Our verdict
Honeydew’s curved side-sleeper pillows are worth considering if you want to adjust your pillow’s height and make room for your shoulder. In the original test, Ben found the Scrumptious sample thicker and more substantial than the lower-profile Essence. Neither shape will be right for every sleeper: loft, mattress firmness and shoulder width all change the fit.
Ben met the founders and received both pillows for review. Product details below distinguish those samples from today’s versions. Yawnder may earn a commission through our links.
See Honeydew pillows and current pricing · Check the Amazon listing
What we tested
Ben tested the curved Scrumptious and Essence pillows and compared their feel and shape in this video.
The samples arrived rolled and vacuum sealed. Both had shoulder cutouts and adjustable fill. Ben found the fill evenly cut and liked being able to remove some for a lower pillow. He received shaped pillowcases with the sample; what is included in a current order depends on the listing.
Scrumptious vs. Essence
In the samples Ben reviewed, the Scrumptious had a gusseted edge and a taller profile, while the Essence tapered more toward the edge. Broader shoulders may need more loft, but a softer mattress lets the shoulder sink farther, which can reduce the height needed.
Honeydew’s current FAQ describes a copper-based fill for Scrumptious and a gel-based fill for Essence, and says Essence is about one inch lower before adjustment. The older test predates those current details; it should not be read as a test of every current fill formulation. Neither material guarantees a particular sleep temperature.
How to choose the right loft
Start with your usual pillowcase and mattress. On your side, look for a comfortable, roughly neutral head position: if your head tilts up, remove a little fill; if it drops toward the mattress, add fill or try a thicker pillow. Make small changes and sleep on each adjustment before changing it again. Keep removed fill in a clean, sealed bag.
Curved pillows give the shoulder more room; a rectangular pillow may be easier if you switch positions frequently. Stomach sleepers generally need less height, while back sleepers often prefer a moderate loft. See our side-sleeper pillow guide for more options. A pillow is not a treatment for persistent neck pain.
Care and pillowcases
The original sample included zippered cases and an adjustable inner pillow. Honeydew says the pillow’s outer fabric cover can be washed after the fill is removed; the fill itself is not designed to be washed. Follow the care label for your particular model and case. A shaped case fits the curve, while the original reviewer found a standard case usable in a pinch.
Check whether a pillowcase is included with the specific bundle. Avoid putting the entire filled pillow in the washer based on a general product description.
Price, trial and alternatives
Prices in the original article are historical. Honeydew currently advertises a 60-night money-back guarantee and a three-year limited warranty, but eligibility, return costs and conditions can vary by seller and may change. Check the exact offer before ordering, including whether a case or extra fill costs more.
If you prefer adjustable fill in a rectangular shape, see our Coop pillow review. For a different, more resilient feel, consider the Purple Harmony; it is not adjustable in the same way. Compare fit and return terms rather than assuming either is cooler for everyone.
For local availability, call the Yawnder showroom before visiting; we cannot confirm these specific pillows are on display.
Common questions
Which is taller?
The Scrumptious sample was taller. The brand says the current Essence has a lower starting profile; both can be adjusted.
Can I wash the whole pillow?
Honeydew instructs customers to remove the fill before washing the cover. Check the label for your specific model.
Will it fix neck pain?
A well-fitting pillow may feel more comfortable, but the review does not establish that it treats pain. Consult a clinician about persistent or worsening symptoms.