Casper vs. Brooklinen Sheets: Top 5 Reasons to Choose in 2024

Casper vs. Brooklinen Sheets: Which is better for your sleep? If you’ve found yourself wondering this question, you’re in the right place. Here’s a quick answer:

• Brooklinen sheets are generally softer, lighter, and come in sateen and percale weaves.
• Casper sheets, made from Supima cotton, are crisper and warmer due to their percale weave.

Both brands offer high-quality bedding, but they have unique features that might suit different preferences and needs.

Casper’s sheets use two-ply thread at a 400-thread count with a percale weave. This makes them durable and crisp but less soft. They are great for those who prefer a cozier, warmer feel.

Brooklinen sheets use single-ply thread at a 300-thread count with options in both sateen and percale weaves. They are known for being incredibly soft, light, and hotel-like—ideal for hot sleepers who love that cool initial touch.

I’m Ben Trapskin, and I’ve spent years exploring the bedding industry to help people find perfect sleep solutions. With a background rooted in both personal experience and professional research, I’ve reviewed countless sheets, like Brooklinen and Casper, to ensure you get the comfy rest you deserve.

Materials and Weave

Casper vs. Brooklinen Sheets word roundup:

• Thuma Mattress
• how to find the best mattress reviews
• siena mattress reviews

Brooklinen Materials

Brooklinen sheets are made from long-staple cotton, which means they use longer strands of cotton fibers. This results in a softer and more durable fabric. The company’s Classic Cotton Sheets are crafted in Portugal, a country known for its high-quality textile production.

Brooklinen offers both percale and sateen weaves.

• Percale: This weave gives the sheets a crisp and airy feel, much like a freshly ironed dress shirt. It’s perfect for hot sleepers as it allows for better airflow.
• Sateen: This weave, on the other hand, has a smooth and lustrous finish. It feels more luxurious and tends to be warmer, making it ideal for colder climates.

Because Brooklinen uses long-staple cotton, their sheets are not only comfortable but also long-lasting. They resist pilling and maintain their softness over time.

Casper Materials

Casper sheets are made from Supima cotton, which is a type of extra-long staple cotton grown in California. Supima cotton is known for its superior softness, strength, and color retention. Casper’s sheets are then woven and crafted in India, where textile craftsmanship is highly regarded.

Casper primarily offers percale weave sheets.

• Percale: This weave is characterized by a simple one-over-one-under pattern, giving the sheets a crisp and cool feel. It’s less soft than sateen but highly breathable, making it a good choice for those who prefer a cooler sleeping environment.

One standout feature of Casper sheets is their organic certification. The cotton is grown without harmful chemicals, making it an eco-friendly option. The percale weave combined with Supima cotton makes Casper sheets durable and crisp, ideal for those who prefer a more structured feel to their bedding.

In summary, both Brooklinen and Casper offer high-quality materials, but they cater to different preferences:

• Brooklinen: Softer, lighter, and available in both percale and sateen weaves.
• Casper: Crisper, warmer, and made from organic Supima cotton in a percale weave.

Next, let’s explore how these materials translate to comfort and feel.

Comfort and Feel

Brooklinen Comfort

Brooklinen sheets excel in offering a soft, cool, and crisp feel, reminiscent of luxury hotel bedding. The long-staple cotton used in their Classic Cotton Sheets ensures a silky texture that gets softer with each wash.

• Crispness: The percale weave in Brooklinen sheets gives them a crisp, airy feel, much like a freshly ironed shirt. This makes them ideal for those who love slipping into cool sheets at night.
• Cooling: These sheets are lightweight and breathable, making them a great choice for hot sleepers. The percale weave allows for excellent airflow, helping you stay cool throughout the night.
• Softness: Over time, Brooklinen sheets become even softer, thanks to the long-staple cotton fibers. This improves the overall sleeping experience, providing a cozy yet luxurious feel.

Casper Comfort

Casper sheets, made from Supima cotton, offer a different kind of comfort. They are less soft and have a rougher texture compared to Brooklinen, but they still provide a crisp feel due to the percale weave.

• Crispness: The percale weave in Casper sheets gives them a structured, crisp feel. This is perfect for those who prefer a more custom and less “fluffy” bedding experience.
• Warmth: Unlike Brooklinen, Casper sheets tend to be warmer. This makes them suitable for those who run cold at night or live in cooler climates. The Supima cotton provides a heavier, more substantial feel.
• Softness: While not as soft as Brooklinen, Casper sheets offer a durable and sturdy texture. This can be appealing to those who prefer a more robust fabric.

