s to my advantage to have well-rested guests since they will be less cranky in the mornings! The Brooklinen pillows come in their own zip cases as seen below: brooklinen pillow Once again, Brooklinen comes through on price and quality. It’s refreshing to see all these new bedding disruptors come online. Everyone should be able to afford quality sleep products. Shop Brooklinen Disclosure: We aim to highlight products and services you might find interesting, and if you buy them, we may get a small share of the revenue.

Brooklinen Pillow Models and Prices

Down PillowPlush, mid-plush, or firm options. Hypoallergenic down and feather fill. 100% cotton sateen shell.Down & FeathersStandard/Queen/King$89
Down Alternative PillowPlush, mid-plush, or firm options. Hypoallergenic down alternative fill. 100% cotton sateen shell.Down AlternativeStandard/Queen/King$69
Luxury Linen PillowPlush, mid-plush, or firm options. 100% European flax linen shell. Down and feather fill.Down & FeathersStandard/Queen/King$139
Memory Foam PillowContoured memory foam designed for side and back sleepers.Memory FoamStandard/Queen/King$89
ClusterFill PillowPlush, down-like comfort with hypoallergenic synthetic fill. 100% cotton percale shell.Synthetic FillStandard/Queen/King$49
Latex PillowSupportive and breathable natural latex core. 100% cotton percale shell.LatexStandard/Queen/King$129
Kids PillowDesigned for smaller heads and necks. Available in plush or mid-plush.Down AlternativeStandard$39
Brooklinen Down Pillows

Best down pillows for the money. Brooklinen always provides great quality.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
Brooklinen Pillows

How Do Brooklinen Down Pillows Compare to the Competition?

Brooklinen’s down pillows are manufactured with a mix of down and feather fill, which set them apart from the many synthetic options flooding the market. These pillows are filled with a combination of ethically sourced Canadian down and feathers, promising both comfort and social responsibility. It’s worth noting that the exact blend varies across the three firmness levels Brooklinen offers: Plush, Mid-Plush, and Firm.

With the Plush pillows filled entirely with down, they offer a level of luxurious softness hard to match, mimicking the feel of a cloud. In contrast, the Firm pillows contain a higher percentage of feathers, delivering more support for those needing additional neck and head reinforcement during sleep. The Mid-Plush, which strikes a balance between softness and support, offers a blend of down and feathers that caters to the majority of sleepers.

When compared to other leading brands, Brooklinen’s down pillows continue to hold their own. Parachute, for example, another popular online brand, offers down pillows with similar eco-friendly and ethical sourcing standards. However, some users have reported that Parachute’s pillows might not provide the same longevity as Brooklinen, flattening more quickly over time.

In comparison to in-store brands like Pacific Coast and Hotel Collection, Brooklinen still stands strong. Pacific Coast’s down pillows, while competitively priced, might not provide the same hypoallergenic properties as Brooklinen, which employs a meticulous cleaning process for their down and feathers. Hotel Collection, meanwhile, is known for its luxurious feel, but its price point often goes beyond what Brooklinen charges, making the latter a more accessible choice for many.

Brooklinen also shines when it comes to customer experience. The company offers a generous 365-day return policy, something few competitors provide. It’s a bold statement of confidence in their product and a welcome assurance for consumers hesitant about buying pillows online.

However, like any product, Brooklinen’s down pillows are not without their drawbacks. Some users have reported that the pillows can emit a slight odor when new, although this typically dissipates after a few days. Also, despite the company’s best efforts to cater to all sleepers, certain individuals may find that even the Firm option does not offer enough support, particularly if they’re accustomed to memory foam or other solid-core pillows.

Brooklinen 2

Brooklinen Down Pillows FAQ

1. What types of down pillows does Brooklinen offer?

Brooklinen offers three types of down pillows to cater to different sleeper needs: Plush, Mid-Plush, and Firm. The Plush is filled entirely with down for a soft, cloud-like feel. The Mid-Plush is a balanced blend of down and feathers, while the Firm contains a higher percentage of feathers for added support.

2. How is the down in Brooklinen pillows sourced?

The down and feathers used in Brooklinen pillows are ethically sourced from Hutterite farms in Canada. The company’s commitment to responsible sourcing guarantees that the materials used are of high quality and are obtained in a way that respects the welfare of animals.

3. Are Brooklinen down pillows hypoallergenic?

Yes, Brooklinen down pillows are hypoallergenic. The down and feathers undergo a meticulous cleaning process that removes dust, dirt, and allergens, reducing the likelihood of allergic reactions.

4. How do Brooklinen down pillows compare with other brands?

When compared to other in-store and online brands, Brooklinen’s down pillows are recognized for their superior quality, comfort, and value. They stand out for their ethical sourcing practices and hypoallergenic properties. However, individual preferences and needs will ultimately determine the best choice.

5. What is Brooklinen’s return policy on down pillows?

Brooklinen offers a generous 365-day return policy on their down pillows. This means that customers have a full year from the date of purchase to decide whether or not the pillow is right for them.

6. What should I do if my new Brooklinen down pillow has an odor?

Some users have reported a slight odor from new Brooklinen down pillows. This is normal and typically dissipates after a few days. If the odor persists, Brooklinen recommends airing out the pillow in a well-ventilated area.

7. Are Brooklinen down pillows suitable for all sleep positions?

While Brooklinen offers three different firmness levels to cater to various sleep preferences, individual comfort can vary. The Plush is often recommended for stomach sleepers, the Mid-Plush for back sleepers, and the Firm for side sleepers. However, some people, particularly those accustomed to memory foam or other solid-core pillows, might find even the Firm option doesn’t provide enough support.

8. How do I care for my Brooklinen down pillow?

To prolong the life of your Brooklinen down pillow, the company recommends using a pillow protector and a pillowcase. These pillows should not be machine washed. Instead, spot clean or professionally clean them.

Remember that these answers provide general guidelines, and individual experiences may vary. It’s always a good idea to do your research and consider your specific needs when choosing a pillow.

Parachute Down Pillows

Comparing Brooklinen Down Pillows to Popular Online Brands:

Here’s a breakdown of how Brooklinen Down Pillows compare to other popular online brands:


FillDown & feather (3 firmness options)Down & feather (2 firmness options)Down alternative (soft & medium)**Down alternative (soft & medium)**Down alternative & Dunlop latex (3 firmness options)
Shell material100% cotton sateen100% long-staple cotton percale100% organic cotton sateen100% certified organic cotton percale100% organic cotton sateen
Price (Standard)$89$119$95$85$149
CertificationsOeko-Tex Standard 100, Responsible Down Standard (RDS)Oeko-Tex Standard 100, RDSOeko-Tex Standard 100STANDARD 100 by OEKO-TEX®, Responsible Down Standard (RDS)Oeko-Tex Standard 100, Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS)
Trial period365 days30 days180 days100 days1 year
Return policyFree returnsFree returnsFree returnsFree returnsFree returns

Pros of Brooklinen:

    • More firmness options: Offers plush, mid-plush, and firm down pillows.
    • Competitive price point: Slightly cheaper than Parachute and comparable to other brands.
    • Longer trial period: Provides an entire year to test the pillow.
    • Ethical sourcing: Certified by RDS for responsible down practices.

Cons of Brooklinen:

    • Limited fill options: Offers only down & feather filling, unlike some brands with latex or hybrid choices.
    • No organic cotton shell option: All down pillows have a cotton sateen shell, not organic cotton like some competitors.


Brooklinen Down Pillows offer a good balance of quality, comfort, and affordability. They stand out for their multiple firmness options, long trial period, and ethical sourcing practices. However, if you prefer organic cotton shells or other fill options like latex, you might consider other brands.

Brooklinen Stores

Brooklinen has 10 stores across the United States, with plans to expand further by the end of the year. Here’s a quick overview:

    • Locations:
        • New York:
            • Williamsburg (original store)
            • West Village
        • East Coast & Midwest:
            • Philadelphia
            • Chicago
            • Washington, D.C.
        • West Coast:
            • Los Angeles
            • San Francisco
            • Portland, Oregon
  • What you can find:
      • Wide selection of bedding, including sheets, duvet covers, blankets, pillows, and towels.
      • Loungewear and other apparel.
      • Opportunity to touch and feel the materials before purchasing.
    • Expert staff available to assist with product selection and answer questions.

More Brooklinen Products

Beyond their popular bedding sets and comforters, Brooklinen offers a wide variety of other cozy and stylish home goods including:

    • Bath: Indulge in luxurious bath towels, hand towels, washcloths, bathrobes, and bath mats, all made from 100% Turkish cotton for superior softness and absorbency.

      Image of Brooklinen bath towels
    • Loungewear: Relax in style with their loungewear collection for men and women, made from soft and sustainable fabrics like Tencel™ Modal and Supima® cotton.

      Image of Brooklinen loungewear for women
    • Throws and blankets: Add a touch of warmth and texture to your living space with their throws and blankets, available in a variety of materials and colors.

      Image of Brooklinen blankets
    • Sheets and bedding: They offer a variety of sheet sets, duvet covers, comforters, and pillowcases in different materials and thread counts to suit your preferences.

      Image of Brooklinen duvet covers
    • Kids’ bedding: Create a cozy and inviting sleep environment for your little ones with their kids’ bedding collection, featuring playful designs and soft, breathable fabrics.

      Image of Brooklinen kids' bedding
    • Travel essentials: Make your travels more comfortable with their selection of travel pillows, eye masks, and packing cubes.

    • Accessories: Find the perfect finishing touches for your home with their selection of decorative pillows, throws, and bedding shams.

      Image of Brooklinen decorative pillows

Whether you’re looking for a new duvet cover, a cozy throw blanket, or a luxurious bathrobe, Brooklinen has something for everyone. With their commitment to quality materials, ethical sourcing, and sustainable practices, you can feel good about shopping their products.

9 thoughts on “Brooklinen Down Pillows – Are They Worth It?”

  1. Hey again,
    I got the parachute pillow (no pillow cover yet) and the pillow sleeps a little warm. How would you compare the Brooklinen pillow and the parachute pillow in terms of heat retention? Is it a large difference? (I purchased a standard soft down pillow from parachute. It feels great and is very comfortable for a stomach sleeper, but it’s a little warm).

    • I mentioned not having the pillow case because I was thinking it might make the pillow feel cooler when I receive it. I wanted your thought on that as well. (Pillow case is from coming in from brooklinen. It is a classic percale 270 thread count, long staple cotton pillow case).

      • A percale weave will generally sleep cooler than a sateen. I wouldn’t be as concerned about the pillow case as the pillow in terms of heat retention so you should be just fine with this sheet.

  2. I purchased a Brookline pillow, but it compressed way to much. Pretty much flat. I like a thick, supportive, down/ feather pillow. I’m a side sleeper. Do you have any recommendations? Would Parachute be any better? Thanks


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Have Questions?

Text us at 858-232-5760 for assistance. We’re happy to help!