In summary, the comfort and feel of Brooklinen and Casper sheets cater to different preferences:

• Brooklinen: Ideal for those who love soft, cool, and crisp sheets that feel like a luxury hotel bed.
• Casper: Better suited for sleepers who prefer a crisper, warmer, and more structured bedding experience.

Next, let’s dig into the durability and care of these sheets.

Durability and Care

Brooklinen Durability

Brooklinen sheets are known for their long-lasting quality, thanks to the use of long-staple cotton. The longer fibers result in fewer breakages and pilling, which means your sheets will stay in great shape for years.

Washing Instructions:

• Cold Wash: Toss your Brooklinen sheets in the washer with similar colors on a cold setting. This helps maintain the fabric’s integrity and color.
• Low Dry: When drying, use a low temperature to prevent shrinkage and preserve the fibers. Avoid over-drying by removing them just before they are completely dry.
• Iron on Warm: For a crisp presentation, you can iron them on a warm setting. However, it’s not necessary if you prefer a more relaxed look.
• Avoid Chlorine Bleach: Steer clear of chlorine bleach to keep the fabric looking its best.

Longevity and Maintenance:

• Durable: The long-staple cotton ensures that Brooklinen sheets are highly durable, often lasting several years with proper care.
• Low Maintenance: These sheets are relatively low-maintenance, making them a practical choice for busy households.

Casper Durability

Casper sheets are crafted from organic Supima cotton, which adds an edge in terms of eco-friendliness. They are also designed to be durable, although they may not match the longevity of Brooklinen’s long-staple cotton.

Washing Instructions:

• Warm Wash: Casper sheets can be washed on a warm setting, which helps in removing stains and maintaining hygiene.
• Normal Cycle: Feel free to use a normal cycle for washing, making the care routine straightforward.
• Tumble Dry Low: Dry your Casper sheets on a low tumble setting. This prevents excessive wear and tear and helps maintain the sheet’s texture.
• Non-Chlorine Bleach: Only use non-chlorine bleach when necessary to avoid damaging the fabric.

Longevity and Maintenance:

• Organic and Durable: While the use of organic Supima cotton adds an eco-friendly touch, these sheets are also quite durable. However, they might not have the same lifespan as Brooklinen’s long-staple cotton sheets.
• Simple Maintenance: The care routine is simple and user-friendly, making it easy to keep your sheets in good condition.

In summary, both Brooklinen and Casper sheets offer durable options with straightforward care instructions, but Brooklinen’s long-staple cotton may provide an edge in longevity.

Next, let’s look at the pricing and availability of these sheets.

Pricing and Availability

Brooklinen Pricing

Brooklinen sheets are on the premium side but still offer good value for the quality. A Queen set of Brooklinen’s Classic Core sheets is priced at $149. These sheets can be purchased directly from Brooklinen’s website, which often has sales and promotions.

Return Policy:

• 365-day return policy: Brooklinen offers a generous return window, allowing you to return your sheets within a year if you’re not satisfied.
• Return Fee: There is a $10 return fee for most products.

Casper Pricing

Casper sheets are slightly more affordable, with a Queen set priced at $140. You can buy Casper sheets through their official website or at major retailers like Target.

Return Policy:

• 100-day return policy: Casper provides a 100-day return period, which is shorter than Brooklinen’s but still ample time to decide if you like the sheets.
• Free Returns: Returns are free, making it a risk-free purchase if you’re unsure about the fit or feel.

In summary, while Brooklinen is slightly more expensive, it offers a longer return period. Casper, on the other hand, is more affordable and easily accessible through multiple purchase platforms like Target. Both brands provide solid return policies, making it easier for you to try them out and see which one suits you best.

Customer Reviews and Ratings

Brooklinen Reviews

Brooklinen sheets have garnered high praise from customers for their softness, durability, and cooling properties. Many users describe them as having a hotel-like feel, which adds a touch of luxury to their bedrooms. The long-staple cotton and sateen weave contribute to their smooth texture and longevity.

Pros:

• Soft and Comfortable: Customers love the soft, silky feel.
• Durable: Long-staple cotton ensures the sheets last a long time.
• Cooling: Ideal for hot sleepers due to their breathability.

Cons:

• Price: At $149 for a Queen set, they are on the pricier side.

One reviewer on Brooklinen’s website mentioned, “After just one wash, my sheets were soft and smooth yet still crispy giving me that luxury hotel bed feel.”

Casper Reviews

Casper sheets receive mixed ratings from customers. While some appreciate the crispness and warmth they provide, others find them less soft compared to Brooklinen. The use of Supima cotton and percale weave makes them more suitable for those who prefer a slightly rougher texture.

Pros:

• Warm and Crisp: Good for people who prefer a warmer sleep environment.
• Affordable: Slightly cheaper than Brooklinen sheets at $140 for a Queen set.
• Easily Accessible: Available at Target and online.

Cons:

• Less Soft: Some users find the texture too rough.
• Durability Concerns: Not as long-lasting as some other high-end brands.

A customer review on the Casper website noted, “The sheets are definitely less soft and more rough than the Brooklinen ones. My husband, however, likes the Casper ones because he runs cold and sometimes finds the cool crispness of the Brooklinen sheets too cold when first getting into bed.”

In summary, Brooklinen sheets are highly rated for their softness and cooling properties, making them ideal for hot sleepers. Casper sheets, on the other hand, are preferred by those who like a warmer, crisper feel. Both have their pros and cons, so your choice will depend on your personal comfort preferences.

Frequently Asked Questions about Casper vs. Brooklinen Sheets

Are there sheets better than Brooklinen?

Brooklinen sheets are highly praised for their softness, durability, and cooling properties, but whether they are the best depends on your personal preferences and needs. There are other high-quality options available, such as linen, bamboo, and Egyptian cotton sheets, each offering their own unique benefits.

Linen sheets are known for their breathability and durability, making them ideal for hot climates. Bamboo sheets are soft, eco-friendly, and moisture-wicking. Egyptian cotton sheets are luxurious and long-lasting but can be more expensive.

The best sheets for you will depend on what you prioritize in your bedding—be it comfort, sustainability, or luxury.

What sheets are better, Casper or Brooklinen?

Choosing between Casper and Brooklinen sheets comes down to personal comfort preferences and material choice.

Brooklinen sheets are made from long-staple cotton with a sateen weave, providing a soft, silky, and cooling feel. They are ideal for hot sleepers or those who prefer a hotel-like luxury at home.

Casper sheets use Supima cotton with a percale weave, resulting in a crisp, slightly rougher texture that some people find more comforting, especially if they run cold at night. They are also slightly more affordable and accessible through platforms like Target.

In summary, if you prefer a soft and cooling sheet, Brooklinen is the better choice. If you like a crisp and warm feel, Casper might be more suitable.

How long do Casper sheets last?

Casper sheets are generally durable but may not last as long as some other high-end brands. The longevity of Casper sheets typically ranges from 1 to 5 years, depending on how well they are cared for and how frequently they are used.

To maximize their lifespan, follow the care instructions: wash on a warm setting, avoid chlorine bleach, and tumble dry on low. Regular maintenance and proper washing can help extend their durability.

In general, while Casper sheets offer good quality, you might need to replace them sooner than some other premium options like Brooklinen, which are known for their long-lasting materials.

Conclusion

When it comes to choosing between Casper vs. Brooklinen Sheets, your decision ultimately hinges on your personal preferences for comfort, material, and budget.

Summary

Brooklinen sheets offer a soft, silky, and cooling experience, ideal for hot sleepers or those looking for a luxurious feel. Made from long-staple cotton with a sateen weave, these sheets are both durable and stylish. They come in a variety of colors and patterns, making them a versatile choice for any bedroom decor.

Casper sheets, on the other hand, are crafted from Supima cotton with a percale weave, giving them a crisp and slightly rougher texture. These sheets are great for those who prefer a cooler, more breathable fabric. They are also more affordable and easier to find, available both online and at retail locations.

Final Thoughts

In our expert evaluations, both Brooklinen and Casper offer high-quality sheets that cater to different sleep needs. Brooklinen excels in providing a luxurious, soft, and cooling experience, making it perfect for those who prioritize comfort and style. Casper, with its crisp and breathable percale weave, is an excellent choice for those who prefer a cooler sleep environment and a slightly more affordable option.

Yawnder’s Expert Evaluations

At Yawnder, we pride ourselves on providing unbiased, expert evaluations to help you find the perfect bedding. Our thorough testing and reviews ensure that you get the best advice for your sleep needs. Whether you’re looking for a luxurious feel or a crisp and cool sleep experience, our evaluations can guide you to the perfect choice.

Perfect Bedding

Investing in high-quality bedding is crucial for a good night’s sleep. With options like Brooklinen and Casper, you’re sure to find sheets that meet your needs and preferences. The right bedding can make a significant difference in your sleep quality and overall well-being.

For more expert reviews and recommendations on mattresses and bedding, visit our mattresses page.